Like I said, I like the bottom one the most but the majority has spoken (and in the end your voice is the most important). Truth be told though the top one is also great so I'll have no complaints if you choose this one.
@ Number A
For the next round, Miria needs a better picture. Here are my favorites.
I think, the first pic is perfect for the tournament.
Last edited by Bayuga; April 20, 2014 at 07:10 AM.
ANNOUNCEMENT: Hello and welcome to the second round of this glorious tournament~! Many of you I'm sure will have noticed that we've reached the halfway point and from here on in things get serious. Every contestant remaining has a victory to their name but with half the field gone the competition is far more intense. In this round, everyone's favourite colourhead squares off against Alicia who is as beautiful as she is deadly while Galatea the Shipped-With-Everyone (seriously, she's like a Claymore Draco Malfoy) takes on Hysteria of the Awesome Hair. How do I call this? Well, Clarice is sort of cute but I think she only made it through to this round because Rigaldo was the wrong gender for this tournament and will be knocked out by Alicia. As for the other round, Hysteria is handsome but Galatea makes sexy nun look classy. You can't beat that.
As for Round 1.8, well, Miria prevailed against Luciela 60/40 and Octavia ousted Cassandra 62/38. Looks like it's not a good day for girls who look like cats :/
It's strange, that only Miria's pictures make problems, but the pics of Teresa and Galatea not ...
The current image is nice, but not good enough for the next round.
And i don't see a problem with this pic, it has a similar size.
This image is also good.
Please, try it at least.
Last edited by Bayuga; April 20, 2014 at 08:51 AM.
Ok, let's be fair
Another good picture of Octavia
Not sure if her humanoid part of her awaken form could be used or not, I like her awaken form hair better
A better picture of Deneve if she advances
I'm proposing that color pictures to be used during the semi-final and the championship match.
ANNOUNCEMENT: I would like to take this time to fully explain what makes a picture suitable for this contest. I'm doing this so that you guys understand where I'm coming from and will be able to suggest pictures I can use. I really, really appreciate your enthusiasm and want to be able to reward it. With that in mind, here is a guide to what makes a good image (roughly in order of importance).
0. It has to be nice. Goes without saying ^_^
1. It has to be the right shape. You all know the definitive Galatea image, right? The one from chapter 74 when she's revealed to be blind?
Look at what happens when you crop it down.
See how it just doesn't work? Her beautiful hair is basically GONE as is any sense of her face shape. Sure she's smiling but the grace and power of the original image just don't come through. Even though the original is fantastic, it doesn't resolve itself well into the shape that every image in this contest MUST fit and so isn't suitable.
Shape can NOT be changed. In order for me to be able to format everything properly all images must be in a 2:3 width:height ratio. Breaking this would mean I'd need to change everything from the board to the matchup template and it jsut isn't worth it.
2. It has to be true to the spirit of the character. This is sort of wooly and subjective and I'll make exceptions for pictures that are otherwise really nice (The Death of Ophelia by Norihiro Yagi would be an example of this) but I do want characters in images to look like themselves.
3. It has to show the character's face decently well. Remember the first Teresa pic I had? This one?
It's a nice pic, but it gets small and awkward when scaled down to matchup size. The new one is much better suited to the format of this contest. Go check the board and see what I mean.
4. New art style is better than old. This criteria is fairly flexible and the new Teresa pic is a good example of what I mean. Her features just work together a little more nicely than they did back in the day.
5. Resolution. This becomes really important really fast if printing dots are involved. Check out this pic of Cassandra's adorable friend who totally should be have been in round 0. See how it's ruined by dots? See also how the new pic of Teresa isn't?
All contest profile pics are 300x450 pixels. The closer a source image is to this, the better. Don't worry about resizing, I've got photoshop and can do this myself. In my experience, anything with a width less than 200 px doesn't blow up well. Larger is no problem.
6. It has to be better than what's already there. Changing a pic requires effort and I'm not going to do it if I don't think it will make a difference.
There are other considerations, but these are the big ones.
Oh, this is only relevant to the contest if you're me but GOOGLE DRIVE CAN BE USED FOR IMAGE HOSTING!!!
---------- Post added at 01:08 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:05 AM ----------
assembled a shortlist of images I knew could work and got people to comment on those? I was screening for shape). Also, both images were better than what I already had: the Galatea one shows more of her head and hair and the Teresa one is more stylistically consistent with the other images and more clearly shows her face.
Another factor which might affect Miria particularly is that her hair, especially when she puts it in a ponytail, is very bushy (it's full of secrets!!!). When drawing her, Yagi generally goes for shots that are wide rather than long so he can get her whole head. It makes sense in the manga but it does make things harder for this contest where the preference is shots that are long rather than wide.
and for the sake of comparison, here's the current Miria profile pic
The image on the top left is blurrier than the current pic so I wouldn't change it for that. Also, it shows less of Miria's head giving you less of a sense of what she looks like. The top right image is almost too far from her head (and I can't crop it in closer without lowering the resolution). The bottom right one is easily the best of the bunch you suggested but it strikes me as being almost too close up. The current image gives you a clearer sense of what Miria looks like. Bottom right is out of the question as it's too low resolution.
Sorry to be so harsh, I'm answering this as thoroughly as I am to show I take your input seriously and am not just blowing you off because I can't be bothered.
---------- Post added at 01:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:08 PM ----------
Here's what matchups 2.3B and 2.4A look like if we use undercovers. I would use the undercover images in those matchups only and revert back to default images when the go up against a character who Yagi hasn't drawn naked.
My only concern about this is that beauty and sexual attractiveness aren't quite the same thing and I don't want to completely alienate our straight female and gay male voters (my sister, for one, isn't that keen on the undercover pics). Also, if we wanna get fussy about being true to characters getting naked isn't really Miria's style. That said, variety is the spice of life and I like image variation so I'll change them up ^_^
Last edited by Number A; April 21, 2014 at 02:16 AM.
I'd say those pics give them an unfair advantage Too bad we don't have nude/suggestive pics for all the cast, it'd even the field.
This is a beauty contest, and the goal is, to use the most beautiful pictures, and not average pics, only because they have the right size. The new images are maybe not perfect for this format, but they show, what a beautiful face miria has. The nice, but not really beautiful current image, can influence the outcome of the next round negative. So if you are not interested to change the image, is it really a fair and objective contest? I don't think so ...
But ok, i will show you a other picture, an hope, this one is good enough for you.
More pics. But probably not the right size.
Last edited by Bayuga; April 21, 2014 at 05:33 AM.
We all know Miria won't win anyway . Galatea will probably win, at least she is one of the prettiest, if not the prettiest, she is hot and she is popular (even if it shouldn't be considered here but after the results I have seen)...
If you think that a face profile is a good picture then in reality you don't want Miria to win. This is one of the worst Miria's picture's I've seen but I won't give better examples since I don't fancy her enough.
For me, she is the most beautiful character in Claymore. And if you compare best of Miria vs. best of Teresa, Galatea and the others, and if you really are objective, without fanboy glasses, you will see, that Miria looks better, she has the most beautiful face. At least, she is in the same league! Many characters have the same beauty level. Looks Galatea better than Audrey, Anastasia, Flora etc.? No! And if you compare the tournament pics of Luciela,Teresa and Galatea, who is the hottest of the three? Luciela! But Luciela had never a chance to win.
So, is Galatea the best? With an objective look, definitely no! She is overrated. She has a nice hairstyle, that's her secret. But body and face are not better than the rest.
So, who is the fairest of them all? The answer is: no one! Many of them have the same beauty level!
Last edited by Bayuga; April 21, 2014 at 05:50 AM.