PDA

View Full Version : Society We and Millions of Sites are F!@$ if this Law passes



meowykid
October 02, 2010, 02:53 PM
the combating online infringement and counterfeits act
This is in the USA by the way. I do live in the Usa.
The Combating Online Infringement and Counterfeits Act was introduced by the Senate Judiciary Committee on Sept. 20. If passed, the bill could ban access to websites that violate copyright infringement laws.

The S. 3804 bill aims to stop online piracy and distribution of films, music, TV shows, and video games and was introduced by Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-VT) and Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT).

There is some controversy surrounding the bill, as it would block certain websites and create two Internet blacklists.

One list would include websites hit with a court order from the Attorney General, and the other list would consist of sites that are “dedicated to infringing activities,” as determined by the Department of Justice, according to the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF).

“COICA is a fairly short bill, but it could have a longstanding and dangerous impact on freedom of speech, current Internet architecture, copyright doctrine, foreign policy, and beyond,” says an EFF analysis. “In 2010, if there’s anything we’ve learned about efforts to rewrite copyright law to target ‘piracy’ online, it’s that they are likely to have unintended consequences.”


There are several websites that allow users to watch films for free online—including nearly all films still in theaters. There are also sites which allow users to download films and other media through peer-to-peer file sharing. Both forms of online piracy could be largely shut down by the bill.

Because of this, the bill has won praise from guilds and unions representing more than 300,000 workers in the entertainment and media industries.

“This legislation will make it easier to shut down ‘rogue’ websites, which are dedicated to stealing the films, television programs, and music created by our members,” says a joint statement from the Screen Actors Guild, Directors Guild of America, and several others.

It adds that, “The largely foreign profiteers who operate these sites rob our members of the ability to make a living from their creativity and labor, prevent funds from reaching their pension and health plans, and endanger their ability to work now and in the future.”

With this law, its no hard task to shut down youtube LOL.
Yep, we should be worried too.

Roflkopt3r
October 02, 2010, 07:23 PM
Good thing I love in germany. Sweden is even better though, they've got Piratpartiet (Pirate Party) in their parliament who, if I remember correctly, even hosted the well known torrentpage thepiratebay for some time after attempts of officials (don't remember in which country) tried to shut it down.

Any attempt of single countries to shut down such pages are futile anyways. They might shut down some, but most will just be rehosted in foreign countries or aren't even reachable for US authorities.

The attempts of defending copyrights seem useless to me. Once something is made virtual computer data, it's practically impossible to protect against those looking to get it, that's the nature of internet. I don't totally like it because I can imagine that there are many artists and small companies severly suffering from this. Yet that's reality and shouldn't surprise anyone in times of capitalism, which makes greed and egoism accepted key qualifications for the system instead of sentencing them as character flaws.

XxVascoxX
October 03, 2010, 10:43 AM
At a time the french law "Adopi" caused a lot of Havoc ....but now in most europe There are controversial political parties who are on the scene ...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_Parties_International

most of us do hope they will defend the "rights?" of internet dwellers ,but must say that we should not really decide to vote rather prematurely for the next local Pirate representative!

S.I.M Editor
October 03, 2010, 12:49 PM
worst comes to worst, everything goes back how it was before naptser(was it with a b or p?, dunno) was made. everything was uninteresting on the internet.

until in napster came out. so basically, someones gonna do something thats new and the cycle will repeat itself. as they say, where theres a will theres a way.

kkck
October 03, 2010, 10:16 PM
I don't think think laws can do much here. The internet cannot be controlled in a manner in which copyrights could be protected completely while at the same time respect freedom of information and freedom of speech(just as china). Even if youtube or this very website disappear how long would take for the other 200000000 billion identical websites to take over? Or how about how the 2 billion identical websites to rapidshare, megaupload and whatnot? Passing a law won't help, there is just too much information out there. Worst case scenario people will completely turn to torrents and then proceed to forget the issue as a whole. The other worst case scenario would be something I said when MH stopped hosting raws. The future of online piracy is the same as with every other industry: Outsourcing.