PDA

View Full Version : Review sahugani's One Piece Review 497



sahugani
April 20, 2008, 09:24 PM
Sahugani’s One Piece Review 497

http://img258.imageshack.us/img258/458/gurrenpiecebyannouncergav3.png (http://announcerguy.deviantart.com/art/GURREN-PIECE-82546567)
the awesomeness is overwhelming

Yo!!! Once again I’m back to single chapter reviews (but this week there was quite a bit to say so it’s still a doozy even by my standards). As I’ve said before, I’ll try to maintain these weekly and not let them get out of hand, which should be easier without my Bleach reviews but there are still no guarantees. In general, my policy is that if I don’t get the review done by Tuesday at midnight PST (GMT -8), I hold off and make a multi review the following weekend. Anyways, lets just get down to it. The pics in this review come from the Binktopia scanlation and one frame is from Null’s scanlation of 319. The title pic is yet another stellar artwork from AnnouncerGuy (http://announcerguy.deviantart.com/) over at DeviantArt so be sure to visit her gallery.

let me warn you guys that I think this is the longest single chapter review I think I’ve ever done


KABUKI!!!

http://img258.imageshack.us/img258/8510/1amp3.png
we need a Naruto omake crossover with Kumadori and Jiraya doing kabuki

Well we return to the story of the CP9 escaping their former employers and trying to save Lucci’s life. They are still hanging out in Saint Poplar since when you have a person that badly injured, moving from island to island is not smart (especially when the only method they can afford risks being hit by the sea train). As it is still raining, I think it is safe to say that the city may very well be a city of perpetual rain similar to how Enies Lobby was an island of perpetual sunlight. The entire chain of islands in the area each seem to have weather patterns that are unique even for the Grand Line since in addition to the aforementioned two islands, Water 7 has its aqua laguna. It makes me wonder what types of odd weather the other two islands connected by the sea train have. Other than the weather issue, the big focus this chapter is payment for Lucci’s medical bills. Since it would be quite difficult to find steady jobs without references, the best paying alternative is show business. Naturally, the task of performing for money is the group’s kabuki specialist, Kumadori. From the size of the crowd around him it seems he is pretty popular so I wouldn’t doubt it if he keeps up this as a profession even after Lucci recovers. I am also still hoping that we get to see Kaku get a job at a zoo later in this cover arc, but Kumadori is entertaining enough to keep me satisfied.


Staying Put

http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/5083/2ayp5.png
whipped!!!

Since the Strawhats have arrived at a very interesting location, it is natural that most of them would feel a need to explore a bit. However, Sanji, Usopp, and Franky decide to forego this island adventure and stay on the ship. Franky feels the need to make a few repairs to the ship and Usopp decides to help him out. These two seem to be developing a very strong bond with each other beyond that of the standard bonds between the crew as Oda has repeatedly paired them together in both combat purposes and socializing more than any other pair of Strawhats. It is completely understandable though as they click on so many levels. First of all, they compliment each other’s skills perfectly as Franky’s expertise in creating weapons systems is enhanced by Usopp’s superior ability to use them as seem in the battle with the Flying Fish Riders. In addition to that, Usopp’s devotion to Merry gives him a deeper respect for Franky’s devotion to Sunny than the other Strawhats and he feels a need to care for the ship alongside the designated shipwright. Other than these two, Sanji was also left on the boat, but his reason is less meaningful. Basically, Nami used his love for her to manipulate him into guarding the loot from Thriller Bark. He even admits that this is the case flat out. Although him being the guard is simply because of Nami’s manipulation, she did have good reason for determining that a guard was needed. Like Jaya, the Shabondy Archipelago is a gathering place for all sorts of untrustworthy folk and it would be idiotic to leave that much treasure sitting on a ship while the only two aboard are preoccupied with repairs.


Lost Swordsman

http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/9961/3aqw6.png
dude, listen to them

Though I said the only three left on the ship were Franky, Usopp, and Sanji, technically Zoro was on board too, though he decides shortly after to take a walk. Immediately after he jumps off the boat, Usopp and Sanji realize how idiotic this is for a person with such a bad sense of direction. They have had enough situations with his faulty inner compass to know that he will get lost all too easily and initially try to forbid him from leaving. However, he displays an unusual amount of common sense and points out that since the trees are numbered, as long as he remembers the number of the tree where the Sunny is docked, he’ll be able to get back easily enough. This bit of logic is enough to convince Usopp and Sanji (though they should know Zoro well enough to know that he could screw even that simple a system up). Surely enough, immediately after announcing his seemingly intelligent plan on how to keep himself oriented, he goes to read the number on the tree where he is currently at but mistakes it as Grove 1 since the 4 of 41 was hidden behind a bubble. This means that Zoro will either end up in somewhere completely random or at the actual Grove 1. Either way, Oda will use this as an opportunity to place Zoro in a position to witness some secret dealing or revealing event that was meant to be hidden from general view. In the words of Barbossa from PotC, “For sure, you have to be lost to find a place that can't be found, elseways everyone would know where it was.” I’m guessing that Grove 1 might be a location reserved for the nobles due to their high standing, which would make sense as a place for Zoro to eavesdrop and/or create a commotion that reveals a critical piece of info.


People of Shabondy

http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/307/4aux3.png
At least Nami's there to listen for Luffy

As we move on to Luffy’s group, Hachi begins to explain a few things about the residents of this archipelago. First of all, he goes a bit deeper into his explanation of the nobles and says their true title is the Tenryuubito, which means the Heavenly Dragon Folk (thanks to Carlos Net for the TL note). They are so uptight and proud that they wear their own masks with air supplies to avoid breathing the same air as commoners. As they appear later on, I’ll hold off on analysis of them for now. Besides them, Shabondy can be thought of as being similar to Jaya, but on a whole other scale. It is a gathering place for many powerful individuals. Strong pirate crews come through on their way to the New World. We don’t have much in the way of details, but it is implied that many of them might rival the Strawhats in terms of bounty or strength. In addition to them, the place also attracts bounty hunters and marines. I’m guessing that the marine presence here is not an official unit but rather some independent ranked officers who act more like rogue bounty hunters looking for marks. I say this because so many aspects of this island require the government turning a blind eye. If the marines were an official presence here, they would be required to make official statements regarding the kidnappings and the cruelty of the Tenryuubito. However, since they unofficially condone those actions but can’t allow the public to know, they do not deploy teams there like Smoker’s base on Logue Island. Any actions of the marines there are on their free time or at least by unofficial order.


Disguise

http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/7486/5aam7.png
i'm getting desperate to confirm if the tattoo has a deep meaning

One thing that I’m guessing a number of you guys noticed once Hachi started speaking is that he was wearing an odd coat that only allows him use of one pair of arms. Eventually he gets around to telling Luffy to treat him and Caimie as humans. On closer inspection, it is also apparent that he has applied a bandage over the tattoo on his forehead and Caimie is wearing a long skirt to hide her fish tail. While he doesn’t go too deeply into an explanation, my best guess would be to avoid kidnappers. As I mentioned, one of the reasons that the kidnapping trade does so well in this region is because the government turns a blind eye to the dealings here. Hachi only specifies that the government will not help kidnapped pirates, but I’m guessing that the same idea applies to most or all kidnappings here since deploying military for the “legitimate” cases would force them to take notice of the injustices that they would rather ignore. The other big reason as I deduced in my previous review is that the Tenryuubito provide a good market for the kidnappers to sell to. Since the nobles are the buyers, the government is willing to ignore the kidnappings in order to keep the market up for these powerful individuals. This relates to Hachi and Caimie in that it had been revealed earlier that mermaids and fishmen are prime targets for kidnappers due to the high prices they fetch. Since the nobles treat these slaves like pets, to them the fishmen and mermaids are nothing more than a rare fish collection to keep in an aquarium. In order to stay safe while in this hotbed of kidnappers, Hachi and Caimie must hide themselves. One of the pieces of disguise is quite noteworthy. This is Hachi’s bandage, which is really the only piece that is directly noticed by Luffy. The bandage hides the sun tattoo on his forehead, which is identical to ones on various other fishmen we have met. It is quite obvious that the tattoo is at least unique to fishmen and that revealing it would be an obvious sign of his race even if he hid the rest well. This could be a symbol of Jimbei’s former crew or simply a popular tattoo among fishmen, but either way, I suspect we will find some deeper meaning to it later in this arc.


Bubble Physics

http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/6120/6aot4.png
I want!!!

Though Hachi was just a moment before discussing quite serious matters, Luffy is quickly distracted by the bubbles and gets it into his head to try to get himself into one. Since the bubble is quite resilient, he is successful and gets first his head and then his body inside. Upon seeing Luffy’s excitement, a merchant quickly comes up to him with an attachment that he sticks on the bubble. This tool allows Luffy to pedal in order to move a fan behind him and ride in this hovering bubble. The merchant gives Luffy the option of renting it for the day at a rate of 500 beli or purchasing it for 10,000 beli. Obviously, Luffy loves it so much that he wants to purchase it so he could always have it. However, Hachi advises him to just rent it instead (though Luffy doesn’t want to listen). Upon hearing Hachi’s advice, the merchant recognizes that Hachi is a local and gives up on trying to sell it to Luffy. It is a very simple scam that earns merchants lots of cash from tourists but anyone who knows the area is able to see through it instantly. After paying to rent Luffy’s inner bubble-bike, an outer bubble-bike for Nami, and a larger transport bubble for the rest, Hachi explains to them why purchasing these things instead of renting is a scam. Though the bubbles are extremely resilient and we have not seen any pop while they have been in the archipelago, this is the only region that the bubbles can maintain this resilience. By going above the treetops or moving away over the water’s surface, the bubbles leave the atmosphere of the archipelago and pop, making these transports useless. However, these do still work in Fishman Island, so it seems directly related to proximity to the trees. Since Fishman Island is located near to where the roots of the mangrove trees anchor themselves to the seabed, the bubbles still work down there. On the other end, the leaves of the treetops act as a barrier to hold in the specific gasses that allow the bubbles to remain strong. Once the bubbles go beyond this, they reenter the standard atmosphere and pop. Although Hachi tells this to Luffy (albeit not in the detailed explanation I gave), Luffy still does not grasp the concept until Nami gives the base definition while using the only word Luffy seems to universally accept, mysteriously. Any time he cannot grasp a concept, the best way to explain it to him is give the cause, effect, and say that the process is a mystery.


Royalty

http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/6642/7azn4.png
skull jokes never get old

After that issue is settled, the topic of conversation shifts to what to expect in Fishman Island and Pappagg says to visit the mermaid princess. Although this is only briefly mentioned, I think it deserves some analysis. We know from both Caimie and Kokoro that though the underwater paradise is called Fishman Island, it is actually a place that is home to both fishmen and merpeople. This makes it interesting that though the island is named after one race, the other race bares a royal family there. Though we have not seen any mermen and most of the fishmen we have seen have been men, I’m guessing that there are both genders of merpeople as Hachi’s side arc proved there were both races of fishpeople (the octopus fishwoman he loved). Since there is a confirmed mermaid princess, I’m guessing there is an entire royal family to go with it most likely with a king based on Poseidon from Greek mythology. On the other hand, Oda could run with the Little Mermaid theme that Caimie has started (a gorgeous mermaid traveling with a talking sea creature). Though we really don’t know anything at this point, I’m guessing that this royal family is likely more ceremonial than anything and the official decisions of Fishman Island are made democratically through representatives of both races. Whatever the case, we can be assured that the princess will be involved with the plot of this arc as Pappagg supposedly has close ties with her, thus assuring an introduction for the Strawhats.


Hotel Grove

http://img521.imageshack.us/img521/631/8aqz5.png
they must have "...and all i got was this lousy t-shirt" apparel

As the group continues on to Grove 35, they find that this grove is marketed strongly to tourists and travelers. One aspect Robin takes notice of is the number of hotels in the area. Though the Shabondy Archipelago is known as a meeting place for pirates and such who want to enter the New World through the unofficial route, it is also a stop for those who want to cross the Red Line legally. People waiting for government approval to cross through the holy land stay at the hotels since the ease of creating the hotels makes them relatively cheap. The rooms are created by coating a large bubble in an alloy, which both weights it down and enhances the durability so it can stay sturdy for as long as needed. In addition to the hotels, the grove also host a number of gift shops which cater to travelers who want a souvenir of their time in the first half of the Grand Line before heading to the New World. Brooke and Chopper buy the classic souvenirs while Luffy purchases a bunch of manjuu that last for three months and are imprinted with “Grand Line First Half”. The idea behind these manjuu is that you can eat this food from the first half after you are well into the New World. The grove has even perfected the method of carrying purchases by allowing customers to carry their things in bon-bags, which allows the objects to hover weightlessly like a balloon in a special bubble rather than carry the weight themselves.


Girl Time

http://img521.imageshack.us/img521/3606/9acb3.png
they must have some of Pappagg's designs in there

Once again, the group splits into smaller groups. This time, Nami and Robin wander off to do some shopping of their own over on Grove 30. Since Luffy, Brooke, and Chopper are more interested in the tourist aspects of the island, they stay with Hachi and Caimie as their guides while the Strawhat women actually have some predetermined purchases that they want to make. While Grove 35 is marketed to tourists, Grove 30 bears a shopping mall where the girls likely plan to buy some clothing and possibly some furniture for the Sunny. Due to Luffy donating most of 100 million beli for the party on Water 7, Nami was unable to buy the accessories she wanted for the new ship. Now that she has the loot from Thriller Bark, she can outfit the Sunny as she pleases and thands to the use of bon-bags, carrying a large load is no problem. In a brief scene with the two girls as they make their way towards the mall, they discuss why Caimie did not join them. As she is an aspiring designer, they likely figured that she would enjoy the mall and she would even be able to help them pick what to buy. However, they were surprised that she declined their offer. They took notice of the fact that she has remained somewhat to herself ever since they arrived and Robin theorizes that she may have a bad history with this island. This idea is strengthened by the little tidbit last chapter about her dream to ride the ferris wheel but it being an impossibility for her. This is likely due to the kidnappers and the fact that she is a mermaid. I would not be surprised if there was a specific noble on the archipelago who had developed a desire for her specifically or had already owned her but she escaped and that is the reason she is targeted so fiercely by the Macro crew. After so many failures, it would be logical to find a different target and move on but if catching her carried with it a guaranteed reward from a specific individual, it would make her a valuable enough target to keep going after. Out of fear of this one noble and the bounty hunters he has at his fingertips, she clings to Hachi rather than enjoy herself while on this archipelago.


Pure Fear

http://img521.imageshack.us/img521/4556/10axz1.png
he looks like Foxy's angry brother

Back with Luffy’s group, our captain is having a race with Hachi on their vehicles while Chopper and Pappagg rest comfortably inside the bubbles. Luffy suddenly takes notice of a large and oddly dressed man screaming for help. He just wants someone to help him remove the color from his neck. Hachi says he seems to be a man who was sold as a slave to one of the Tenryuubito. Once entered into slavery, the captured are equipped with special collars that are set to explode if they try to escape. The collars are attached to chains held by their masters and the explosion sequence is set to start after the chain becomes broken, leaving a very short time before detonation. This means that if an escaped slave is seen, the master is very nearby. This one was apparently a former pirate captain worth 60 million beli. Even a man of that level is terrified for his life due to his current situation. Since most of the pirate crews we see in this series save the Strawhats, Red-hairs, and Whitebeards have been depicted as cruel or simply greedy, the fact that this captain is planning to give up his dream in order to be free and return to his family speaks volumes for the level of cruelty his masters dish out. He has been humbled to the point where he is no longer the fearsome pirate he once was and with his future robbed of him, he now simply wants to see a glimpse of his legacy embodied by his family. However, despite his heartfelt pleas for assistance, not a single person goes to help him. The Strawhats come close to but are stopped by Hachi and Pappagg. Moments later the collar explodes to the horror of the witnesses. The level of this pirate also gives me a theory about the bounty hunters of this area. I get the feeling that many of the bounty hunters here double as kidnappers due to the fact that a bounty hunter’s main concern is money. When capturing living marks, before going to the government to collect a reward, they first go to the Tenryuubito and see if they can get a better price. Duval’s group was thought of as a high level kidnapping group but they likely wouldn’t be able to handle pirate captains like this guy but bounty hunters could.


Silhouette

http://img521.imageshack.us/img521/5316/11aal9.png
beware of shady axe murderers

Normally I wouldn’t bother with analysis of minor little things, but the shadowy man with an axe intrigues me. From what I can tell, Oda is setting him up to be somewhat important in the upcoming storyline. First of all, the fact that his face is hidden in darkness while he looks over the scene implies that Oda wants to save the revealing of his identity for later. If I had to guess, I’d say he is a bounty hunter since he seems to be carrying a stack of bounty posters while he analyzes the scene below. He seems to like estimating the worthiness of marks to enter the New World as he deems this guy to be unfit for the task. The now blackened pirate captain seemed boring to him, so it is likely that he sets a standard on the skill level of his opponents before taking them on.


http://img521.imageshack.us/img521/9831/11blt1.png
i wouldn't say its out of the question. would you?

In addition to that, I have a second theory regarding this guy though it’s a bit farfetched at this point. After seeing his silhouette, his profile definitely seemed familiar and sure enough, the hat or hairstyle he has is remarkably similar to that shown of Admiral Kizaru from chapter 319. I still think it is too early for the crew to be tackling an admiral at this point, so if this is the case, I’d say that his appearance in this arc would be likened to Dragon’s appearance in Logue Town. He will not be very directly involved in the plot of the arc but he will oversee the events and look forward to the day he meets Luffy again in the New World. In addition to this physical appearance, the way he comments on the pirate’s inability to survive the New World could be seen as him simply previewing possible future opponents. So far among the admirals we know Ao Kiji follows a sense of justice with morality and Akainu follows absolute justice, so having the third admiral be one that does not care much for justice at all but instead values power would be a good fit. He comes to the Shabondy Archipelago to view pirates who have potential and when he finds one that interests him, he waits for their power to grow in the New World before cutting them down.


Wealth and Cruelty

http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/7074/12auj3.png
thats a mighty ugly creature

After the shadowy axe-man finishes, the next image we get is a dog with a portable air supply coming up to pee on the burnt ex-pirate. Closely following the dog are a father and daughter both wearing bubbles on their heads with portable air supplies and towing behind them a massive and fearsome being. When discussing this fallen pirate, they treat him like a mere pet that had to be put down. Apparently he comes from a collection of pirate captains the father has taken as slaves, giving more proof to the bounty hunters doubling as kidnappers and slave traders. Tenryuubito like this man provide a market for bounty heads that the bounty hunters are willing to oblige. While the purchasing of fishmen and mermaids may be likened to the collecting of rare species for collections, the sale of pirate captains is more similar to that of show dogs. These are specimens that though the species is not as unique for pets or servants, the nobles compete amongst themselves to collect individuals with higher bounties and how well they can break them in. Once one goes rogue though, he is seen as a failure and must be eliminated and replaced. This being the case, the pirate that escaped just now is shot by the father and left to die while the daughter happily tells her father what kind of slave she wants next. After they leave and Luffy gets to discuss what happened with Hachi, it is mentioned that the marines took him away. While this does seem to go against my previous thoughts regarding marine deployment here, I’m still pretty sure the general policy here is the blind eye approach. In this case, the case was that the man was a bounty head and so dead or alive he needed to be taken in. Since even after he was put into slavery, this man’s bounty poster was still active, the government simply ignores this capture until the nobles dispose of him. After that he becomes fair game for a resident marine to call in and have a small team take him to be imprisoned or confirmed as dead.


Dark Bloodlines

http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/4375/13azv3.png
its been a while since the lost century was referenced

After hearing a bit of discussion regarding the cruelty of the Tenryuubito’s actions, we finally hear the origin of their nobility and the reason why they are so feared. The reason they have such high status is due to the fact that they are descended from the twenty kings that founded the World Government 800 years ago, which is pretty much exactly what I said last week (not in the review itself but in a reply post). This means that if anyone knew the truth of the lost century, these people would. Due to this, I’m quite certain that this arc will lead Robin to more clues regarding that time through either a poneglyph hidden in Fishman Island or the interrogation of a Tenryuubito. In any case, as Professor Clover deduced that the World Government was responsible for some great evil during that time, it is clear that those evil founders have passed both their influence and their ideals onto their following generations. As such, the Tenryuubito’s political power is great enough that if one of them is injured by an individual, they can call upon an admiral from Marine Headquarters to exact retribution. This does hint at an admiral being the main opponent of the arc, but as I have said before, I’m still hesitant on the idea that the Strawhats will be fighting yet another battle with the World Government powerhouses. In addition, as there are only three admirals, I’d think that their power is too much for any time short of the second or third arc in the New World. I think this fight will be either with a noble who bears great combat ability or a bounty hunter that acts as a hired gun. Then at the end of the arc, the nobles will call for an admiral but one of two things will happen. If Ao Kiji is the one assigned, he’ll officially accept but in reality will ignore the order as he knows the nobles got what they deserved. If Akainu or Kizaru are assigned, they will either tail the Strawhats for a few arcs before initiating combat or they will come out of nowhere after a few arcs pass to fulfill their duties.


Overall

Whew! I think this might be a record breaker for the longest single chapter review I or GK has ever done. I’ve done longer ones before but I think those were at least triple chapter reviews. Oda has masterfully incorporated so much material in here that can be explored. Much of this comes from the fact that we are on the brink of not only a new and unique arc in the series but the start of a new saga once the arc ends. This being the case, Oda must provide setup not only to prepare us for the plot of the Fishman Island arc but also needs to show us beforehand that entering the New World will be very different from the Grand Line’s first half. This means both hinting that some mysteries will be revealed in this arc while simultaneously providing the base for plots of New World arcs. While I can’t say this chapter exceeds others like Merry’s funeral or Zoro’s sacrifice in terms of deep and emotional meaning, this is pure gold when it comes to the sheer amount of stuff to analyze.

Highseas7
April 20, 2008, 11:37 PM
1st to pop that comment cherry lol sahugani Kick ass review man and i also agree that hachi's tattoo is of great importance and i think it is a symbol for Jimbei's fish crew, anyways I concur they wont be fighting an admiral because im pretty certian they will be goin toe-2-toe with jimbei but they might have a scurmish with one real quick then Escape, and as a final note they the strawhats might get that giant member i've been wanting because as the stuck up dad and daughter leave she says she wants a gaint and i know its a longshott but hey i can dream cant I? hahahaha

sahugani
April 21, 2008, 12:06 AM
regarding the tattoo, i'm really hoping that it is a sign of Jimbei's crew or something of equivalent importance because its a repeated symbol, which has to mean something. i highly doubt Oda would repeat these tattoos on multiple fishmen for no reason when he could just as easily make each fishman bear completely unique tattoos. given that, other than simply their race as fishmen, Jimbei is the best explanation that unites these individuals.

as for the big bad guy of the arc, i'm against it being an admiral but i also doubt it's Jimbei. first of all, fighting two Shichibukai (actually 3 including Kuma) in a row is even less likely than an admiral. also, Oda seems to be strongly setting this arc up as a struggle against the ideals of the Tenryuubito and since i doubt they are favorable to fishmen, i don't imagine Jimbei siding with them

as for the giant member, i'm personally not a fan of the idea and find it unlikely to happen, but as One Piece fans, we must keep our minds open and never count anything out completely, so dream on

Sarmad
April 21, 2008, 05:37 PM
Hey sahugani!

I'm glad that you had the time to do this review and it's a great review! well yours always are ^^

anyway, you hit the bullseye about the nobles. they are indeed connected to the goverment and even more, they're tied to the founders of that conspicuous organization by blood! i wonder though, if those gorosei geezer are also world nobles. I guess that at least one of them is a descendant.

regarding Kizeru being the man in the shadows, i dout that it's him or rather i hope that it#s not him. for me at least, it doesn't look like he's wearing a hat. and furthermore his weapon... we know that aokiji is a human popsicle and that aikanu's not wearing any weapon during the raid on ohara, which doesn't prove anything but still, i'd like to think that Kizeru fighting style wouldn't use any weapons, except maybe a sword to match him with zoro. i don#t say that an axe wouldn't suit an admiral, cause i'm sure that oda would make it work for me anyway ^^, but i still hope for something else. that said i wouldn't really be disappointed if your prediction may be true.

it's really funny how hard it is to predict what'll happen next right now (at least for me XP)
papagg told us that it's almost suicide to get involved with the world nobles. But knowing the strawhats it is impossible for them to not kick some noble asses ^^
so what will happen when they finally fight them? i think that there are two other options, beside the options you stated, which were btw quite brilliant.

option a) there is a possibility that the things that papagg had told us were just partly true. i don't doubt that there is anything untrue about the world nobles being the decendants of the 20 kings who founded the world goverment.
It's the part about the admiral that i think could be false. the whole thing could be made up, maybe by the world nobles or maybe by the goverment itself, to prevent pirates from doing anything to the nobles. and in order to make sure that everyone truly believes, that it isn't just scaretactics, they would've had to stage an attack and made an admiral appear to punish the culprit.
[edit: of course al VIPs for the world goverment would be protected by he highest ranks, including the admirals, but my theor y is that the woorld nobles, at least the ones in the kidnapping buisness wouldn't be counted as real VIPs.
the realtionship between the world nobles and the goerment may be somewhat like the one between helmeppo and captain morgan, as weird as it may sound ^^]

option b) the strawhats will give the nobles a beating in/on fishmen island and until info reaches the marines hq they'd be long gone ^^


.. im not finished yet ^^, but since i'm too tired to continue i'll have to write the rest tomorrow or some other time X/ (revolution ... dragon ...fishmen island .. nice teaser huh XD )

sahugani
April 21, 2008, 06:27 PM
regarding the Gorosei, i think it is quite likely that they are from the nobles. while what we have seen of the Tenryuubito so far is simply arrogance and a superiority complex, there are likely at least a few among them who end up extremely intelligent, cunning, and strong. i'd guess that the members of the Gorosei choose their successors from these gifted members of the Tenryuubito each time one dies or retires

as for Kizeru, i'm currently a bit undecided as to whether or not i want the shadowy guy to be him. like you i'm not too keen on the idea of a marine admiral wielding a giant axe though i know if Oda decided to do that, he'd do it in a way that would be more than acceptable to me. on the other hand, i'm really liking the theory i made as it enhances the storyline in that this arc is leading into the jump to the New World and we need something big to kick it off

for your first theory, it is quite plausible that the admiral call is a bluff and if it is i'm guessing it is at the direction of the government rather than the Tenryuubito. however, i think the reality is somewhere between your theory and Pappagg's words. the admiral call could be thought of as a request that the admiral can choose to ignore or accept based on the severity of the situation and his own demeanor. while i doubt the admirals would really move in to avenge the minor whims of nobles annoyed by peasants, if the situation risked the life of a noble, the sanctity of the holy land, or the protection of government secrets, the admiral might actually show. however, even this is limited by the specific admiral's nature as Ao Kiji would likely ignore the order regardless of the circumstances and especially if it involved the Strawhats. i'm guessing that the admiral call started out as a promise to protect the lives of the Tenryuubito with the power of the admirals but as the nobles become more accustomed to power and grew snottier, they began to boast that their importance was so great that the admirals would avenge the tiniest scratch.

your second theory sounds very plausible. that way we don't have the Strawhats fighting an admiral this early but the threat of an admiral's pursuit follows them into the New World

can't wait to hear the rest

lelouch
April 22, 2008, 06:47 AM
Wow awesome review!! was a really satisfying read, thanks, and i just realized how much i missed your single chapter reviews after reading this :P

anyway, my predictions of what would happen -
obviously, luffy n co will noble ass.. I'm pretty sure Jimbei isn't the antagonist in this arc or the next he probably made a deal with the WG to keep Fishman island safe, this ties in with Arlong arc, his hatred for humans can be attributed to the extreme racism he experienced at the hands of humans. Being chased by an admiral, Luffy n co seek sanctuary in Fishman island under the guardianship of Jimbei, and so the admiral would have to retreat or risk clashing with another great power.

Sounds unlikely..but its sure sounds good :p
hahah

sahugani
April 22, 2008, 02:21 PM
you're right that it sounds unlikely, but it fits in with one idea i REALLY want to come true. i want him to be a likable Shichibukai. to me, his name meaning "whale shark" just screams gentle giant, so i've always pictured him as more of a pacifist. i really like the concept you gave of him becoming a Shichibukai (or some other deal after gaining the title) in exchange for Fishman Island's safety. i'd love to see the Strawhats work alongside a Shichibukai to defend the island

lelouch
April 23, 2008, 08:40 AM
Sahugani we need chapter 498 spoiler reviews ^^

Sarmad
April 23, 2008, 05:48 PM
Hey sahugani

sorry it took me so long to reply and continue the stuff i wanted to say the last time, but couldn't due to my need to sleep ;)

so here i go again, but before i present to you my very special theory (haha rather random thoughts and btw i really hope you didn't expect too much XP), i'd like to say a few words to what you said about the stuff i said :D
about the truth or reality as you said being between what i theorized (very poorly indeed ^^ ) and papagg's words, i agree. it's the most logical solution.
regarding what you said about the nobles becoming more snobbsih by the days, i like to think that there is a discrepany between the snobish nobles and the "normal" nobles, who are porbably working with the WG, due to the snobish world nobles' inacceptable behaviour(human trafficking, slavery, etc). and this would support the idea of that "reality".

and well, just one thing i'd like to add here. i realized just now that the option i called "b" is in a sense identical to what you mentioned in you review. it wasn't intentional ^^

ok then, let me then continue where i left off. hehe

I think that Monkey D. Dragon may have been a Marine!
it's pretty far fetched, i know, but if one considers how less we actually know about him, it might not be that unlikely after all!
First of all, he's been referred to as the "revolutionary" dragon and never as the pirate dragon. [this is at the same time my strongest or maybe second strongest argument for this theory, the rest is absolute speculation. (to be honest)]
another thing is that his father is a famous marine.... but, since nobody knew that dragon is in fact garps son, it might an argument against my theory.
however, the thing that makes me believe that dragon was MAYBE a marine before revolting against the WG, is that Dragon must actually have a damn good reason for fighting the WG.
There must've happened something between the two parties that made Dragon realize how bad the WG in fact is and that life itself would be better without the WG or rather without its influence.
And that's how i think it might've all gone down.
Dragon ceased from being a marine at some time after Gol D. Roger's execution. dragon was, before all that happened, a high ranked marine who was stationed in mariejoa. and then some incident must've ocurred which shook his believes or ideology so gravely that he decided to take down the WG. all the pirates we've come to know so far are either looking for one piece, which includes the search for adventure, or the ultimate power over the seas. none of them were actually interested in destroying the wg. at least until now! that's why i think that dragon's reasoning must be different! anyway his journey as a revolutionary must've begun in the new world and even if this turns out to be totally wrong, the end of the revolution has to reach or will probably reach mariejoa as the last bastion of the WG. It ends where it all started. For the sake of my theory ^^
what lead me to this very speculative theory was the idea that a revolution on fishmen island might be highly likely with the nobles running around and (possibly) opressing the fishmen even down in/on fishmen island.
the strawhats united with other pirates (or a pirate like jimbei for example) might be able to pull off a revolution and this might also become their first step into the global conflict (but all this rather unwillingly, like always) ^^


btw ... have you read the spoilers? can't wait for the next review, like lelouch ^^


so long
sarmad

sahugani
April 24, 2008, 06:55 PM
@lelouch - haha. yes the spoilers do look all too tempting but there are a few reasons why i have been holding back on commenting on the spoilers. first of all, studying for a midterm means no time for good analysis. secondly, over time i seem to have phased out of commenting in the discussion threads cause i hate how ideas get lost so easily after the next page is reached. lastly, i like to start analysis only when i have all of the info available to me so i don't make false analysis due to the wrong context. you'll just need to wait till my next review for my thoughts on the awesomeness

@Sarmad - glad to see you back. sleep is very important and i for one should get more of it.

regarding the nobles, of course a line must be drawn between the two types of nobles. as i said when replying to your thoughts on the Gorosei's link to the nobles, they do need a base of intelligent people from which to chose their heirs.

as for your special theory, i love it!!! Dragon having his background in the World Government is simply perfect. we know that Garp trained Luffy and Ace to become marines (though that didn't exactly turn out as he planned) so its more than likely he did the same with his own son. with high ranking father and a large degree of personal talent, i think that at the time of his turning point, he was likely equal to his father in rank or was at least seen as a prodigy among the up and coming officers that could go on to admiral or higher in time. as for what happened to make him hate the world government, it has long been my theory that he somehow found out the true history that Robin is investigating. after learning this, he turned his back on the government and used his knowledge of its inner workings to formulate revolutions throughout the world.

regarding a revolution on Fishman Island being an entrance into the "Global Conflict" as it has been now dubbed, i think a true entrance into this can only be made official by defeating or publicly allying with a Yonkou or marine admiral. though Shichibukai are one of the 3 powers, they are more replaceable and are still more independent from the conflict than the other 2 parties. any actions besides the aforementioned may get them noticed by the world powers but are still thought of as independent actions. an alliance with Jimbei and/or a revolution on Fishman Islands may turn heads like the Enies Lobby attack did, but it won't alter the Government or the Yonkou's main objective. before joining the global conflict, we need to learn more about the major players so that the main story can effectively merge with the side-plot we get windows of revolving around Shanks, Whitebeard, and the other world powers. i doubt we'll see this till at least a few arcs in when the Strawhats face off against either Akainu or Kizaru

that said, though it is not yet time for the Strawhats to enter the arena of the global conflict, , i think it is only right for Oda to make it clear that the entrance into the New World is a step in that direction. this is why i like the idea if the shady man being Kizaru. though he won't be fighting the Strawhats now, it makes it clear that the top tiers of the World Powers are taking a personal interest in this crew's strength since up till now we've only heard about their FUTURE potential from these people

Raysen_ht
April 26, 2008, 04:56 PM
I really like ur theory on Dragon

Sarmad
April 27, 2008, 05:52 AM
YOHO thx for replying ^^

well i of course agree with all that you said, except for one thing!

If Dragon should know about the true history, as in knowing what really happened, then why does it seem like the rest of the world never heard of the true history?
Wouldn't it be only logical to spread the information about the true history or even just information about the fact that there is a "true history" ?
Furthermore i'd like to think that it'll be the strawhats, more specifically Robin, who'll reveal the truth about what happened 800 years ago.

Or could it be that i misunderstood? ^^ I didn't know exactly if you were saying that dragon knows the truth behind what happened 800 years ago or that he just knows that a "true history" exists and that he partially(maybe vaguely) knows what happened. Well that he pulled off something like Saulo.


very nice review for 498 btw! :D ^^