Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter! Celebrate another year with MH and read our yearbook.
Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (7/14/14 - 7/20/14).
Forum News: Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Well, aizen does lie but he does make a pretty good point about the hollow attacks and ichigo.
In the most optimistic case based on what we saw with kirge his orders were to see if there was anyone worthwhile among the arrancar in HM and kill the rest. So you have a madman giving insane orders to a madman.... My point is not that SS is made out of saints, my point is that right now they are a saner, better, alternative to wandenreich. Every developed wandenreich member is clearly an insane remorseless murderer so far. In SS you have at the most mayuri as someone who would kill like that and then you have kenpachi and unohana who at least from what we saw in the manga are very selective on whom they kill. Heck, kenpachi actually spared nnoitora (nnoitora did refuse to stop fighting and was killed though).
Your scenario is still massively improbable though. To begin with hollow attacks are not all that common, shinigami handled most of them to begin with. Mayuri did have his part although I doubt he would have cared much about powerless quincy. And if he had been involved then he would have probably noticed that suddenly the quincy powers of a bunch of quincy just disappeared which is pretty damn suspicious. If the selection was not the direct cause of death of the mixed blood quincy then there wouldn't be any merit in surviving it. There wouldn't have been anything special about ishida surviving it. Why would juhabach make the point that ishida was the only survivor from the selection if the selection did not kill anyone? Juhabach did not make the point that ishida was the only quincy to keep his powers after the selection either, it was specifically about "surviving" it and only because something about ishida surpasses juhabach. The selection killed the quincy, its the only way in which juhabach's words make sense. Heck, juhabach is so guilty of killing the mix blood quincy that halswald was immediately suspicious of ishida wanting to avenge his mother.
1000 years ago they probably weren't doing anything in particular. And they probably were in SS. With Juha. He wouldn't want to get back his kingdom if never lived there.
Rukia couldn't feel Ichigo until she was just next to him, as his reiatsu filled his whole room. IIRC there was some barrier, I'd need to reread the whole manga, or maybe it's just my imagination. >.<Quote:
And my point is SS are also bad, even if SR are worse. I'm saying there's no clear "good guys side" and "bad guys side", because we have bad guys and normal guys on both sides.Quote:
Kenpachi selective? Tell that to te mountain of corpses he sat on when he met Unohana, who, by the way, went to massacre a whole district back then. Sparing Nnoitra or Ikkaku has nothing to do with him being any sane. He's just that big of a psycho, that he prefers people to hate him and try to kill him, and they can't do it dead. "Come back and kill me if you can".Quote:
Then Masaki, As Nodt and Katagiri SURVIVED the selection, and didn't survive the AFTERMATH. Simple IMO. And about surpassing... of course Ishida has something that surpasses Bach. Juha wanted his power, but couldn't take it. Surviving doesn't really matter now, does it? He still had power and could kill bunch of Hollows without much problem.Quote:
I'm not sure, I read it somewhere, might have been incorrect translation, though.
Isshin made a charm for Kon, meaning he's skilledin that regard.Quote:
Ichigo never saw a Hollow in his whole life, yet after he becomes a Shinigami they just pop up constantly. And they're saying how tasty he is, and how they should go after him. They NEVER felt him. Not to mention Aizen was FULL of shit.
Kid chased after a Hollow and got his mother killed because she lost her powers, but he saw that Hollow. He didn't know it was a Hollow, but he WAS attacked by it. But Aizen didn't see it because noone told him, so he couldn't make up a convenient lie.
Ichigo should have been targeted, but somehow never was.
Benefit of the doubt is enough. Innocent until proven guilty. Some of them seem normal. Mayuri massacred like TENS OF THOUSANDS people in Rukongai. Even SRs fall short.Quote:
Nah, Kenpachi is not sane, he is just on a good side.Quote:
Logic and reason don't work... Then... PROOFS. Proofs that Selection killed every Quincy, despite Masaki being strong enough to survive it. Proof, that Yhwach is an idiot to say it's a feat to survive a Selection and the aftermath. And again with my flawless examples that are so stupid I'm astonished:Quote:
If I cut off your leg and you get killed by a truck, it'd be truck driver who killed you.
From what we have seen shinigami are able to adjust the balance on their own though. The quincy killing hollows over hundreds of years would not really seem to be an issue in that scenario as the shinigami could just make adjustments. In turn if they kill hollows faster than what they can adjust then there is a problem.
I am giving them the benefit of doubt. However since basically all the quincy that have been developed are in fact batshit crazy lunatics that would murder their allies without a shred of remorse or alternatively kill people uninvolved with the war for the lols along with juhabach modeling them after murderers from 1000 years ago their odds are not good. Currently SS only has a few psychos. With wandenreich at least half of them are insane remorseless murderers. Even if every remaining quincy turned out to be the pope times mother teresa times ghandi they are still the objectively more evil organization because the amount of confirmed insane lunatics in wandenreich (at least 11) is almost as large as the amount of captains in SS.
Note that with kenpachi I said "saner", not actually sane.
There is not much I can do if you really believe that bit about the selection. Proof? Math is enough... What you are saying is that juhabach carried out his selection and then every quincy involved in it died because of some freak accident which followed.... That simply does not make sense. Is it possible there were a few freak accidents? Sure, it is entirely possible but accidents are accidents because they are not intentional, because they are improbable. The idea that every mixed blood quincy died after the selection for reasons completely unrelated to the selection is every bit as insane as most stern riter. If every quincy died after the selection then what happened was not improbable, it was certain.
Yeah, killing 28,000 people to adjust the balance seems like they can do it.
They're bad guys, even when they seem normal if they get excited with a fight people will call them names. I remember long time ago someone wrote that SRs Shunsui fought was mental, because he was very excited about Juha fighting. The same could be said about Kyoraku, but noone thought it was strange or out of ordinary.Quote:
Again with "freak accident". Neither a freak nor an accident. Look at Africa. Revolutions, all that crap. There was a war, they got power and are now reigning over their country. The problem is, they can't stop fighting even if there is peace, but now it's not shown in TV. Situation is the same. TV needed to show they can make revolution and succeed, but they won't show what this revolution did with people and this country. People say Kaddafi was better. Syria is in ruins, ruled by psychopats. Same could be said about mixed bloods. They could no longer fight, but they just couldn't stop. Unless we are told otherwise, we can't say Selection killed all of em. You're making a claim saying "Mixed bloods were killed by Selection", burden of proof is on you, and you depend on probability, which is as far as you can get from a proof.Quote:
Quincy before the selection did not take active roles in hollow huntings as far as we know. Just look at ryuken's mom, she even specifically told ryuken not to let involved with white when he was killing shinigami. There is no reason for us to think the mixed blood quincy were in a war situation against hollows. The scenario you are proposing sounds every bit as proposterous as every one of them being involved in a freak accident.... I mean, what you are suggesting is not a freak accident but rather that each and every mix blood quincy was stupid and had a profound deathwish and they simply jumped at the chance to fight hollows they lacked the means or a reason to fight. And the same logic with the freak accidents would apply in the end. A few quincy being insane and going to fight an enemy whom they did not need to fight with powers they lacked? Ok, absurd but plausible. 10 quincy doing that? Things get murky here, you'd think common sense would strike at least by quincy even by accident. 20 quicy? No common sense in 20 mixed blood quincy? 40? 100? Are they inbred? Probability is pretty good considering the alternative so far are massively improbable scenarios which involve either the quincy being too unlucky or too collectively stupid to live anyways. Heck, juhabach himself makes the point that no mixed blood quincy survived the selection (nodt, as far as we saw, was saved by juhabach which is not quite the same as with uryu who survived on his own). The alternatives we have so far are that either juhabach killed the mixed blood quincy, they were too unlucky to exist or they had a collective deathwish. Accepting juhabach's explanation that the selection killed them seems like the only obvious alternative.
There is another clear, easy alternative. They just were weakened, stripped of their power and couldn't do shit, thus they died. Easy peasy. Katagiri went into coma because, as it was stated, she was weak from the birth. Unless ALL Gemischt Quincies were weak from the birth, and Masaki was a very rare case to actually stay not only concious, but to do something to a Hollow, Selection didn't kill them. But they all died, though.
Btw, why didn't Grand Fisher kill Ichigo? Ichigo was his meal, he was right there, Masaki was powerless, he didn't get any "food" from her. She wasn't tasty. Tasty Ichigo was right there, though.
Last edited by Duniak; May 11, 2014 at 10:02 AM.
that we have every reason to believe they did just that. And in the case of the mix blood quincy it would make a huge amount of sense to do just that because, well, they can't do anything at all. They would be going to die a pointless death.... The scenario which you are suggesting is that the quincy collectively killed themselves which simply does not make sense. Same as before, it is plausible that a few quincy got themselves in a situation where they pointlessly went to a fight where their only plausible contribution would be to add to the bodycount but what you are suggesting is that EVERY quincy went in and did that. That not a single quincy thought "Well, my actual options right now are to not go there and let everyone die or go there and die with them.... Sorry folks, of to watch "how I met your mother" reruns". Alternatively, it seems like you are suggesting that every mixed blood quincy got into a situation like that of ichigo's. That every mixed blood quincy had his family attacked by a hollow even though we have every reason to believe hollow attacks are relatively rare to begin with.
I would argue that ultimately katagiri being weak from the start was not too relevant to her actually dying or it might have just speed up the process. As you said, everyone died and it is improbable every mixed blood quincy had a weak constitution (although the idea of her being that weak is weird if we consider she was capable of fighting). Masaki should not be considered here because she was not a mixed blood quincy, her situation was different.
Good question about ichigo although that is precisely the part of the events that was skipped. Considering the exceptional situations around masaki being involved in the selection at all it is plausible we have not seen everything surrounding those events and they will be relevant in the future.
Probably THIS. That's why Ryuken said "Purebloods shouldn't waste their bloodso easily".
You know what quilty consience is? You think reason is all that matters in life? xD "I either do nothing and watch them die or I try to save them, it's not like a human can't possibly harm Hollow right? Nah, Imma watch HIMYM reruns and I won't feel bad for it".Quote:
Read about the guy who dropped the bomb on Hiroshima.
Okay now, weak body is different than a weak Quincy. her body couldn't handle her body being stripped out of power. That doesn't mean she couldn't fight as a Quincy. Look at Gremmy. His body was... well, he didn't have one. His power? Formidable.Quote:
Urahara came to save them and chased it away? Ryuken? Yhwach personally came to save his grandson because he made a mistake in killing his daughter because he didn't know she became Gemischt? Either way I doubt Grand Fisher would be alive after that. It must have been someone weak. Tatsuki kin geri'd the guy? Or it's a plothole that won't be explained.Quote:
Last edited by Duniak; May 11, 2014 at 03:30 PM.
But then that takes us back to the bit about how likely it is that every quincy involved in the selection just happened to die due to reasons unrelated to the selection. Did each and every powerless mixed blood feel guilty at not intervening in hollow attacks which they could do nothing to stop? Even knowing that without actual power it was extremely likely that they would simply make a bad situation worst by adding to the body count? Heck, even if what killed every quincy was a combination of all the stuff you mentioned it would still add up to something incredibly improbable. Being fair, if what did kill them was any of the things you have suggested or a combination of them then at least even by dumb luck there should be a few mixed blood quincy left... Yet there aren't as far as we know. Its not just about reason and common sense, intervening in that state is just plain suicide.
Personally I thought that in masaki's case juhabach specifically aimed to murder her. She did not actually become a hybrid, white was there but the actual merging of souls was prevented via the gigai. Her being a part of the selection in itself and just happening to die is weird altogether. Its not like being like she was is something that juhabach would personally take a stance against. He had no trouble making ichigo a part of his army, he had a couple of expendable arrancar and he even invited aizen to join him. So if having a hollow inside of her is not a problem as far as we know (even arrancar are ok) and she was a part of a selection she was not supposed to be a part of then it makes sense that juhabach went out of her way to specifically target her. My crackpot theory on the matter is that the whole thing was a scheme to kidnap ichigo that did not go quite right.
hes probaby tired of his existance and wants to pass it on to somebody. Which will be determined after Bach vs Ichigo. The winner becomes soul king.
Young emotional, unexperienced ones felt guilt, old, experienced, indifferent Quincies who knew their place didn't give a shit. Then we have Ishidas, who were both young and didn't give a shit.
If every Quincy had died because of Selection Isshin wouldn't have said that Katagiri felt into coma died because she was weak. It implies that Quincies who were not weak could actually live. At least they didn't fall into coma.
Whole Selection just to take Ichigo? Ishida would hold a grudge against Ichigo then... if he didn't exist, his mother wouldn't have died.
The question is, how does Selection work? If it something like Juha thinking "All not pureblooded Quincies lose their powers", then Juha might not have known that Masaki stopped being pureblooded and would be included in this "rule". When he finished selection he felt her power in him and boom, he killed his daughter!
Any scenario where you assume that was killed every quincy was something different from the selection has the implicit assumption that they were lemmings... You are still assuming that each and every quincy involved in the selection had some form of a deathwish which was purposely realized. Whatever happened to the quincy has to be directly or at least indirectly caused by the selection itself. If your idea is true then it would seem like the collective deathwish an entirely population got would be related to the selection too in which case its also the same as juhabach mass murdering them.
As for the ishin bit, we have ishin's testimony vs juhabach's. From what I gather ishin either hid some stuff from ichigo or he is simply not familiar with the details regarding the selection.
No, I didn't mean it as a selection to take ichigo. More of an scenario that the selection was something that was already going to happen and in the midst of it he would specifically aim to reclaim his little piece of soul from masaki to get a good chance to take ichigo himself.
But the fact Ishidas were the exception stays the same.
Manga made it every clear Katagiri went into coma because she was weak. She didn't even die immediately. And unless everyone was weak, you can't prove anything to me, as you guess is as good as mine.Quote:
It still a manga fact, and unless proven otherwise, we can't assume it's not true. I could say Yhwach slept for so long, that he's mad and didn't remember what he did, as he's 1000 years old and Alzheimer is pretty common. Isshin did the gut spilling he talked about, no reason to hide anything.Quote:
How would killing Masaki make it easier for them to take him? Wouldn't it be easier to recruit Masaki and Ichigo instead of killing Masaki and making Ichigo hate him?Quote: