PDA

View Full Version : Review Bleach 235 Review By Gigantor21



gigantor21
July 13, 2006, 06:38 PM
235 – The Frozen Clutch

(I actually scanslated this chapter...go to the 235 RTS thread and check it out. Hope you like it!)

Alright! This chapter was awesome, especially compared to last week’s, because it directly addressed my main problem with 234—it focused on all the right parts for the right amount of time. The chapter was split evenly between two of the three fronts of the current battle (which Bleach fans should be used to by now, as I hear), and Kubotite somehow managed to make it so that both basically ended at the perfect moment, leaving us guessing about just about everyone in the current fight.

To be honest, these are my favorite kinds of chapters.

Okay, so we started off with Yammi confirming that Hitsugaya’s Sennen Hyourou killed Luppi…sort of. Since he’s only slightly better than Ichigo was in Chapter 1 at sensing people’s energy, I honestly don’t see how he can tell any more than us readers. So it’s probably safe to keep considering Luppi’s health status as up in the air at this point. Anyway, right at the second page, BAM! Urahara comes out completely unharmed, and wit his sense of humor in tact, to boot. He then proceeds to basically break down his entire strategy against Yammi while successfully dodging and nullifying his Bala—which he’s capable of doing because Yamii had been pummeling a portable Gigai in 234, while Urahara basically analyzed everything about the technique from a distance. The scene ends with Urahara deciding that they should finish this, as we digest the orgy of evidence showing how intellectually badass he is.

Keeping that in mind, I’ll pardon the lack of Benihime Bankai for another week.

Anyway, we shift gears a bit after that, moving back to Grimmjow and Ichigo’s fight—which really can’t be classified as a fight anymore. Right off the bat, Ichigo tries to re-materialize his mask and fails, proving that he’s incapable of doing it again—which means that he can’t fight Grimmjow anymore. Just as he’s about to get Ceroed in half, Rukia steps in and freezes Grimmjow completely with another new Shikai technique (Next Song: White Pulse). That doesn’t really last very long, though, as the chapter ends with Grimmjow breaking free, grabbing Rukia’s face, and charging up a Cero at point-blank range while Ichigo watches on helplessly. I’ve been in the discussion thread and heard some talk of Ichigo re-materializing his mask out of anger or desparation; personally, I think that this is a perfect set-up for someone to come in and save them.

Whether it’s a Vaizard (the best choice), another Shinigami from Soul Society (which would be a bit random, especially if it were a captain), or even Ichigo’s dad (which would be insanely awesome), has yet to be seen. In any case, I figure that if the fight is continued in the next chapter, then that’s what’s going to happen. I’m still holding out hope for Urahara to use his Bankai—though I think that it’d be likely for Yammi to release his sword first and give Urahara some trouble before then. So I doubt we’ll see Urahara’s Bankai until 237 or 238, at the earliest. We’ll probably get an update on Orihime and Ulquiorra next week, for sure—I think, and personally hope, that someone will come in and help her, like a captain or something. Zaraki with a new Shikai would be nice…

Anyway, this chapter was really good, and made only better by the fact that it was released so early, along with Naruto and One Piece (which both had excellent chapters, too, though One Piece has been on a year-long streak with those). I can’t wait until next week’s chapter.

Gold Knight
July 13, 2006, 07:42 PM
While the Urahara scenes were awesome, I wasn't too fond of Rukia doing her usual "I am teh pwnness" entrance and then subsequently getting herself pwned once again. Then there's the thing about the dialogue apparently actually being medicore this week if it hadn't been for Djudge's translation that saved it, so it's not exactly easy to judge the chapter... nevertheless, I'm liking how the fights are going.

gigantor21
July 13, 2006, 08:30 PM
While the Urahara scenes were awesome, I wasn't too fond of Rukia doing her usual "I am teh pwnness" entrance and then subsequently getting herself pwned once again. Then there's the thing about the dialogue apparently actually being medicore this week if it hadn't been for Djudge's translation that saved it, so it's not exactly easy to judge the chapter... nevertheless, I'm liking how the fights are going.


I hope this whole "I like this chapter when you don't" thing between us doesn't become the norm...that's two chapters in a row...

Anyway, in the case of the dialouge being mediocre, that is HIGHLY dependent on the way it's translated, to me. Djudge's translations of Bleach are always the most interesting, while most other translations (including the mainstay groups like M7 and Ju-ni in recent weeks) have been pretty flat and straightfoward, which has only been acceptable because this current story arc has been pretty interesting for the most part. I guess it's one thing if you can read Japanese and think that way, but for me, the translation can play a very decisive role in how I percieve the chapter--which is why I read a bunch of different ones before I actually do the reviews.

As for Rukia's entrance, what else could she have possibly done? We haven't seen any type of attack from her Shikai that doesn't involve freezing the opponent in some way. I didn't really see her attack as being that much more flashy than most of the other stuff in Bleach overall. Look at what happened after Grimmjow kicked Ichigo after he tried to materialze the mask--it looked like a series of bombs went off when he hit the ground! Attacks in Bleach are almost always over the top in terms of presentation--if Kubotite was trying to make it even more flashy in Rukia's case, then it was probably to make Grimmjow's escape that much more dramatic. We all pretty much knew it would happen, anyway...

But in any event, I guess I shouldn't be criticizing your views so vehemently--especially since our positions were reversed last week.

Gold Knight
July 13, 2006, 09:15 PM
Well, what kills me is Rukia already knew she was outmatched against Grimmjow - she couldn't at the very least plan some sort of strategy? But nooo... she just shoots an attack at him.

ibra87
July 14, 2006, 08:18 AM
Well, what kills me is Rukia already knew she was outmatched against Grimmjow - she couldn't at the very least plan some sort of strategy? But nooo... she just shoots an attack at him.

You haven't noticed that Grimmjow was going to fire a cero right at Ichigo and that one second of delay would have killed Ichigo? And it seems as if Rukia had underestimated Grimmjow, which is why she completely forgot about him.

gigantor21
July 14, 2006, 09:49 AM
You haven't noticed that Grimmjow was going to fire a cero right at Ichigo and that one second of delay would have killed Ichigo? And it seems as if Rukia had underestimated Grimmjow, which is why she completely forgot about him.


Exactly--she didn't have a choice. What else could she have done in such a short amount of time? Because there definitely wasn't enough for her to have come up with any type of strategy...

Gold Knight
July 14, 2006, 11:28 AM
Exactly--she didn't have a choice. What else could she have done in such a short amount of time? Because there definitely wasn't enough for her to have come up with any type of strategy...


Which is why I feel Tite Kubo is kinda giving Rukia a hard time. But point taken.