PDA

View Full Version : Is Garp just a Vice-Admiral or a Fleet Vice-Admiral?



Filster
March 15, 2012, 04:38 AM
The only thing that i came across watching One Piece that i didnt understand is Garps position.It was mention'd a couple of times that he was a Vice-Admiral.But hes stronger than the admirals,hows that...I mean ,hes is a legendary guy who new the seas when Pirate King was alive,he even fought him several times.So can someone explain this to me?

beck26
March 15, 2012, 10:21 AM
garp just wont accept being promoted to higher positions....that's all....

mattiaildivino
March 15, 2012, 10:54 AM
indeed,Garp was a vice-admiral but he was at least at admiral level. by the way,that's not the place to open this kinda threads,you should have asked that in the Hangout,or in one piece's page (47). but this is the section of the spoiler discussions,where we discuss about the latest chapters.

hoeru
March 15, 2012, 12:44 PM
Garp has the rank "chuujou" which translates to vice admiral. He is apparently not bound to a home base unlike Comil (G-2 commander) and Momonga (as his ID code implies, he's head of G-1's staff), but has his own Marine warship. Becoming an admiral would limit him in his freedom to move, therefore he denied being promoted.

Kaiten
March 15, 2012, 01:02 PM
He is not a Marine at all anymore, he retired in the aftermath of the war.

kkck
March 15, 2012, 01:15 PM
I was under the impression that both garp and sengoku retained their titles though. I think they simply retired from their duties and got teaching positions so technically they would still be marines.

Xander92
March 15, 2012, 11:16 PM
Garp was just a vice admiral, like a lot of the D.'s he just wanted the freedom to do as he pleased.

BlackHair
March 19, 2012, 02:21 PM
Garp wasn't just a VA, he was HQ VA. As such he holds more authority than sub-division (base) VA, such as G5-VA Smoker.


[..]Momonga (as his ID code implies, he's head of G-1's staff)[..]Could you explain that ID-Code? Not sure what u r talking about. Two years ago he was part of the Buster Call. As such he has to be a HQ VA.

I did some further digging after ur post and found out that the marine officer in chapter 598 isn't Mamonga. Apparently it was further confirmed in the anime. I don't watch it anymore, so I don't know it for a fact. However it makes more sense for Mamonga being a HQ VA than a G1 VA.

Edit: Just checked: Episode 517 at 16:03 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HYzj6Sgiixo&feature=related) Isn't Mamonga for sure.

hoeru
March 19, 2012, 10:42 PM
Garp wasn't just a VA, he was HQ VA. As such he holds more authority than sub-division (base) VA, such as G5-VA Smoker.
As a matter of fact, Oda never said something about VA's from headquarters being stronger or having more authority than base commanding VAs. Actually, he showed VA Comil having the sole command over G-2, and being called as one of the strongest fighters of the Marine forces to Marineford. Vice Admirals may have some priviliges like having an own warship (like Garp's).

That's it what we know of Vice Admirals.


Could you explain that ID-Code? Not sure what u r talking about. Two years ago he was part of the Buster Call. As such he has to be a HQ VA.
Momonga's authorization code for passing the Justice Gate starts with G-1. (http://www.mangareader.net/103-2632-4/one-piece/chapter-525.html) Oda placed a gap between "G-1" and "00660":

http://thumbnails64.imagebam.com/18065/d30e1a180645737.jpg (http://www.imagebam.com/image/d30e1a180645737)

Being in the Buster Call fleet doesn't have anything to do with where the VA is stationed. The Buster Call fleet is assembled by several warships that are the closest to the target. Marineford is just the closest and largest marine base to Enies Lobby. And we don't know why these VAs have been at that time at Marine Headquarters, probably because Blackbeard delivered Ace to them some days ago. There was no explanation given aside from Garp saying that he wasn't in Marineford to respond to the Enies Lobby request for Buster Call.


I did some further digging after ur post and found out that the marine officer in chapter 598 isn't Mamonga.
Then it must be his monocygote twin with the same beard and hair style but a basecap to appear different...

How often do people have to say this? DON'T EVER rely on the anime. They lack of credits, rename characters (proven by Blue Deep databook "Kaizerhige" vs. Stainless) and read the manga instead. Please compare Momonga shown on the page above with that mustache of his and compare it to this commanding officer (http://www.mangareader.net/103-57801-21/one-piece/chapter-598.html). It's pretty striking that this IS Momonga:

http://thumbnails65.imagebam.com/18065/1a888e180645070.jpg (http://www.imagebam.com/image/1a888e180645070)

Even the wrinkles are the same ... :teehee

BlackHair
March 19, 2012, 11:38 PM
It was stated in the green datebook that HQ marine officers hold more authority than subdivision ones.

The code is rather interesting. I already forget about that completely.

As to anime and manga: It is not out of the ordinary for Oda making mistakes in drawings or creating character with similar design. Though Im not watching the anime, I use it to clarify things which were ill-defined in the manga. Mamonga being the perfect case. Though that code clears everything up.

PS: Ur sarcasm annoys the hell out of me. I tried my best being polite, but Im forced to draw a line here. In further discussions with you I will always remember ur sarcasm. :super

hoeru
March 19, 2012, 11:52 PM
It was stated in the green datebook that HQ marine officers hold more authority than subdivision ones.
Which log and page for reference issues?


PS: Ur sarcasm annoys the hell out of me. I tried my best being polite, but Im forced to draw a line here. In further discussions with you I will always remember ur sarcasm. :super
Sorry, if you feel hurt. It was meant as joke. And still: No, the anime doesn't clarify but obfuscate.

BlackHair
March 20, 2012, 12:31 AM
arg'.. I thought I put the link in my post. Here u go (http://www.mangareader.net/one-piece-databook/1/16). The question is asked for general differences between HQ and subdivision. The answer has Morgan as example. Giving it some thoughts, it makes sense for the elite being in HQ.


No, the anime doesn't clarify but obfuscate.If the manga itself isn't clear enough and if there isn't any SBS or whatever answers from Oda, we have only the anime left. The anime is the closest we have besides Odas canon.

warsetone
March 21, 2012, 09:55 PM
No Garp is just a vice admiral, and No its never said that hes stronger than other admirals, the current 3 admirals (pre time skip) were said to be the strongest in Marine.

"Cornering Roger" is nothing special, considering:
1) Smoker (currently vice admiral) has also cornered Luffy (the upcoming pirate king) many times.
2) others like Shiki have also cornered Roger.
3) It's not like Roger is all mighty god-like to began with, he probably gradually developed his skills like Luffy does
4) In comparison, many today, could consider to be Luffy's rival, like Smoker, Kidd, Law, Sentomaru etc, and those will eventually be known as the pirate king's rival...

But Garp is admiral level strength at his prime, proabably comparable to Sengoku, considering how shit most other vice admirals are (generally below shichibukai standard)

BlackHair
March 22, 2012, 02:31 PM
The rank Admirals were said to be the strongest force of the HQ, not each individually. So there is no canon saying Garp is definitely weaker. Im not necessarily saying he is stronger, however its way to early to make judgements.

Furthermore Roger himself stated in the fights with Garp, to have nearly killed each other many times. So apart from WB, Garp is also one of those who fought Roger to standstill. Two years ago WB was limited with past battle wounds and health problems, yet he was worthy to be feared. Garp who is not limited with health problems, shouldn't disappoint either.

Uriel
March 28, 2012, 08:48 PM
The question was soled, therefore I close this thread now. For any further discussion about Marine Tittles, please redirect to the right threads.