PDA

View Full Version : Who is Captain Monkey D. Luffy's Favorite Crew Member?



lordHokage
March 13, 2008, 05:57 PM
Out of all the members of Straw Hat Pirates, in your humble opinion, which one of Captain Luffy’s Straw Hat Pirates would stand by or betray his ultimate goal for their personal agenda and please gives your reasons? :blink

Thank you for your posts. :wtf

In the efforts of not having to create another poll when a topic is so closely related, this poll thread has been modified to ask the question of "who is Luffy's Favorite Crew Member?" rather than "who is his most trusted crew member?" Zoro won the poll about Luffy's most trusted by a landslide. Here were the results of the original poll:
Name Votes Vote %
Zoro 107 90.68%
Nami 6 5.08%
Usopp 4 3.39%
Sanji 0 0%
Tony Tony Chopper 1 0.85%
Nico Robin 0 0%
Franky 0 0%
Brook 0 0%

This new question should hopefully allow for a greater diversity in opinion.

caquinha
March 13, 2008, 08:16 PM
My answer is "all of them". I think you need to add this option.
The Nakamas well being comes first!

Wale
March 14, 2008, 08:08 AM
After Thriller Bark.. i say it's Zoro! :)

belle_chan
March 14, 2008, 11:50 AM
i would say all of them but each time i read the manga and watch the anime, i had this feelings that somehow luffy is more intimate to zoro than the rest of the crews. i dunno how to explain but that was what i felt. it is not suprising since afterall zoro is his first crew member.

lordHokage
March 16, 2008, 08:38 PM
i would say all of them but each time i read the manga and watch the anime, i had this feelings that somehow luffy is more intimate to zoro than the rest of the crews. i dunno how to explain but that was what i felt. it is not suprising since afterall zoro is his first crew member.

Intimate is such a strong word but I do understand what you are trying to say and I agree with you all the way. :)

Tsukisama
March 16, 2008, 09:50 PM
Luffy trusts all of them, but I also feel he has the strongest bond with Zoro.

wing_gundam
March 16, 2008, 10:10 PM
I'd have to say at this point none of the members would betray him 'anymore'.

Franckie
March 17, 2008, 01:00 PM
All of Luffy's relationships with the various crewmembers are important, hence no one would do things such as become an obstacle without just cause. I'd say Luffy's relationships with Nami and Zoro though are the most important relationships out of all the crewmembers.

Tsukisama
March 17, 2008, 01:55 PM
Perhaps a better question is with whom Luffy has the weakest relationship on the crew. I would guess Robin. Luffy trusts her, but they don't seem particularly close.

Freakzin
March 17, 2008, 08:50 PM
i'd say brooke and franky, I think he doesn't "seem" close to Robin cause that's how Robin is, you can tell by how she looks at Luffy and laughs with him how close they actually are , it's more subtle i'd say,

kkck
March 17, 2008, 10:59 PM
I think zoro since he is the second mate and oldest companion. Also zoro is very loyal to him as we saw when he gave his life to save him from kumar or when he saved smoker only because he ordered him to do so. We also saw that luffy listens what zoro has to say even when it hurts, when they were discusinf the usupp issue.

igotthegoods
March 18, 2008, 12:21 AM
zoro is the obvious choice here.......he's luffy's first mate and right-hand man :)

however, i'm positive luffy wouldn't question the trust of any of his nakama ;)

IgnorantSage
March 18, 2008, 05:11 AM
Same answer as those previously mentioned.

Zoro is the least likely to betray Luffy although Usopp comes a very close second.

Considering their characters however, I wouldn't put it past any of the SHs to betray Luffy. They have their own dreams and if Luffy stands between them and their dreams then... well... they'd go against Luffy. That won't probably happen though since Luffy respects his nakama's dreams.

Mugiwara_no_Jack
March 18, 2008, 05:37 AM
Zoro ... definitively.

I can't remember Zoro once doubted Luffy ... NEVER.

(the others often doubt him by his actions ... Skypia for example)

by the way: after EL I think Robin is one of the trustfullest mates after Zoro.

kazuma_uzumaki
March 18, 2008, 06:51 PM
before sogeking, the weakest wouldv'e been ussop

Seriously he needs a smack in the head >_>

he DID sort of betray Luffy just for the merry go (no matter how important it was)

the obvious choice was zolo. He was willing to die and give up his dream to live till his battle with mihawk just for luffy during thriller bark

if you ask his most favorite?

brooke :3 sorta...
The musician he's been wanting since the first couple of chapters
plus brooke's pretty neat :3

lordHokage
March 19, 2008, 03:55 PM
I think if the opportunity arises, Usopp would not only betray Luffy but the crew as well for the Thousand Sunny. :blink

kazuma_uzumaki
March 19, 2008, 05:14 PM
I think if the opportunity arises, Usopp would not only betray Luffy but the crew as well for the Thousand Sunny. :blink
nah. Ussop had a special connection with the merry go
it was given by kaya(thats her name right)
and plus he had to repair all the crap so he had spiritually bonded with it while with the sunny, not so much since they have frankie

Anyarel
March 19, 2008, 05:24 PM
Well, I'm gonna answer the same thing as everyone but I hesitated a little between him and Nami.
But I think Zoro is the most trusted, then comes Nami. And then all the others. ^^

Superman
March 19, 2008, 06:42 PM
This is a weird and a useless threat.
I mean, its a nice idea and everything nothing personal i dont want to offense somebody but everybody know it is Zoro so why disscusion threat everybody agree
the people which don´t agree maybe did`t read the manga from the start or something like that.....:oh

Tsukisama
March 19, 2008, 07:02 PM
^ I agree that this topic is not going to breed much discussion as is, since almost everyone agrees that Zoro is the most trusted/has the strongest with Luffy. That is why I think that we should also make this topic about the least trusted member/who has the weakest bond with Luffy.

I trust Robin, and she does have a bond with Luffy, but her reserved, aloof personality I think just lends itself to having the weakest bond. All of the other characters engage with him more, and thus they seem closer. Also, although she has certainly become a welcome member of the crew now, Robin is the only member of the crew that Luffy did not seek out. Robin had to convince Luffy to let her join as a nakama. It may be rather irrelevant aat this point, but it still is true and is something to consider. (I love Robin, and she is my favorite nakama, especially since her personality is most like mine; so, it's not as though I dislike her or anything. I just think her bond with Luffy is weakest of the Nakama, barring Brooke obviously for his short tenure.)

Superman
March 20, 2008, 07:42 AM
Yeah i like Robin too and her ability, she just don`t fight enough but what can we say about it........ shes a lady.:D
Lets say she is equal in physical strenght with sanji + her ability she could handle Zoro and luffy with ease.
Ok Luffy can stretch and poke her in the eye if hes caught :D but whatever.
For example she can throw Luffy in the water and if no water is there she hold him tight and kill him with a knive or other sharp things.
In the case of Zoro there is no big difference.
What i forgot and the most peaple too that she can let things and people fly!!!!!
We saw that in wiskey peak ( dunno if the name is right ) where she first appear on the strawhats ship and gave them a special log port directly to arabasta.
She let Luffys hat and even sanji and usopp fly.
Don`t underestimate this abilitys its only a bummer that she isn`t so strong like sanji.

Sorry its so off topic but luffy trust her and she trust luffy.
In the end there is only to say that everyone of the strawhat would sacrifice themselves to save eachother and everyone can trust everyone.
But the most trusted is like in the most posts once again zoro.


Instead of apologizing for the Off-Topic isn't better to avoid doing it ;)

Is that a trick question :p:p joking

marte1980
March 20, 2008, 02:07 PM
if you ask his most favorite?
brooke :3 sorta...
The musician he's been wanting since the first couple of chapters
plus brooke's pretty neat :3
His favourite? The favourite of whom? Luffy's favourite crew member?
I don't think that Luffy has a favourite crew member, but, if there's one, it's Zoro for sure.
[hr]

I think if the opportunity arises, Usopp would not only betray Luffy but the crew as well for the Thousand Sunny. :blink
Usopp, like any other member of the crew, would never betray his companions. Usopp never betrayed the crew, he didn't want to abandon the Going Merry so he decided to fight Luffy for it and leave the crew. A stupid decision, of course, but that cannot be considered betrayal. If he had stolen the ship from them, that would've been betrayal. Actually he went nearer to betrayal when he tied Zoro to the ship when they arrived at Nami's island and left him tied up which led him to get caught by the fishmen. That was treated by Oda as something irrelevant, but IMO that was the worst thing that Usopp has ever done. But then he went and tryied to help him, so no real problem.

lordHokage
March 20, 2008, 06:52 PM
Straw Hat Pirates don’t operate like other pirates in One Piece. What Usopp did in Zoro’s eyes was mutiny, he would have walk the plank if Zoro had his way. :blink

kazuma_uzumaki
March 20, 2008, 10:55 PM
Actually he went nearer to betrayal when he tied Zoro to the ship when they arrived at Nami's island and left him tied up which led him to get caught by the fishmen.

not really. He only tied him up so zoro wouldnt do something stupid and get killed
ussop was still a bit of a weakling so it was mere instinct that made him fled

marte1980
March 21, 2008, 07:05 AM
not really. He only tied him up so zoro wouldnt do something stupid and get killed
ussop was still a bit of a weakling so it was mere instinct that made him fled
Only? That's actually betrayal! To flee leaving your comrades in danger is betrayal! He tied him up so that he wouldn't do something stupid, that's right, but that's not the problem. Read more carefully what I wrote! The problem is that he abandoned him in that condition and let the fishmen take Zoro. I repeat, to flee leaving your comrades in danger is betrayal!
Anyway, as I've already said, Usopp then went to try and help him, so no big problem in the end.
It's like on the Puffing Tom, when Sanji and Franky decided to help Robin. If Usopp had really decided to not help Robin, that would have been betrayal.
Instead, fighting the captain head on for something that you consider right isn't betrayal, not even Zoro said that Usopp betrayed them. Zoro said that After having lost the match, if he wanted to come back, he should have begged for it and that's obvious.

lordHokage
March 24, 2008, 07:52 PM
Usopp wouldn't a true team player during the Arlong arc. He did betrayed Zoro and he acted like he was the true captain of Straw Hat Crew when Lieutenant Fullbody, The Iron Fist asked who is your captain (http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/43/05/ )? :blink

DRAGON-PEIN-SAMA
March 26, 2008, 03:26 PM
Zoro is more like the vice captain of the crew, and what he says counts more than any1 else's, just like when he was the only 1 to disagree with usopp coming back to the crew, so yes hes the most strusted and second in command.

alias85
April 26, 2008, 04:47 PM
why didn't anyone vote for sanji :(
he offered to make the ultimate sacrifice for luffy AND zoro, but zoro knocked him out and took it himself. give sanji some credit guys!

waldo
April 26, 2008, 06:05 PM
why didn't anyone vote for sanji :(
he offered to make the ultimate sacrifice for luffy AND zoro, but zoro knocked him out and took it himself. give sanji some credit guys!

this act of sacrifice only shows how deep the Mugiwara's bonds are...

everyone can be truisted coz actually, not only sanji but anyone in the crew is willing to sacrifice on that situation...

no one will betray the crew...

Zoro is the secondmate so he is like a vice-president next to Bush in command... (and this is my obvious answer to the poll)

but everyone gets the same treatment/respect in Strawhats coz everyone has the same level of respect for each other...

(Luffy who is captain is always beaten down by Nami hehehe while no one in Whitebeard's crew will punch their captain hehehe or any other crew)

lelouch
April 27, 2008, 01:24 AM
Usopp is Luffy's best friend, whilst Zoro is First mate and Nami is Navigator.
Most trusted..hmm I'd say Nami, though Zoro would take command if Luffy went missing.

admirenkiwi
April 27, 2008, 04:29 AM
i think the one that would take command woulda been robin...shes smartest
the most trusted HAS to be zoro though.
his first comrad, very first friend, very first trusted and loyal mate.
but this is a hard question :amuse

neomaster121
April 27, 2008, 06:32 AM
It's a mistake to say robin would be in charge if luffy wasn't around

Zoro is really the more serious normal swordfighting version of luffy so the crew see him has the second captain when their in danger and luffy's not around.

luffy knows this and thats why Luffy would trust Zoro to protect the crew while he were to be gone

admirenkiwi
April 27, 2008, 06:56 AM
well, who knows
luffy didnt actually say it was zoro he trust the most or let be in charge

and whos to say robin is a mistake? just because she hasnt been on the ship as long as the others, doesnt mean she has knowledge of most things thats happened.

all of the crewmates play an important role. thats why i said the question was hard. there really isnt an answer. besides knowing that it has to be zoro luffy trust the most "because" he was the first to be luffy's friend and board his ship.

lordHokage
April 27, 2008, 07:41 AM
Zoro is more like the vice captain of the crew, and what he says counts more than any1 else's, just like when he was the only 1 to disagree with usopp coming back to the crew, so yes hes the most strusted and second in command.



It's a mistake to say robin would be in charge if luffy wasn't around

Zoro is really the more serious normal swordfighting version of luffy so the crew see him has the second captain when their in danger and luffy's not around.

luffy knows this and thats why Luffy would trust Zoro to protect the crew while he were to be gone


Well said. Zoro's opinion takes precedence over all matters. Zoro trust Robin because Luffy trust her but I don't think he really trust her. :blink



why didn't anyone vote for sanji :(
he offered to make the ultimate sacrifice for luffy AND zoro, but zoro knocked him out and took it himself. give sanji some credit guys!


The reason why Zoro knocked Sanji out because he was trying to talked him out of it. Sanji would sacrifice his lifetime goals for Nami and Robin but not Luffy. :blink

Navid.
April 27, 2008, 11:44 AM
Zoro and Nami for me are the ones that stand out, while every other crew member is a very close and trusted friend of Luffy's... Zoro and Nami don't feel like they are friends, they feel more like his brother and sister in the way they interact with him.

And that for me sets them apart from the rest.

endless_dream
May 05, 2008, 07:48 AM
If I there were two choices my guess would be Nami and Zoro but I would say Nami is the most trusted crew member because Luffy would always ask her to look after his strawhat if he ever gets into battles that most likely do damage to his hat ( Like the arlong arc, skypiea arc and the first fight in the second movie, etc)

Anime Head 101
May 05, 2008, 05:14 PM
If I there were two choices my guess would be Nami and Zoro but I would say Nami is the most trusted crew member because Luffy would always ask her to look after his strawhat if he ever gets into battles that most likely do damage to his hat ( Like the arlong arc, skypiea arc and the first fight in the second movie, etc)

He only asks Nami cause all the other crewmembers are fighting along side of him most of the time.

Dice
May 06, 2008, 05:51 AM
And in the Arlong arc there also was another reason. He wanted to show her that he trusts her despite being betrayed by her and that they are really nakama.

weixiaobao
May 12, 2008, 11:36 AM
the answer is quite obvious zolo (first mate), sanji (food), nami (the brain of operation)...

Lohnt
May 13, 2008, 07:27 AM
The reason why Zoro knocked Sanji out because he was trying to talked him out of it. Sanji would sacrifice his lifetime goals for Nami and Robin but not Luffy. :blink

I think you misunderstood, Sanji wanted to sacrifice himself for Luffy & Zoro not for Nami and Robin in that situation. Zoro knocked him out because it was not Sanji's place to sacrifice himself. The duty of keeping the captain alive falls on the second in command directly, and then the rest of the crew.

If Zoro was not there, Sanji could have sacrificed himself, but there is an order to who's worth is worth more alive and dead. Sanji is worth more alive as a cook to the crew, but Zoro is worth more dead to the world government. If Kuma attacked Sanji, the WG would have been pissed, but not satisfied, whereas Zoro has been a thorn in the WG's side longer than Luffy and as such is worth more to them dead/captured. The WG does not think Sanji's worth is anything more than "food" right now, they don't know how much Luffy values him, and that he wouldn't have another cook.. (then again, I don't think Luffy would care if he had another cook..)

lordHokage
May 13, 2008, 08:10 AM
I think you misunderstood, Sanji wanted to sacrifice himself for Luffy & Zoro not for Nami and Robin in that situation. Zoro knocked him out because it was not Sanji's place to sacrifice himself. The duty of keeping the captain alive falls on the second in command directly, and then the rest of the crew.

If Zoro was not there, Sanji could have sacrificed himself, but there is an order to who's worth is worth more alive and dead. Sanji is worth more alive as a cook to the crew, but Zoro is worth more dead to the world government. If Kuma attacked Sanji, the WG would have been pissed, but not satisfied, whereas Zoro has been a thorn in the WG's side longer than Luffy and as such is worth more to them dead/captured. The WG does not think Sanji's worth is anything more than "food" right now, they don't know how much Luffy values him, and that he wouldn't have another cook.. (then again, I don't think Luffy would care if he had another cook..)


You contradict yourself. Zoro is irreplaceable to Luffy, Sanji is not. :p

omni-giri
May 15, 2008, 10:58 PM
RORONOA!!!! <3 gatta love him

KnuckleheadedNinja
May 16, 2008, 03:56 PM
i picked zoro because he was his first crew member. Also he was willing to give up his dream and life for luffy goal at Thriller park.

jeffhmwong
May 25, 2008, 09:13 AM
No doubt its Zoro.

It can be seen in many situations where, Luffy request zoro to do important task.

Example :
Saving Smooker in the casino
Slicing the Ocean train into 2.
Breaking the cage and freeing Hatchi

Zoro never once doubt Luffy.

Wale
May 25, 2008, 07:52 PM
Zoro is the most responsible guy from the SH crew. Luffy can really any time count on him and trust him.

kaizokumarcee
May 25, 2008, 08:27 PM
I don't think having a "most trusted crew member" even occurs to Luffy's mind. He thinks all of them as equal nakama.

lordHokage
May 27, 2008, 12:29 PM
I don't think having a "most trusted crew member" even occurs to Luffy's mind. He thinks all of them as equal nakama.


I don't think so. Luffy trust all of them, he has to, he is the captain but Zoro stands out. :blink

MonkeyD.ODZ
July 02, 2008, 11:44 PM
I think most of us think that Zoro and after I vote , it's true. He's the first one who join the crew, the one as " fool" as the captain and with his swordman 's soul he's the one is trusted. Of course , Luffy trust another nakama too.

c0nflikt
July 03, 2008, 02:48 PM
Perhaps a better question is with whom Luffy has the weakest relationship on the crew. I would guess Robin. Luffy trusts her, but they don't seem particularly close.


I'd disagree with this after enies lobby she is very loyal to luffy and and is willing to do whatever luffy wants and is always second to agree with zoro who is always after luffy's best interests.

But i'd say zoro being first mate and this even being mentioned by another pirate he has the most trust and hes also the most loyal.

JC123
July 03, 2008, 06:39 PM
Zoro - never doubts the captain's words and makes the hard decisions

Nami - makes the lives on the open seas for the SHs a cake walk with her navigation skills

Sanji - cooks like there's no tomorrow

Usopp - Long Range expert who fights for Luffy. (Remember the Arabasta fight for details)

Chopper - heals the SHs with his knowledge and plays with Luffy and Usopp

Robin - Quiet reserved beauty, studies the ancient digs and finds info on the enemies of the SHs (I'm putting her as a scout type person)

Brooke- Musician. Chicks dig the musician. :p

Franky - Repairs the ship
-------------------------------------------------------------

To me, each of them are trusted for a different reason. Even though Chopper is the youngest, he fights harder than Usopp and gets the lowest bounty.

Although Usopp is weak, his will is about as strong as Luffy or even Zoro's and his sharpshooting destroys everything

Although Robin is reserved, she can find info that other SHs (other than Nami or Usopp) may miss.

Again, each are trusted and they all have a strength. As Luffy said in the Arlong arc, they compliment him in things he can not do himself.

So in my opinion, I can't answer the pole. He trusts them the same no matter what the circumstances.

Tsukisama
July 05, 2008, 02:03 PM
^ I agree with the many people who think that Luffy trust each of his nakama equally at the current point in the story. As such, this topic probably is not going to see much activity. Perhaps it would be best if this topic asked "who is Captain Monkey D. Luffy's Favorite Crew Member?" Although I know he likes all of them, one could speculate about which one he likes best more so than whom he trusts the most.
[hr]

I'd disagree with this after enies lobby she is very loyal to luffy and and is willing to do whatever luffy wants and is always second to agree with zoro who is always after luffy's best interests.

But i'd say zoro being first mate and this even being mentioned by another pirate he has the most trust and hes also the most loyal.

I agree that now Robin is more trusted, but I was looking more at each crew member's overall trust by Luffy (as in from their beginning as a nakama to the present). Of each of the crew members, she was definitely the least trusted originally IMO, and it would seem logical that it would take a little longer for her to gain Luffy's confidence, but yeah, at this point in the story, I would say Luffy trusts her as much as everyone else.

kkck
July 05, 2008, 03:31 PM
^ I agree with the many people who think that Luffy trust each of his nakama equally at the current point in the story. As such, this topic probably is not going to see much activity. Perhaps it would be best if this topic asked "who is Captain Monkey D. Luffy's Favorite Crew Member?" Although I know he likes all of them, one could speculate about which one he likes best more so than whom he trusts the most.
<hr noshade size="1">



My vote went to zoro but If the thread was about luffy's favorite crewmember then I would go for brook.

Tsukisama
July 05, 2008, 09:00 PM
I have changed the thread title and made a new poll for this. :hbunny

In case anyone could not tell, Zoro won the last poll question (Who is Luffy's most trusted nakama) by a landslide. Here were the results:

Name Votes Vote %
Zoro 107 90.68%
Nami 6 5.08%
Usopp 4 3.39%
Sanji 0 0%
Tony Tony Chopper 1 0.85%
Nico Robin 0 0%
Franky 0 0%
Brook 0 0%

Yabe
July 05, 2008, 11:13 PM
I was so reluctant between Usopp and Brooke, I had to choose Usopp because he has been at Luffy's side in settling the idea of every piraty parties, sharing his wits and passions about being pirates, and yeah he's been with Luffy long before Brooke. I think Luffy has got such different reasons for liking each of his crews, and they're not comparable; but seeing the jovial, fun-loving character of Luffy is so prominent, I must say I think he secretly favors his entertainment buddy Usopp the most. It also obviously showed he's hurt a lot when he had to fight with Usopp about Mary.

Akainu
July 06, 2008, 06:37 AM
I think his favorite highly depends on which situation he is in ... if he's hungra its Sanji, if he's sick it's Chopper and so on, thus I don't think he's got an overall favorite, but as he is eating almost always (reminds me of Metallicas Lars Ulrich *eg*) I'm voting for Sanji this time.

Raysen_ht
July 06, 2008, 06:54 AM
I think we should leave the thread as it was, and start a new one with this favourite question...
People might vote for Zoro without realising that the question changed...

I voted for Nami, because i think luffi knows she is the one who will allow him to get to the end of GL in the most direct way
(of course the others help also, but her dream and his are the closest ones)

bittman
July 06, 2008, 07:08 AM
I voted for Usopp as 'favourite' because it implies more joy than trust or even those he has the strongest bonds with (Nami). Usopp has always brought a smile to Luffy's face and they get on better socially than many other Strawhats. Though there was the whole fight thing, that's what happens.

If the poll was still trusted, I would have joined the sheep and voted Zoro.

kkck
July 06, 2008, 10:00 AM
I voted for brook because he is a skeleton and luffy showed many times during th manga that a musician was more important to him than many other more important positions.

The Adamant Dragon
July 07, 2008, 04:20 PM
Nice thread Lord hokage

Luffy is the only captain I've seen so far who doesn't think of his crew member as underlings or mear followers but really consider as friends more than anything else... But that said, we all have a friend who's opinion matter the most and we think that stands out of the pack. And Luffy's case wouldn't be different...

For me I picked Zoro, not just because he's his first crew member and first Mate, But because he's the only one who can counter Luffy's decisions and put him in his place when he needs to ( without tasting the Aftermath of Gomo-Gomo lol ). And more importantly he knows more than anyone when to shut-up when Captain D. Luffy speaks seriously.

Even if luffy is a kind captain, I like the fact that he can be authoritarian to his crew when its needed. Like the time he fought against Ussop to decide who would take blue-Marry. That fight was used to remind his crew members that '' Hey! I'm the captain Here !! '', Everyone contasted that fight decision... expect Zoro who told reminded them that luffy is their captain and they needed to respect his decision and let Ussop fight him. He's spent more than the others his time with luffy and thus know him better...

For the influence he's got on the ship, Zoro would be the perfect choice.

Raysen_ht
July 07, 2008, 04:33 PM
@The Adamant Dragon
Sorry if i got it wrong, but, the justification u gave, made me think that u still voted for the most trusted member, without realising that that poll has ended and a new question/poll started... the new thing is who is the favourite member!!

I said before that this could happen, that the poll shouldnt have changed, and a new thread should have been created with the new question to avoid confusion... but i guess it was ignored... :notrust

The Adamant Dragon
July 07, 2008, 04:47 PM
@ Raysen-Kun
My post reffers to the latter '' who's luffy's favorite crew member ''. But it can easily reffer to both of the subjects though. But yeah, they should create a new thread or Update the first post of the thread and indicate that there's two queston in thread. 'Cause one can easily be mistaken.

I have edit the first post to clarify the change.

Dice
July 07, 2008, 05:31 PM
Mhhh my vote isn't included: I'd like to vote for the refridgerator XD

But I guess it's like Akainu said: it depends on the situation. Altogether I don't think he has a favourite crew member which he would prefer. But since this is a poll and I want to vote I'll vote chopper. For two reasons:
He doesn't have any votes yet and he got fur...

lordHokage
July 09, 2008, 07:09 AM
Who is Captain Monkey D. Luffy's favorite crew member? Zoro all the way. :p

sharingan_kakashi
July 09, 2008, 11:22 PM
Zoro? maybe But i remember a scene where Luffy was chasing Chopper around to be his Nakama ( ... or maybe he wanted to eat him O.o)

kuriorisu
July 19, 2008, 03:13 PM
Definately going to be Nami, First person to wear Luffy's precious hat. and if I remember correctly many other times.

danielkoburger
July 20, 2008, 05:24 PM
Ofcourse the first obvious choice would be Zoro.
Just because he is the first crewmember and nakama and the incident on thriller.

The tendency for least in loyalty would of course be usop.
The merry chps. were defenite enough.

But if you take the question really tight you have to come to the conclusion that now nobody would "betray" him because they all know that he would fight the strongest to have their dream come true. They all see in him the one who connects all their dreams. And he is the one who took them into the crew because of their way they pursue their dreams.

Anyway i don't think the quesiton is very reasonable because the chances of such an occasion are towards zero. This because luffy would never stand in their way when it comes to pursuing their dream. Therefore it would never be a betraying but more a departing from the crew in joyfulness.

:fangirl
:)

lordHokage
July 20, 2008, 05:56 PM
But if you take the question really tight you have to come to the conclusion that now nobody would "betray" him because they all know that he would fight the strongest to have their dream come true. :)


If the opportunity is available, someone definitely betray Captain Luffy for their sole purpose. :D

Yabe
July 21, 2008, 01:51 AM
Ofcourse the first obvious choice would be Zoro.
Just because he is the first crewmember and nakama and the incident on thriller.

The tendency for least in loyalty would of course be usop.
The merry chps. were defenite enough.

But if you take the question really tight you have to come to the conclusion that now nobody would "betray" him because they all know that he would fight the strongest to have their dream come true. They all see in him the one who connects all their dreams. And he is the one who took them into the crew because of their way they pursue their dreams.

Anyway i don't think the quesiton is very reasonable because the chances of such an occasion are towards zero. This because luffy would never stand in their way when it comes to pursuing their dream. Therefore it would never be a betraying but more a departing from the crew in joyfulness.

:fangirl
:)

Huh? Dude, I think we're talking about Luffy's most favourite crew here (the vote on the most trust crew was already concluded).

Do you care to edit your post with your opinion on the current topic?

dsr
July 21, 2008, 02:18 AM
Chopper, just because he's uber-cute and he's the one who cures Luffy a looooot of times.

Superman
July 21, 2008, 03:02 AM
Who is his favorit hmm?
Well, everybody is his favorit.
He appreciate and love every single one of his nakamas the same.
They are his family, his brothers and sisters and he would do everything for them.

Where is the option "All"?;)
Even if the thread is called Favorite CREW MEMBER, i miss the option "All".
Soooooo....i didnt vote for anybody because his love for them is all the same.

Z Near
August 20, 2008, 08:46 AM
Of course you can't say who 's Luffy favourite , because he like them all .
Even so , I vote for Zorro .
He's my favourite One piece character . The first crew Luffy had . Just see Zorro at the end of Thriller Bark Arc making him worth to be choosen .

Black Hawk
August 20, 2008, 11:09 AM
No i think is Lysop, cause about the Story about Yasoop and Shanks. Shanks took Yassop with him, to travel around the sea, to get the best sniper.
And Ruffy whos favorit and best friend Shanks, do the same Way. But Ruffy meet also Yassop befor. That is a big strap of friendship by this two.

paradoxe
August 20, 2008, 08:52 PM
Best friends - Usopp
Most trusted - Zoro
Most precious - Nami (almost to the point of being a love interest..although obviously Luffy doesn't realize it. And yes I know Oda has said that they are all in love with adventure..but I mean who wouldn't agree that they would be a cute couple? :P )

Stop
August 20, 2008, 09:52 PM
Best friends - Usopp
Most trusted - Zoro
Most precious - Nami (almost to the point of being a love interest..although obviously Luffy doesn't realize it. And yes I know Oda has said that they are all in love with adventure..but I mean who wouldn't agree that they would be a cute couple? :P )

I agree and yeah they would make a nice couple

toxun
August 21, 2008, 12:32 AM
There's no doubt if you check this out http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/457/12/ . Altough uncouncious definitly the one who come in mind of him first is Sanji who give him favourite thing (meat). I used this because what is inside Oz is Luffy shadow. It's no other name. Another poster is giving their mind according to them, but that pictures shows what really is inside Luffy sub-concious mind.

BlackHair
August 22, 2008, 01:14 PM
Seriously, I wasn't going to post in this thread, since it seemed to be idiotic to discuss over such thing, but well.. Im totally bored, since the OP section of this forum is almost dried out xD

Imo Luffy don't have a specific member as his favourite. He treasure them all equally.
btw a Mod should add "all equal" or sth to the poll.

Within the crew, Zoro has a position as of 1-mate, but that doesn't concern the thread topic.

neomaster121
August 23, 2008, 11:13 AM
Luffy looked extremely stressed more stressed for a crew mate i've seen in a super long time
its has to be Zoro his most favorite crew member

descendant
August 24, 2008, 06:28 AM
Imo Luffy don't have a specific member as his favourite. He treasure them all equally.
btw a Mod should add "all equal" or sth to the poll.


AGREED!! Luffy cares for all of his nakama and there's no favorite in particular

oh btw in the sbs of one piece volume 49, oda confirmed that robin started calling the other straw hats by their name after enies lobby incident. is this true? i didn't noticed it, has anyone noticed this?

Tsukisama
August 24, 2008, 12:29 PM
Imo Luffy don't have a specific member as his favourite. He treasure them all equally.
btw a Mod should add "all equal" or sth to the poll.

There is a specific reason why "all" is not an option, and that is because it would defeat the purpose of this thread. Just like with the original topic of this thread (whom does Luffy trust the most), Luffy obviously trusts and likes everyone in his crew or else they would not be his nakama, but the thread starter wanted to see if people felt that Luffy might trust/like a little more in their opinion for whatever reason.

Thus, the poll will continue to exclude the "all/everyone" option. If you don't feel that Luffy has any sort of favorite at all (which he would if he were a real person, because psychologically humans have scales on which they base things and it is extremely difficult and unlikely to completely like a group 100% equally), then feel free to post that and just not cast a vote in the poll.

Natsu Dragonil
August 24, 2008, 04:44 PM
well imo luffy has for different situation diffirent precious nakamas.i personally think it is nami cause she is the one that luffy did a promise to let her always be happy.for zorro i think he is the one who understand luffys feelings and accepts him as a leader the most.