Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter! Celebrate another year with MH and read our yearbook.
Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (8/11/14 - 8/17/14).
Forum News: Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Singles Tier List
Only characters that had at least one match (or currently have one) are to be ranked. For Doubles, only players that played together before may be ranked.
Concerning the Tier Lists for Prefecturals, Tokyo, Kanto and Nationals, the above criteria apply to the given time frame.
Last edited by Kaoz; June 18, 2014 at 02:20 AM.
Implying he has weak stamina here by Atobe Keigo himself.
So I do think Hiyoshi will rise up the tiers due to having solid stamina now.
The 4th counter doesn't say its trajectory is anything tricky. Certainly Shiraishi and Niou (as Tezuka) hit it back like it's nothing so it's at least ineffective against equal tier opponents in terms of offensive value. Hirakoba is considerably below even 4 counter Fuji in tier and he also used up all his energy for Giant Habu so the fact he can't return it doesn't say much. It's probably meant to be a defensive move, but against equal tier opponents we see both time Fuji used it, it results in an immediate smash by the opponent so its value is dubious.
Nakagauchi was hitting cord balls on purpose because that's a criteria to use Southern Cross. Sure, any top player can hit cord balls on purpose, but why would you purposely try to set up a shot that allows Fuji to use his strongest move? I guess some of them might do it just to see what Fuji's best move is, but they're certainly not obliged to feed Fuji cord balls. I think Shiraishi hitting cord balls on 5th counter is because he cannot hit it over cleanly, so he might as well aim for a cord ball. If he can simply return it cleanly like Niou (as Tezuka), given his brand of bible tennis there's really no reason for him to get fancy there. 6th counter isn't useful on anyone weaker than Shiraishi because they'd never be able to return the 5th counter to begin with. Niou in his base stats is still presumably above most people by the virtue of being a Rikkidai, and he sure doesn't look like he can do anything about 5th counter until he starts using his illusions.
Fuji's problem is that for whatever reason, his move is considered extremely well-telegraphed in POT. To stop a ZSD all you do is run up to the net, but we see not even Sanada can do that in his game against Ryoma when Ryoma used ZSD. This implies that even for a top player, it's not obvious when the ZSD occurs so it usually works despite having a rather simple way to stop it. On the other hand almost every instance of Fuji using his first counter (which is very similar to ZSD) shows everyone and their brother running up to the net to attempt to stop it. Likewise Sanada's Rin looks like a simple lob, but neither Yanaji nor Tezuka can capitalize on this so it implies whenever he does it, his opponent is unable to take advantage of the lob to counterattack, so it is an uber defensive move. However when Fuji uses the 4th counter (which is very similar to Rin) the ball just ends up getting smashed in the two cases against people of his tier (or above). It's actually pretty weird since Closed Eyes make him completely unpredictable, and yet his special moves are some of the most predictable moves in POT.
But like I said, any opponents below 5thCounter!Fuji will be wrecked/raped by 5thCounter. And those who are close to 5thCounter!Fuji who are good enough to gradually return it, since the method to return it for those below Fuji is to keep hitting it at the net til it gets higher and higher over the cord.
Therefore the opponent will be met by 6thCounter which is unreturnable anyway.
Without a clean hit back on 5thCounter you have basically lost the match.
Comparing them is silly.
I don't really see your point here.
You can't telegraph ZSD easily because Tezuka hits it with almost the same form he hits a regular slice with. The only one who actually knows when it's coming is Inui. Tsubame Gaeshi on the other hand, you can see coming from a mile away. Higuma Otoshi is the same, you know when it's coming. Hakugei is less obvious, but since the ball passes the opponent twice, they can just hit it the second time (you can distinguish it from a normal lob when it passes you the first time). 4th and 5th counter have complicated motions as well, so again you know it's not a regular shot.
As a result, you have a lot of time to prepare when Fuji hits his special moves, making them easier to return than stuff like ZSD or Kamikakushi that are hit with normal forms.
Does anybody else notice the irony?Originally Posted by Ken
Can I see some proof from the manga that's not biased by opinion? If you think my argument is wrong. Can you show some proof?
Here's my proof, if you want it.
Why would coach change Kenya off and not Zaizen? Is it because Zaizen style fit Chitose tennis better? I don't see how Zaizen fit the bill better there. If you can show some substantial evidence, I'll be happy to have an actual debate with you. I notice that you can't even make a comeback with any manga evidence from your past argument. Well, I guess it's normal for someone to support characters that they're a fan off, but really, if you want to support a characters, knows your character tier and stick with it. It make you look less dumb.
And it'll be nicer for you to actually make a good argument that doesn't revolve around stupid plot power instead of picking up little flaw in people's argument. Oh, I guess you didn't defend it. Where's your answer to Echizen being top and above everyone just forever that way? That's your plot argument at works at its finest, isn't it? f you want to keep continue using the plot argument, please at least try to defend it.
If someone try using the same argument that just keep getting shot down each time, and it makes the person that make the argument look like he had short term memory. Not saying anyone in particular, but just that when it happens, it make me think that way.
Last edited by -Ken-; February 16, 2013 at 02:10 AM.
Also, you can't compare a tiebreak match with a regular full length match. The writing is different. The one has only 7 points, the other usually has 7 games. This IS relevant because you have to condense all you want to do in 7 points. And because Konomi was foreshadowing (something you probably don't understand because you don't understand storytelling) Kenya's improvement during the Shiraishi match, he allowed Kenya to get some points.
Also, you can't use the formula (A > B) and (C > A) therefore (C > B) in PoT. Inui beat Renji. This does not mean anybody who beats Inui is automatically better than Renji, because Inui is uniquely qualified to play against him. I've said many times, Renji would beat more people in the series than Inui would.
Last edited by Fayte; February 16, 2013 at 09:28 AM.
And I never say Kenya is on Shiraishi level. If he is, the tiebreak result will be 5-7 or something closer. I only says that he is better than 4 counter Fuji, which is different.
I won't say tiebreak match is too different than full length match. Cancer lost to Yuushi 7-0 while he's supposed to be specialized in short length match (as shown by both of his match in PoT). I'll say they're miniscope of what the full match is supposed to be. This is because there's no way cancer would beat Yuushi, because cancer is, well, cancer.
Revolution!Yanagi and Revolution!Inui I would say are dead equal after Nationals!Yanagi shat on Nationals!Inui then Mitsuya arrives leaves Yanagi for dead on the ground.
I think Yanagi actually slept. The bastard actually went to sleep because he had his ass handed to him so badly.
I think Yanagi is a cool guy so that was painful to read for me.
Whereas Inui defeats Mitsuya and looks rather comfortable afterwards. So comfortable he has to carry the unconscious Yanagi.
I can't think of a situation where Yanagi is better than Inui anymore. I think Konomi just confirmed that if anybody is better of the two, it isn't Yanagi anymore.
If you have another angle to view it then I'm all ears but, yeah...
It's funny that people think that with speed alone the 4 counters + closed eyes + that slice serve (phantom serve?) will be easily returned.
So, prefecturals Kamio > Kanto finals Fuji too right? Of course not, considering that Prefecturals Kirihara destroyed Pref Tachibana (who was, by far, the best in Fudo) and Fuji was evenly matched with Muga! Kirihara (he was even better than freaking Tezuka at the time...).
Kenya is a guy that would have troubles with Jirou's tier, nothing else. 4 counters Fuji would destroy him.
Why would Kamio beat Fuji? He even lost to Kenya with beast aura upgrade. Kenya was even holding himself back with handicap for most of that match and are still rocking Kamio. That's a really stupid argument.
I already present my proof of why Kenya> 4 counter Fuji. If you can't back that up with evidence from manga, it's just your opinion and nothing more. I'm not interested.
If Fuji 6-2 or 1 Jirou, and 4 counter Fuji lost 5 game and 3 points to Shiraishi without getting a single point, that's not a good sign. And then Kenya manage to get 3 points out of 10 points from the same National Shiraishi. What does that tells you? Kenya is most likely around same tier as 4 counter Fuji, and slightly stronger even. I think that points to 6-0 Jirou.
I'm all ears for good discussion. I like discussing with people when they actually back up their side with evidence. So I ask for evidence, if you may?
This discussions with you, honestly, are useless, you just stick with results. There's no way that Kenya would beat Kanto Fuji, even if he is so awesome that he was able to score 3 points in a plot power tie break against Shiraishi.
Last edited by Hardy; February 16, 2013 at 02:02 PM.
4th counter is against spin shots, Kenya doesn't use any, so Fuji won't use 4th counter against him. The triple counter can all be returned with speed.