Requests, General Discussion and Q&A

[Mooncrow]

Hello! Welcome to the brand-new Manga Review section of MangaHelpers! For a while I noticed that it is difficult for someone thinking of getting into a series to find information on what that series is about. Most manga download sites only offer a short blurb lacking any details, while other places, like wikipedia or fansites, can’t seem to keep spoilers from even the opening summery. So, that is what we hope to correct here, by offering reviews that are detailed, while remaining spoiler-free.

Feel free to post any requests for reviews in this thread; if it's a manga I haven't already read, it's a good excuse for me to do so If I don't have any requests, I'll just do whatever random manga pops into my head^^

Also, everyone is welcomed to add in comments on existing reviews; however, I ask that you keep in mind the purpose of the forum, ie. no spoilers! And if you find yourself strongly disagreeing with my review, feel free to write up a second opinion. I make no claim of infallibility, the more voices, the better =) Just be sure and follow the template here.

Hope you enjoy!

[Impel Down]

So, do we review the entire series, or do we also get to review the chapters?

[Mooncrow]

It would be hard to do a spoiler-free review of the chapters...

[Shippuuden_09]

wow i'm so cunvused!
but i'm not cunvused at the same time......
thanks though!

[Viewtiful]

I think that a FMA review would be a great idea =D

[juUnior]

hmm so I have a question <3
- so we can comment other authors reviews? <I see it's possible > Or in one topic with, for example "Bleach" - there can be only reviews? <because in the rules-topic I don't see any 'yes' or 'no' for such thing, besides giving another review by someone else >

[Gr1mmy]

Approximately how many chapters should a manga have before it's suitable to be reviewed?

[Mooncrow]

@juUnior: yes, at least for now I want to have some feedback within the threads. I may change that if people can't keep a civil and helpful tone however.

@Gr1mmy: No set number, just make sure you keep the length in mind when you do your review.

[Manji Yoshimitsu]

So, basically, If I want to write a review about D.Gray-Man I can go ahead and make a thread? Or do I have to wait for you to make one?

[Mooncrow]

Go right ahead. I look forward to reading your review =)

[Manji Yoshimitsu]

About to post

[noonethere]

Thanks for this new section, its really nice.
I am just proposing one thing: wouldn't it be nice if after a review, the reviewer proposes other series similar to the manga reviewed?

[Mooncrow]

That is something I am hoping to implement =)

[secretAZNman19]

i hurd vinland saga is really kool and reads like berserk sorta. could someone review it?

[arg]

Cool section of the forums. I like it.
I never know about the new series that come out, all I see is weird names in the RTS forums. So, I suggest that you review new series that are published. Paying special attention to those that MH has raws of.

Keep on rockin!