In regards to all of us keeping the same pace, well, that's impossible to grant for sure. Frostymouse told me about a similar experience with that idea, and about how it didn't work. So I guess, the rule being about the comments and not about the reading pace, is the best we could have there.
---------- Post added at 07:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:44 AM ----------
If I could read just a certain amount of chapters per week, stop, then go discuss those chapters at the "book club", I certainly would. I just can't restrain myself(Once I get going with Eden, I'll probably breeze through the 18 volumes in like 3 days lol). It would be more fun if I could though. That's why I like the idea of this thread, I just don't fit into it well
---------- Post added at 11:36 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:58 AM ----------
Setting up the voting system
In regards to the voting system I have a doubt about how to articulate the system we are using, the posting system, and the spreadsheet. The spreadsheet provides us with more useful information to make a decision. We can ask the voters that have already post their votes, to use it. But some of them could be reluctant to do it. So, what if we just use both systems in a consistent way, adopting these rules:
What you think?
- We will receiving votes by any of both systems, namely, a member can post his/her preferences, or can simply add his column (and not post anything). Both things will be valid ways of vote.
- Votes C (Can read), I (Interested) and II (Very interested), of the spreadsheet will be counted for a vote in the posting system.
- The first criteria to decide will be the number of votes. If with this criteria there is a draw, we will be using as a second criteria the ratings reached in the spreadsheet, which can be different for comics with the same amount of votes.
Last edited by ukimix; March 09, 2013 at 11:41 AM.
[C] Shin Angio Onshi
[I] Eden it's an endless world
[C] Kokou no Hito
Welcome Shabrak!! I will add your votes.
I have no problem with your way of counting.
I have added a sheet to count only the vote but i let people enter there own data.
If your name is not in the list, add it after the last column and not in the middle please.
Last edited by k-dom; March 10, 2013 at 06:27 AM.
Ok. thanks again for the help. Now the spreadsheet cover all, good.
About the column added in the middle, it was me. I deleted Jammin colum, since he said he sadly has not the time for participate, and I add in his column the one of Shabrak. But well, we can keep the Jammin column in case he changed his desision.
I hope it's okay, I updated my choices on the list myself. I look forward to the next stages of this .
Btw, i don't want to read Sanctuary again xD.
Hey all, is it too late to get involved?
Actually most of the stories i read boring me in some point of them.
Well I've filed the spreadsheet with the ratings, found that I've read quite a lot of mangas on that list, although I'm quite interested by Beck, Planetes, Touch and Holyland