Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter! Celebrate another year with MH and read our yearbook.
Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (9/8/14 - 9/14/14).
Forum News: Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Hello everyone. I've come to this little theory on the origin and purpose the titans.
The story tells since the first episode that territory plays a very important role. Humans have been enclosed into the walls to be protected of the sudden appearance of the titans. But how the titans have born? I'll start with the why, imagine the world before the titans, where nations fought each other to spread territory, they needed a better way of approach, the creation of drugs to enhance human physical traits have come as an option. One of these nations started to research in this matter and ended up creating a titan, although the experiment have been a failure and the guineas pigs long forgot their humanity, although the titans did fulfilled their purpose, they would only attack humans, they would eat them and do not harm any other food supply. The first bunch of titans would be dispatched into the "Battlefield".
Another nation, aware of this bio technology, would start developing better kinds of titans, thus creating new, bigger and advanced titans as a counter-attack. The titans started to develop this way.
One of the nations located in the middle of this war, unaware of the titans, started to receive those bigger than three meters "gift". As seen in this image:
At this point, a group living in this city started to research on this matter and discovered the origin of the titans, hiring scientists from other nations to help on a defensive measure. The experiments with the titans would be forbidden and inhuman to the eyes of the people, so the church was created as a façade to the experiments and would hide any information about the titans. The experiments started and another bunch of titans were created, one that could solidify, and they thought that it would help to create walls but the titans were still brainless, the creation and development of the titans continued until they managed to hold the humanity in the titans for a small amount of time, and used them to stand tall and generate the walls, the humanity on those titans were soon lost, but they were already part of the walls. This allowed Grisha Jaeger to develop a way to create titans that would not lose their humanity at all. Soon Grisha, who would be known to cure diseases inside the walls, but in the end, he would use the diseased people in his experiments, but the drugs would take a considerate amount of time to develop.
The Titan Shifters that Grisha created would come to ears of another nation, that would persuade some of those shifters to their side. With the power of the colossal, this nation started a move: Break through the walls and take the territory. But they would not do this so harshly, they wanted other specimens of Grisha, as well as his annotations, all his documents and research about his lifetime experiments. Going on rampage would grant them the territory, but with nothing of great benefit to them in it.
Grisha, after the breakout, would give his son medication, so he could turn into a titan and protect himself from other possible attacks. He leave the walls, he have been hired by one other nations to create Shifters.
The story proceeds normally until to the point titans have been see inside the walls, just after the victory over Annie Leonhardt. In fact, there were no breakout, but the titans were just born from Conny's village, results of the experiments Grisha conducted years ago when he was "curing" an epidemy there. One new kind of titan appeared, one full of fur resembling an ape, probably one of Grisha's creation outside of the walls, he is a Shifter that is able to speak, he starts an infiltration and ended up beating up Mike Zakarius, discovering an interesting engine, the Three Dimensional Maneuver Gear technology, that proves that outside the wall know nothing about this technology. With this in hands, the Ape Titan called it a day, and decided to return to his land.
Another small theory I have is about that there is a few to no female titans. I say that female humans does not welcome the titan medication as well as the male. Thus, dying in the process or having no means of survival after being a titan, Like the supposed Conny's mother (She would not be able to move after she became a titan).
Interesting. Then, Reiner, Bertolt and Annie are from where exactly? Experiments of Grisha as well?
I say it is Grisha's. I presume they live inside the walls since before they became titans. Athough they are working for the outside of Maria. And I say that Ymir came from the outside as a titan already, but is helping in the inside.
Well, what can I say, your theory really intrigues me, also because we somewhat had a confirmation of the fact that the normal Titans we have seen so far are in reality humans in which probably the transformation in Titans has been inducted...
The timeline would not fit your theory though. Humans have presumably been within the walls for 100 years, grisha can't really be from the time titans first appeared or have taken action in such a thing as the creation of titans. Whether they were biological weapons created by several nations is kinda up there though. I would question the idea to some extent.... I mean, we have 3 different nations coming up with different sort of titans? And the one that follows the other is the one with the more advanced titans? I can imagine titans as physics defying biological weapons but if they were odds are only one nation created them and unleashed them upon the world... At least that would make more sense to me.
As as female titans.... The main issue with that theory is that we only saw one female titan who apparently went through a failed transformation. Presumably half or so in the village were female, if titanism had that sort of failure rate among women we would have seen more women like her in such a state. Heck, even the notion that titan origins are unknown would be absurd as in every case of infection half the population would end up even more deformed than regular titans.
I take it that annie's female body is the result of her being a succesful human titan. Normal titans are not necessarily male looking, they are just deformed and have no genitals. On the other hand human titans are not in any way deformed so to speak. Eren and reiner are obviously make in terms of body type at least. What we know does not necessarily imply annie is a special case, it implies annie is much like other human titans. The exception would be ymir considering she is a tiny titan with relatively weak strength and is at large deformed though.
The Titan biotechnology is being developed over the time, and every time one nation comes with a new kind of titan, as i said. This process took a considerate amount of years. Of course old scientists have been replaced, Grisha is just another scientist of his time giving continuation to the researches, resulting in the shifters. There's no time flaw.
Ahhh, I see what you mean. The idea is kinda weird though.. if they were currently at war with another nation wouldn't the members of the scouting legion know about it by now? They venture outside the walls quite often and it does seem like there are places where they are relatively safe from titans at large such as the forest. If there are nations around then odds are they are far away enough for an actual war between them to be impossible at least on horseback. Human titans are another deal and they could indeed wage war against other nations. Perhaps this is what the armored and colossal titan refer to as hometown? Although that would be weird as their initial attacks do seem to be an initiative of their own.... I don't have a problem with the idea of other settlements but I do find the idea of them currently somehow waging war on each other strange.
I would say based on the physical features of the Titans, it's not really a performance enhancement drug, but rather a means to obtain eternal life along with eliminate the need to feed to survive. If you recall a Titan does not need to eat, but they feast on humans, almost like zombies in a sense to eat in hopes of regaining humanity.
Of course what went wrong is that bv using this drug they lost their humanity and they became cursed beast sure they have eternal life but at the price of being unable to really live life, a short of twisted joke, all that time but you can't do anything with it.
THe other interesting note is that, they way their bodies appear is still a mystery, almost as if it's done through an alchemic mutation, where it gathers the atomic resources around them to create the body, which actually would make sense when you consider that a titans' body is avery hot or rather when they leave the state it leaves them not only weakened but in a very fevered state.
It may be safe to conclude that a titan transformation is a nuclear reaction, gathering the elements around them and creating the body which they hide their vessel in the back of the neck.
Though hopefully in 2-3 chpts we will learn most of the secrets am pretty sure that the reason why Eren was taken by the other titans is to find out the true origin behind everything and since he has the key to the laboratory/basement that his father left him and he's also a titan, they want him to see the truth.
Here's the thing, I've got a theory for a while now. I find it VERY hard that I am wrong about this. Spoilers follow, naturally.
About the humans inside the wall? Remember that Eren kept saying at the beginning that they're cattle? I think that's what they are. Cattle.
They are encased in the walls to reproduce. Why? To make giants. My guess is that there is someone out there wanting an army of titans. And to that end they've put community of humans, so that they can grow in numbers and then someone can come and turn then into giants. The Ape Giant is the one doing the "giantification". That is the reason people in Connie's village were turned into giants. It is also the reason why the walls are made of Them. It is ALL an experiment.
And now, let's get some things out of the way:
Eren's father: My guess is that he is a supervisor for the project OR that he's a cientist turned rogue. Reason: Apparently he suddenly appeared in Eren's town:
I know, not directly said... but the way I see it it is highly implied.
Ymir: I THINK Ymir was a high-ranked person in the society that is turning people into giants(which is also the reason she can read in another language). She, however, did not approve of the experiments. So she was cast out and was turned into a giant "for the happiness of a great many people". THAT is the reason she wanted to meet Christa/Historia. They are, in a way very similar. Proof:
http://mangafox.me/manga/shingeki_no...c018.5/10.html(and the next two pages)
http://mangafox.me/manga/shingeki_no...0/c040/25.html(and the next two pages)
http://mangafox.me/manga/shingeki_no...9/c038/31.html(and the next page)
http://mangafox.me/manga/shingeki_no...0/c040/38.html(and the next page)
Reiner and Bertholdt: Here's my guess. They are from another community of humans that got turned into giants and they, one day "woke up" and managed to control their giant powers. They want to end these experiments by killing all the humans before they get turned into giants. Hence, the reason why they broke Wall Maria. Proof? There are two. Small ones.
Look at Reiner's face when Eren said "we passed by your home village". He's thinking "what the hell does he mean by that?"
And, finally, the most relevant proof:
JUST AFTER it was discovered that there is no breach, Reiner and Bertholdt are saying that there is no need to break the walls anymore? Why is that? I'll tell you why, my friends. Because things already went to hell. People already started turning into giants and there is nothing they can do about it. The only thing they want is to Eren to follow then and to help them break other walls in other places(and maybe help them get their home town back from the giants). I think they think that Eren is also from the outside world like them(because he's a giantshifter too), but I'm not sure.
Annie: I have no idea. My guess is that she's also from the outside world and someday she bumped into Reiner and joined his cause.
The Giantification: Ok, the biggest thing here is motive. Why turn humans into giants? I have no idea, to be honest. I DO think, however, that the people turning humans into giants ARE humans. Here are my guesses:
#1: They want an army because they are in war with another country that also uses giants(which is why giants eat humans).
#2: They want an army to defeat another type of enemy that is hugely powerful.
Yeah, those were my guesses. Another reason for giants to eat humans are to keep them inside the walls, btw.
So, what do you guys think?
P.S.: I HATE the word "titan" for the creatures in this. I'm actually kind fond of "eotena" and "giant". Don't judge me.
Every time I try to figure the mystery behind Titans I have headaches. I don't think we have enough elements. We know that:
-Titans are more or less sensitive to the sunlight.
-There is a pilot mode.
-They are violent.
It also seems that only the shorter can speak
I don't know why there are so much titans but if they were all titan shifters I wonder what was their objective(at first, I thought famine was the reason) but they kill humans for the lulz and ignore other species...
Do you like norse myth? ^^
Imho there's not too much organization/s around titan factor, maybe only one.
For me it's a disease, at least at the begginning, than probably someone manage to use this disease as a bacteriological weapon in two ways:
1- Turn people against themselves from within the walls
2- Have huge soldiers with varied powers to use against the army inside the walls
Ape Titan can be a deviant specimen, born from an ape or similar, and act in solo.
All the stuff about giant writings and so on are related not to giant but to a civilization, existed before the 100 years of giant attack, maybe responsible of the disease or its use as a militay weapon.
This is my 2 cents ;D
Quote:Isn't there something wrong with that logic. To prevent this breeding of titans, we shall save the world by destroying the barrier that's protecting everybody and let's kill everybody so they don't end up turning into titans.... Wait, wot. ಠ_ಠQuote:
Logically speaking, if one were to prevent something they'd protect, not destroy.
ok, i will give some of my thoughts of the story:
I think, that the titans breed the humans, because they need them. The intelligent titans build walls for the humans and created a religious sect, that praises the walls.
Maybe titans need the humans to get children, becuase if 2 half-human half-titan (like Eren) pairs, they will just get a silly titan, that cant pair.
The young titans (Reiner, Berthold) are just playing around with humans, because they want them to fear titans.
The titans have the possilibity to destroy humankind for sure, but they wont kill them. I mean the colossal titan could just destroy all wall Entries, but he didnt.
Additionally the titans are testing mutation drugs like the armored titan or the colossal titan. Actually I think, that Erens father is one of the superior titans and maybe the one who created the armored and the colossal titan.
So the modified titans want to catch Eren for his father.
I think the Ape Titan is on a different side to Reiner and Bertholdt. Those faces on them, as well as Ymir's, when the Ape Titan passes by... there's just so much written on their face, but in my opinion for now, "the enemy boss is here" is the most fitting description for their expressions.