Not a member? Register now!
Announcements
Manga returns! Catch up with the details. Enjoy downloading, translating, and scanlating manga HERE legally!
Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter! Celebrate another year with MH and read our yearbook.
Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (8/11/14 - 8/17/14).
Forum News: Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Translations: Gintama 506 by Bomber D Rufi
New Reply
Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 63

Thread: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

  1. #1
    Registered User MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted ninjabot's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Country
    United States
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    6,069
    Post Thanks / Like

    Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    The topic says it all. Think of all of the genuine sages in the series and how they access Sage Mode.

    Naruto: Mastered Sage Mode, can absorb natural energy and balance it in record time.
    Jiraiya: Can achieve Sage Mode, but requires Ma and Pa to aid with keeping natural energy.
    Hashirama: Unknown, seems not to have any animal affiliation
    Kabuto: Perfected Snake Sage Mode to become a dragon (the highest mastery of Snake Sage Mode), automatically absorbs natural energy thanks to Juugo's DNA. Given the necessary body through strengthening himself with Orochimaru's DNA as well as the Sound 4.

    Now look at Sasuke as well as the experimentation Orochimaru did to him.

    Has mastered CS, proving that he has mastered natural energy (atleast the kind that comes from Juugo).
    Has Juugo's DNA inside of his body (the very same DNA that allows one to automatically absorb natural energy, much like Kabuto).
    Is currently manipulating the natural energy being extended to him by Juugo, using it to power up his Susanoo (proving that combining natural energy with his chakra to create Senjutsu is within his power).
    Has gained more and more strength the more he has gotten angry (he doesn't have a Senju class body, but he has mammoth chakra reserves amongst his clan and his strength only grows with more hatred).
    Was stated to have made Juugo's chakra his own by Orochimaru

    Now let's look at what is needed to be a full fledged Sage.
    1: A large chakra reserve
    2: The ability to sense natural energy.
    3: Good enough chakra manipulation ability to mix natural, physical, and mental energies to make Sage Chakra.

    Sasuke has all of these. So back to the original question: why can't Sasuke become a sage?

  2. #2
    Registered User 上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member someguy0830's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Country
    United States
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    424
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    2: The ability to sense natural energy.
    3: Good enough chakra manipulation ability to mix natural, physical, and mental energies to make Sage Chakra.
    Uh, what? When has Sasuke ever displayed either of these abilities? And don't say his Cursed Seal is an example of 3. That process is involuntary and Sasuke didn't even know how it worked when he used it.

    All glory to the Hypnotoad!

    It is ridiculous to think that video games influence children. If Pac-Man affected kids born in the eighties, we should have a generation of teenagers who run around in darkened rooms and eat pills while listening to monotonous music.

  3. #3
    Registered User 英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member marshall313's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Country
    Marine Headquarters
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    2,365
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Wow. So sasuke can sense natural energy? And he had a large chakra reserve? Since when?

    Why can't sasuke become a sage? It's the same as madara can't also become a sage despite having hashirama's DNA/power.

    Sasuke was destined to awaken his rinnegan. So it's kinda ridiculous if kishi would give him the sage mode.

    Don't be a greedy fan. sasuke's power is all about sharingan/doujutsu, while naruto's power is all about chakra/body. Wanting sasuke to have the sage mode is almost the same as wanting naruto to have the sharingan.

    Well, if large chakra reserve and good enough chakra manipulation are enough to become a full fledged sage, then tobirama, tsunade or any uzumaki could become a sage.

  4. #4
    Registered User 英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member Suzaku's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Country
    United States
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    666
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Because he hasn't undergone any sort of senjutsu training at all.

    Simple answer.

  5. #5
    Registered User MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted ninjabot's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Country
    United States
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    6,069
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Quote Originally Posted by someguy0830
    Uh, what? When has Sasuke ever displayed either of these abilities? And don't say his Cursed Seal is an example of 3. That process is involuntary and Sasuke didn't even know how it worked when he used it.
    The ability to sense natural energy? Quite simply, you can't use natural energy if you can't feel it, unless you're of Juugo's clan. Even then, Juugo can still feel the natural energy to some extent outside of his CS. It's how he speaks to animals. It's the absolute first step in achieving Sage Mode (remember what Naruto did with the oil?).

    As for number 3, if it was involuntary he would go into Curse Seal without activating it of his own volition. It would work identical to Juugo's insanity: only happening when his body can no longer maintain the natural energy within him. Likewise, why do you keep ignoring that Orochimaru states Sasuke made the chakra his own?

    Quote Originally Posted by Suzaku
    Because he hasn't undergone any sort of senjutsu training at all.
    So what you're saying is that what's happening in the current chapter (Sasuke syphoning Juugo's chakra to use the natural energy within it) is a complete fluke, and he had absolutely no idea it was possible until this exact moment?

    The fact that he knew to what extent he could manipulate the natural energy, aswell as Orochimaru's flatout admittance that he had experience manipulating it back when he injected him is proof that he has indeed trained with natural energy (in the form of Juugo's chakra, which was laced with it).

  6. #6
    Registered User 上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member someguy0830's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Country
    United States
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    424
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    The ability to sense natural energy? Quite simply, you can't use natural energy if you can't feel it, unless you're of Juugo's clan. Even then, Juugo can still feel the natural energy to some extent outside of his CS. It's how he speaks to animals. It's the absolute first step in achieving Sage Mode (remember what Naruto did with the oil?).
    Pain would disagree with you, and it cost him a body demonstrating the fact. Also, nowhere is it said that Juugo's animal whispering is a result of his nature affinity. A logical connection, I grant you, but we've never seen Naruto do this and he's a whole lot better at it than Juugo.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    As for number 3, if it was involuntary he would go into Curse Seal without activating it of his own volition. It would work identical to Juugo's insanity: only happening when his body can no longer maintain the natural energy within him. Likewise, why do you keep ignoring that Orochimaru states Sasuke made the chakra his own?
    You misunderstand. The process is involuntary. Sasuke controls the seal. The seal gathers the energy. Sasuke isn't the one gathering the energy, and thus cannot see or properly handle it absent that ability. And I'm not ignoring it, you're just focusing on it to the exclusion of the facts. Orochimaru says, right up front, that Sasuke's former possession of the seal is why this is working. If Sasuke did not have the seal, he would not only be unable to see natural energy (and flat out cannot now, anyway), Juugo's chakra either wouldn't mix or would immediately kill him.

    Remember, Orochimaru had to kill a lot of people to get the seal working right, and there were all those psychos at the place Juugo was kept. Sasuke's seal is the product of many refinements to Juugo's ability.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    So what you're saying is that what's happening in the current chapter (Sasuke syphoning Juugo's chakra to use the natural energy within it) is a complete fluke, and he had absolutely no idea it was possible until this exact moment?

    The fact that he knew to what extent he could manipulate the natural energy, aswell as Orochimaru's flatout admittance that he had experience manipulating it back when he injected him is proof that he has indeed trained with natural energy (in the form of Juugo's chakra, which was laced with it).
    Just because Sasuke knew this would work (because they've done something similar before), and knows what the energy is (because Kabuto told him), does not mean Sasuke has the slightest idea how to use natural energy.

    All glory to the Hypnotoad!

    It is ridiculous to think that video games influence children. If Pac-Man affected kids born in the eighties, we should have a generation of teenagers who run around in darkened rooms and eat pills while listening to monotonous music.

  7. Like 1 Member(s) likes this post
  8. #7
    Registered User MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted ninjabot's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Country
    United States
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    6,069
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Quote Originally Posted by marshall313
    Wanting sasuke to have the sage mode is almost the same as wanting naruto to have the sharingan
    Not really, because Sage Mode isn't a genetically received kekkei genkai. Anyone can be a sage provided they have the body for it. And there's more than one way to achieve it, as shown by Kabuto. I can't for the life of me figure out why Sage Mode is considered a Naruto exclusive jutsu.

    I think the problem here is that people, when they think of Sage Mode, keep thinking of the "legit" way of gaining it. Training for it. Kabuto trained for Sage Mode as well, but it's not what gave it to him, because he still needed the body, which he only received through experimentation. Sasuke has a body that's compatible with natural energy to the point that he can use Senjutsu, as shown in the recent chapter. His body is also far stronger than it was when Orochimaru first attempted the experiment. All he needs is a way to absorb the natural energy on his own (which should be the flesh Juugo placed in his chest a few hundred chapters ago).

    ---------- Post added at 05:26 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:00 AM ----------

    Quote Originally Posted by someguy0830
    Pain would disagree with you, and it cost him a body demonstrating the fact. Also, nowhere is it said that Juugo's animal whispering is a result of his nature affinity. A logical connection, I grant you, but we've never seen Naruto do this and he's a whole lot better at it than Juugo.
    Pein disagrees that you can't use natural energy if you can't sense it? Are you implying he used natural energy before despite being unable to sense it? I don't get what you're saying here.

    Also, Naruto activates Sage Mode, which is different from being naturally in tune to natural energy. He also hasn't been a sage as long as Juugo has been in tune with nature.

    Quote Quote:
    You misunderstand. The process is involuntary. Sasuke controls the seal. The seal gathers the energy. Sasuke isn't the one gathering the energy, and thus cannot see or properly handle it absent that ability.
    ...the seal that is no longer in Sasuke's body? The seal that Juugo doesn't have because his body has no seal that leads to his transformation, because it's a natural occurence for him? You can't give the Curse Seal this feat because Sasuke no longer has the Curse Seal.
    Even wierder, Kabuto isn't the one gathering his natural energy either: his body does so automatically thanks to Juugo's DNA. So why can Kabuto use it to achieve Sage Mode, but the thought of Sasuke doing the same seems so hard to accept?

    Quote Quote:
    And I'm not ignoring it, you're just focusing on it to the exclusion of the facts. Orochimaru says, right up front, that Sasuke's former possession of the seal is why this is working. If Sasuke did not have the seal, he would not only be unable to see natural energy (and flat out cannot now, anyway), Juugo's chakra either wouldn't mix or would immediately kill him.
    Orochimaru flatout says that before, he injected Sasuke with some of Juugo's chakra, and he made it his own. He says that that is the reason he's capable of performing the same feat again here, because he had already done it once before with his body. The only difference is that now he's doing it with his Susanoo. You could blame the previous event on his access to the Curse Seal, but not this one because, as stated before, he no longer has the Curse Seal. Juugo is giving Sasuke his chakra. And Sasuke is using it to give his Susanoo Senjutsu properties. This could not be done if Sasuke had not previously learned to "make Juugo's chakra his own." The training is done. He's already learned to manipulate the Senjutsu transformation obtained via the Curse Seal. That is controlling natural energy.

    Quote Quote:
    Remember, Orochimaru had to kill a lot of people to get the seal working right, and there were all those psychos at the place Juugo was kept. Sasuke's seal is the product of many refinements to Juugo's ability.
    Right. Except he no longer has the seal. He no longer has the tool that forceably pumps his body with natural energy and transforms him into his CS form. So how does he do it now without the Curse Seal? Juugo gives him the natural energy. But he's just giving it to him. Sasuke has to manipulate it (unless you're capable of proving Juugo can activate Sasuke's Susanoo for him).

    Even back when he had the CS Sasuke needed to learn to manipulate it lest his will be corroded, so even then when he had the CS "automatically" controlling the natural energy for him, he was still repressing it's mind controlling side effect. No matter how you want to look at it, the natural energy of the CS was Sasuke's to control. As it is again here.

    Quote Quote:
    Just because Sasuke knew this would work (because they've done something similar before), and knows what the energy is (because Kabuto told him), does not mean Sasuke has the slightest idea how to use natural energy.
    No. Sasuke using natural energy does though. And would you look at that! He's using it in the current chapter. He even used it years ago during one of Orochimaru's experiments. So there you go. I don't know how you plan to prove one can use natural energy without knowing what it is (as in, sensing it during it's application, as we both know what happens when you get too much of it), since creating senjutsu still requires chakra control and balancing of energies... you'd have to figure out some way to segue right past the rules of chakra control to think up a way for Sasuke to use jutsu with natural energy in it without actually creating the jutsu himself. And his Susanoo is exclusive to him, so I'm not sure you can find away to blame Senjutsu Susanoo on Juugo.

    I feel like people are thinking Orochimaru's words don't represent a different experiment, but rather the one moment when Sasuke first recieved the CS. And that would be the mistake that's throwing everyone off.
    Last edited by ninjabot; September 27, 2013 at 12:29 AM.

  9. #8
    MangaHelper 伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member kkck's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    wherever cookies can't get to me...(as if such a place existed...)
    Country
    Galactic Empire
    Posts
    18,545
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Sasuke cannot sense natural energy. Even though the CS used to make him some form of sage he never really displayed anything which suggested he understood what natural energy is. Even recently he didn't know anything about it at all until he heard what everyone was talking about. As far as a large chakra reserve goes, who knows. He was able to abuse his MS before getting the EMS and we know for a fact doing that is considerably taxing on the body. Kakashi has a very limited use of his kamui and itachi while he was alive got tired very quickly from using his eyes as far as we saw. Getting the EMS apparently reduced the strain all these techniques have on sasuke though. I guess a case can be made for sasuke having quite a bit of chakra but at this stage talking about a massive chakra reserve seems to be a bit much IMO.I guess it depends on the kind of sage he can become. Its more likely that he becomes a variation of what jugo is rather than a sage like naruto.

  10. Like 1 Member(s) likes this post
  11. #9
    Registered User 上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member someguy0830's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Country
    United States
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    424
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    Pein disagrees that you can't use natural energy if you can't sense it? Are you implying he used natural energy before despite being unable to sense it? I don't get what you're saying here.
    Pein used his chakra absorbing body on Naruto. Naruto started gathering up a ton of (unbalanced) natural energy. Dead Pein body. If you absolutely needed to be able to sense it to use it, then Juugo would not be able to.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    Also, Naruto activates Sage Mode, which is different from being naturally in tune to natural energy. He also hasn't been a sage as long as Juugo has been in tune with nature.
    Naturally in tune with nature also turns Juugo into a psycho. Naruto can actually sense and control that energy. I'm just not seeing the connection.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    ...the seal that is no longer in Sasuke's body? The seal that Juugo doesn't have because his body has no seal that leads to his transformation, because it's a natural occurence for him? You can't give the Curse Seal this feat because Sasuke no longer has the Curse Seal.
    Even wierder, Kabuto isn't the one gathering his natural energy either: his body does so automatically thanks to Juugo's DNA. So why can Kabuto use it to achieve Sage Mode, but the thought of Sasuke doing the same seems so hard to accept?
    Irrelevant. He had the seal. That is all that is important. His compatibility with the seal, and whatever lingering effects it's had on his body, is why this is working. Orochimaru has said so, Juugo said so way back when he healed Sasuke's chest.

    As for Kabuto, there's a big difference between him and Sasuke, and that's the simple fact that Kabuto actually knows how to use Sage Mode. He is using Juugo's DNA to get around the movement restriction, but nevertheless he knows how to mix and control that energy. Sasuke does not.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    Orochimaru flatout says that before, he injected Sasuke with some of Juugo's chakra, and he made it his own. He says that that is the reason he's capable of performing the same feat again here, because he had already done it once before with his body. The only difference is that now he's doing it with his Susanoo. You could blame the previous event on his access to the Curse Seal, but not this one because, as stated before, he no longer has the Curse Seal. Juugo is giving Sasuke his chakra. And Sasuke is using it to give his Susanoo Senjutsu properties. This could not be done if Sasuke had not previously learned to "make Juugo's chakra his own." The training is done. He's already learned to manipulate the Senjutsu transformation obtained via the Curse Seal. That is controlling natural energy.
    Still not the same thing, because Sasuke isn't controlling anything but the seal. When Sasuke got the seal, he had to go through that death box thing just to make sure it wouldn't kill him, and after that he had control of the seal. At no point has Sasuke ever had control over natural energy, only the seal which is a glorified power booster. As noted above, his current lack of a seal doesn't matter. The compatibility remains.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    Right. Except he no longer has the seal. He no longer has the tool that forceably pumps his body with natural energy and transforms him into his CS form. So how does he do it now without the Curse Seal? Juugo gives him the natural energy. But he's just giving it to him. Sasuke has to manipulate it (unless you're capable of proving Juugo can activate Sasuke's Susanoo for him).
    Sasuke doesn't have to do anything. If he weren't compatible with the seal, Juugo's healing would not have worked. Same thing here. Do you think he intentionally made the cursed seal pattern on his Susanoo? I seriously doubt that.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    Even back when he had the CS Sasuke needed to learn to manipulate it lest his will be corroded, so even then when he had the CS "automatically" controlling the natural energy for him, he was still repressing it's mind controlling side effect. No matter how you want to look at it, the natural energy of the CS was Sasuke's to control. As it is again here.
    That's proof of a strong will, not of his ability to control the energy. Sasuke used his own chakra to surpress Orochimaru later on. Doesn't mean he could control Orochimaru, even though it did grant him a limited version of Orochimaru's powers.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    No. Sasuke using natural energy does though. And would you look at that! He's using it in the current chapter. He even used it years ago during one of Orochimaru's experiments. So there you go. I don't know how you plan to prove one can use natural energy without knowing what it is, since creating senjutsu still requires chakra control and balancing of energies... you'd have to figure out some way to segue right past the rules of chakra control to think up a way for Sasuke to use jutsu with natural energy in it without actually creating the jutsu himself. And his Susanoo is exclusive to him, so I'm not sure you can find away to blame Senjutsu Susanoo on Juugo.
    Sasuke didn't know the seal used natural energy when he got it. He still used it. Sasuke didn't know it used natural energy until long after he lost it. Sasuke isn't the one gathering the energy, or even mixing it. That's being done for him.

    As for Susanoo, Sasuke/Sasuke's Susanoo might as well be the same thing where compatibility is concerned. Theoretically, Juugo could grab Sasuke and upgrade him to CS2 directly. Instead he's funneling his chakra into Susanoo and that gets the upgrade.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    I feel like people are thinking Orochimaru's words don't represent a different experiment, but rather the one moment when Sasuke first recieved the CS. And that would be the mistake that's throwing everyone off.
    So suddenly there's another experiment where Sasuke gets Juugo's chakra, when Orochimaru states in the same panel that Juugo's cursed seal is senjutsu? Not buying it. Why would it refer to anything other than when he was given the seal?

    All glory to the Hypnotoad!

    It is ridiculous to think that video games influence children. If Pac-Man affected kids born in the eighties, we should have a generation of teenagers who run around in darkened rooms and eat pills while listening to monotonous music.

  12. #10
    Registered User MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted ninjabot's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Country
    United States
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    6,069
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Quote Originally Posted by kkck
    Sasuke cannot sense natural energy. Even though the CS used to make him some form of sage he never really displayed anything which suggested he understood what natural energy is. Even recently he didn't know anything about it at all until he heard what everyone was talking about.
    Sasuke seemed suprised that Juugo had mastered Sage Mode, not that it existed.

    Quote Quote:
    As far as a large chakra reserve goes, who knows. He was able to abuse his MS before getting the EMS and we know for a fact doing that is considerably taxing on the body. Kakashi has a very limited use of his kamui and itachi while he was alive got tired very quickly from using his eyes as far as we saw. Getting the EMS apparently reduced the strain all these techniques have on sasuke though. I guess a case can be made for sasuke having quite a bit of chakra but at this stage talking about a massive chakra reserve seems to be a bit much IMO.I guess it depends on the kind of sage he can become. Its more likely that he becomes a variation of what jugo is rather than a sage like naruto.
    Though it's my mistake for not specifying, I'm still referring to a Sage like Kabuto, not Naruto.

    Quote Originally Posted by someguy0830
    Pein used his chakra absorbing body on Naruto. Naruto started gathering up a ton of (unbalanced) natural energy. Dead Pein body. If you absolutely needed to be able to sense it to use it, then Juugo would not be able to.
    So like I said: you can't use natural energy and not be able to sense it. Hungry Ghost realm wasn't using Naruto's natural energy. He was absorbing it. And that's not arguing semantics.

    Quote Quote:
    Naturally in tune with nature also turns Juugo into a psycho. Naruto can actually sense and control that energy. I'm just not seeing the connection.
    Fair enough.

    Quote Quote:
    Irrelevant. He had the seal. That is all that is important.
    If you could even begin to prove that that has anything to do with being able to manipulate natural energy now, then yeah. You don't retain abilities you've lost. If he did, he could activate CS on his Susanoo without needing Juugo's aid. So... you're flatout wrong on this one.

    Quote Quote:
    His compatibility with the seal, and whatever lingering effects it's had on his body, is why this is working. Orochimaru has said so, Juugo said so way back when he healed Sasuke's chest.
    Then you agree with me that the reason he's capable of manipulating natural energy is because he's had experience doing so before, thanks to the CS? That's what I'm getting at: Sasuke's compatibility with the natural energy in Juugo's chakra is thanks to the mastery of the CS that he gained through the training prior to this moment in the manga. The reason he was capable of recieving Juugo's flesh during the fight with Bee is also only possible thanks to the CS mastery he accrued in the past. He has tons of experience with natural energy. You can't say he has no experience manipulating natural energy, and then use his experience manipulating natural energy as proof that he can't manipulate natural energy.

    Quote Quote:
    As for Kabuto, there's a big difference between him and Sasuke, and that's the simple fact that Kabuto actually knows how to use Sage Mode. He is using Juugo's DNA to get around the movement restriction, but nevertheless he knows how to mix and control that energy. Sasuke does not.
    If he did not, he could not control his Curse Seal to the level that he could use partial transformations, and completely negate the will corrosion effect. Keep in mind I'm not saying he can go straight into Sage Mode from right now. Just that he has all the tools ready to do so. If someone told him in the next chapter how to do it, it wouldn't take him a year or two to do it. He could do it in this very fight, as he has steady access to natural energy, a (most likely) strong enough body, and experience manipulating natural energy.

    Quote Quote:
    Still not the same thing, because Sasuke isn't controlling anything but the seal. When Sasuke got the seal, he had to go through that death box thing just to make sure it wouldn't kill him, and after that he had control of the seal. At no point has Sasuke ever had control over natural energy, only the seal which is a glorified power booster. As noted above, his current lack of a seal doesn't matter. The compatibility remains.
    If Sasuke never had control over natural energy, then the CS activations would be automatic, and he could not do partial transformations. Juugo's chakra is laced with natural energy, that's why adding it to Sasuke allowed him to give his Susanoo senjutsu properties. If Sasuke could not manipulate natural energy, his Susanoo would just be a plain Susanoo right now.

    Quote Quote:
    Sasuke doesn't have to do anything. If he weren't compatible with the seal, Juugo's healing would not have worked. Same thing here. Do you think he intentionally made the cursed seal pattern on his Susanoo? I seriously doubt that.
    I don't think he intentionally made it, I think it naturally came from the combination of he and Juugo's chakra... just like with his own CS, since it is also a combination of he and Juugo's chakra. Sasuke's CS manifests as flames and a tengu like nose tatoo thing. Juugo's manifests as blocks. If Juugo had simply been imposing his chakra on the Susanoo and transforming it on his own, it would take on Juugo's transformation look, not Sasuke's.
    If it transforms to level 2 next chapter, it'll have wings. Thanks to Sasuke.

    Quote Quote:
    That's proof of a strong will, not of his ability to control the energy. Sasuke used his own chakra to surpress Orochimaru later on. Doesn't mean he could control Orochimaru, even though it did grant him a limited version of Orochimaru's powers.
    The energy is what drives the insanity/loss of will. He had to overcome it or else he'd lose to it. Having a strong will helps you overcome hardships sure, but I don't see it helping you overcome mind control. How many people have you seen break out of Tsukuyomi just because they really really wanted to be out of it?
    Sasuke didn't know the seal used natural energy when he got it. He still used it. Sasuke didn't know it used natural energy until long after he lost it. Sasuke isn't the one gathering the energy, or even mixing it. That's being done for him.

    Quote Quote:
    As for Susanoo, Sasuke/Sasuke's Susanoo might as well be the same thing where compatibility is concerned. Theoretically, Juugo could grab Sasuke and upgrade him to CS2 directly. Instead he's funneling his chakra into Susanoo and that gets the upgrade.
    I'm not sure Juugo has enough natural energy in his body for such a transformation. Having enough energy in his body to transform Sasuke is easily doable, but enough to transform a giant Susanoo? How strong do you think Juugo is?

    Quote Quote:
    So suddenly there's another experiment where Sasuke gets Juugo's chakra, when Orochimaru states in the same panel that Juugo's cursed seal is senjutsu? Not buying it. Why would it refer to anything other than when he was given the seal?
    Translation, quite simply:

    http://narutobase.net/manga/Naruto/648/3

    When he injects Juugo's chakra into Sasuke. Not when he applies the Curse Seal (which is a combination of Orochimaru and Juugo's chakras). He even states that Sasuke was able to release the CS's power just from having Juugo's chakra placed in him. This is why I say he manipulates the natural energy on his own, because he was able to use the CS's power with Juugo as the catalyst, not the seal. This is how he knew that his Susanoo could do the same (use Juugo's chakra to activate the CS without actually having the CS). Because he did it once with his body as well.

  13. #11
    Registered User 上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member someguy0830's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Country
    United States
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    424
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    So like I said: you can't use natural energy and not be able to sense it. Hungry Ghost realm wasn't using Naruto's natural energy. He was absorbing it. And that's not arguing semantics.
    But it does prove my point that not being able to sense it doesn't prevent someone from being able to absorb it. Sasuke cannot sense it, but all the time he had that cursed seal, the seal was absorbing it when active.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    If you could even begin to prove that that has anything to do with being able to manipulate natural energy now, then yeah. You don't retain abilities you've lost. If he did, he could activate CS on his Susanoo without needing Juugo's aid. So... you're flatout wrong on this one.
    I've said this quite a few times already. Why did that flesh transfer thing work? Because Sasuke was compatible with the seal. He did not have the seal, but it didn't matter. The compatibility mattered. That isn't an interpretation. That is exactly the reason Juugo gave when he did it. That is no different than what he's doing now.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    Then you agree with me that the reason he's capable of manipulating natural energy is because he's had experience doing so before, thanks to the CS? That's what I'm getting at: Sasuke's compatibility with the natural energy in Juugo's chakra is thanks to the mastery of the CS that he gained through the training prior to this moment in the manga. The reason he was capable of recieving Juugo's flesh during the fight with Bee is also only possible thanks to the CS mastery he accrued in the past. He has tons of experience with natural energy. You can't say he has no experience manipulating natural energy, and then use his experience manipulating natural energy as proof that he can't manipulate natural energy.
    As I've said, the reason this whole thing is working is because of his experience with the seal. He has zero experience manipulating natural energy. The seal does the work, and Sasuke manipulates the seal.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    If he did not, he could not control his Curse Seal to the level that he could use partial transformations, and completely negate the will corrosion effect. Keep in mind I'm not saying he can go straight into Sage Mode from right now. Just that he has all the tools ready to do so. If someone told him in the next chapter how to do it, it wouldn't take him a year or two to do it. He could do it in this very fight, as he has steady access to natural energy, a (most likely) strong enough body, and experience manipulating natural energy.
    Still not seeing where you're getting the idea that he's manipulating natural energy. If it were raw natural energy, it would have killed him straight off the bat. That's what happened to the Pein body. Juugo would likewise be dead. Juugo's cells offer a unique alternative. Juugo can't control that energy, but instead of dying, his body mutates and he can control that. Sasuke is piggybacking off that right now. Juugo's pre-mixed chakra is merging with his own, hence the seal pattern.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    If Sasuke never had control over natural energy, then the CS activations would be automatic, and he could not do partial transformations. Juugo's chakra is laced with natural energy, that's why adding it to Sasuke allowed him to give his Susanoo senjutsu properties. If Sasuke could not manipulate natural energy, his Susanoo would just be a plain Susanoo right now.
    The seal =/= natural energy. You're treating them as one and the same. Juugo gathers the energy all the time, hence why he goes crazy. Orochimaru saw this and was like "wow, I want this, but the crazy thing is annoying." So he makes these seals, which you can turn on and off, giving control to that power. The seal is the control, the power itself comes just by turning it on.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    The energy is what drives the insanity/loss of will. He had to overcome it or else he'd lose to it. Having a strong will helps you overcome hardships sure, but I don't see it helping you overcome mind control. How many people have you seen break out of Tsukuyomi just because they really really wanted to be out of it?
    It does in large amounts, yes, but Sasuke has control over the seal. He doesn't have Juugo's problem of constant buildup.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    I'm not sure Juugo has enough natural energy in his body for such a transformation. Having enough energy in his body to transform Sasuke is easily doable, but enough to transform a giant Susanoo? How strong do you think Juugo is?
    That wasn't quite what I meant. Assuming Juugo were to actually try that, however, I bet it would take a prohibitively large amount of time (Juugo never runs out of natural energy, but the rate would definitely be too slow).


    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    When he injects Juugo's chakra into Sasuke. Not when he applies the Curse Seal (which is a combination of Orochimaru and Juugo's chakras). He even states that Sasuke was able to release the CS's power just from having Juugo's chakra placed in him. This is why I say he manipulates the natural energy on his own, because he was able to use the CS's power with Juugo as the catalyst, not the seal. This is how he knew that his Susanoo could do the same (use Juugo's chakra to activate the CS without actually having the CS). Because he did it once with his body as well.
    That seems a stretch of interpretation. Injecting Juugo's chakra could just as easily refer to when he got the seal. After all, if he hadn't been able to do that, he'd be dead like all those other test subjects.

    All glory to the Hypnotoad!

    It is ridiculous to think that video games influence children. If Pac-Man affected kids born in the eighties, we should have a generation of teenagers who run around in darkened rooms and eat pills while listening to monotonous music.

  14. #12
    Banned 有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Country
    Croatia
    Age
    25
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    3,936
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    I don't think he has a large enough chakra pool. I mean, by general standards he has one, but not in Sage's point of view, not yet at least.

  15. #13
    Registered User 英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member KungPaoChicken's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Location
    Earth
    Country
    The Wall
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    659
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Or maybe he wasn't introduced to the concept of attaining sage mode?

  16. #14
    Registered User 英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member marshall313's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Country
    Marine Headquarters
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    2,365
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    Not really, because Sage Mode isn't a genetically received kekkei genkai. Anyone can be a sage provided they have the body for it. And there's more than one way to achieve it, as shown by Kabuto. I can't for the life of me figure out why Sage Mode is considered a Naruto exclusive jutsu.
    But what if the sage mode is indeed genetically received kekkei genkai? I think it's safe to assume that sage mode can be considered as senju or the younger son's descendance exclusive jutsu. Well, I think the reason why kabuto was able to master the snake sage mode is because of uzumaki's amazing chakra/life force. Maybe jugo's DNA alone isn't enough to master the senjutsu chakra. Yupz, even orochimaru can't achieve the sage mode even though he himself has a large amount of chakra.

    Quote Originally Posted by ninjabot View Post
    I think the problem here is that people, when they think of Sage Mode, keep thinking of the "legit" way of gaining it. Training for it. Kabuto trained for Sage Mode as well, but it's not what gave it to him, because he still needed the body, which he only received through experimentation. Sasuke has a body that's compatible with natural energy to the point that he can use Senjutsu, as shown in the recent chapter. His body is also far stronger than it was when Orochimaru first attempted the experiment. All he needs is a way to absorb the natural energy on his own (which should be the flesh Juugo placed in his chest a few hundred chapters ago).
    Not really. I think sasuke's body isn't compatible with natural energy. By having jugo's flesh isn't enough for sasuke to use senjutsu. The same as madara, obito and yamato by having hashirama's DNA. But then again, they didn't gained hashirama's sage mode/senjutsu.

    Well, orochimaru right now is like a father to sasuke. So anything would be possible right now.

  17. #15
    Registered User 英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member LnDRash's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Eorzea
    Country
    Germany
    Age
    29
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    2,379
    Post Thanks / Like

    Re: Why can't Sasuke become a Sage?

    Quote Originally Posted by Roman View Post
    I don't think he has a large enough chakra pool. I mean, by general standards he has one, but not in Sage's point of view, not yet at least.
    Well... Jiraiya was a sage and while he had a large chakra pool, I doubt it was as gargantuan as Naruto's or Hashirama's. He simply had a large chakra pool compared to your average joe... something that can also be said about Sasuke by now.

    @general topic

    I'd say there's no reason why Sasuke should be incapable of learning sage mode if he sets his mind to it other then if Kishimoto doesn't want him to.
    Click here for what I consider the definition of "simply brilliant"

    Quote Originally Posted by syx View Post
    He was once a very charismatic, kind, special and inspiring person. LnDRash was a premium brand, now this brand is called LnDTRash!

New Reply
Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts