We get epic animation for fodder characters being incinerated by magma fists and blasted by cannon balls. In terms of plot progression, it was a 15-minute struggle for the Whitebeard Pirates and Luffy to gain back some momentum. Oars Jr. played a crucial role in providing a way out for most of the pirates. Jinbei narrowly helped Luffy escape near death (again) and threw him up to the pillar.
To sum things up: Pirates getting shot at. Whitebeard's ship gets set on fire. Luffy falls into the sea, gets saved by Jinbei, and climbs up to the Admiral's pillar. Meh.
The animation budget must be extremely high for One Piece to provide great artwork for an episode that barely budged plot-wise or even action-wise.
The anime helped try to clear out some of the inconsistencies that were in the manga chapter and therefore some filler was used. Watching 10 minutes of pirates dying and ships being incinerated into pieces helped intensify the desperation of Whitebeard's crew during the war.
i don't know about the rest of you but luffy's confrontation with the 3 admirals looked like crap to me. He looked like a freaking ragdoll. They made him look crazy and not even half as cool as he was in the manga. And akainu's head looked small and retarded in that scene. Actually, I think I've hated all the extra luffy stuff they put into the war cuz they make him look like a weak emo pussy and they draw him terribly. They always make him look less of a man and more like a weak kid.
edit: They took Capone Gang Bege's lines on Whitebeard being a legend and gave them to Law...
Last edited by fistsofrage; November 07, 2010 at 11:12 AM.
I loved everything minus Luffy's design (only oda can draw that guy perfectly, Inoe does a good job, tough), and Akainu.
The rest was brilliant, loved how they show how weak Luffy his, and the water, oh the water, what a great scene, if Luffy didn't look that ugly and Akainu hadn't a Face smaller than his neck I'd give it a 10/10.
Preview looks really Inoue like, AKA good.
Last edited by beastboy; November 07, 2010 at 05:12 PM.
The luffy bit was my favourite moment in the manga, gave me goosebumps. They animated it perfect so i'm happy. Luffy looked narley.
@fistsofrage some of us must have picked up a different interpretation of the war. As to me luffy did look like a mad dog on his last lifes in this scene of the manga. This was a last desperation, all out attack from him and if you read the manga you know what happens next.
It just shown again how outragerous and ballsy luffy is, and how are you arguing that he isn't a weak kid here? I know peak form where he isn't being distracted by ace he would excel more but that has nothing to do with this scene.
Ill give 9.5/10 for one piece standards because cmon, realisticly were only going to give a 10 for an episode with 3 chapters of content animated perfectly which aint gona happen. damn though again this episode shows how F*ckin epic this arc could have been if the anmation was consistant and they had more content.
Yeah I agree, It's hard to seeing him getting kicked around so much and I kind of wanted him to pull out a random power up during the past few arcs and get a wtfpwned moment on a admiral. I actually think what luffy went through to get his current strength (manga) was unecessary and Oda could have sort of adjusted some things and luffy could have easily been close to that level in this battle. You know what I mean? because what he shown up untill marineford he could have been much stronger aswell as haki.
- If anyone thinks i'm being a bit too loose with spoilings just say and ill wrap it.
I have uploaded 720p Stream which has preview of next episode
I already update the thread though but if you are lazy to check it
here is the direct link to it -->http://veevr.com/videos/h0XF3pGHC
The next episode gonna be action packed
Well I don't mind Luffy "looking weak" after all, he is in a battle field and most of the opponents are stronger than him....especially the admirals. It's just build up to show that he needs to get way stronger than he is now. Neways good episode overall.....
The episode was fine for me. Could be better, but it also could be worse, like that episode where Mihawk was trying to kill Luffy, so I won't complain.
Damn, I forgot that the anime staff can make ok fillers. Sometimes. I like the part with Whitebeard getting emotional looking at his ship sink. It was his Going Merry after all.
The distortion used on Luffy's face for that angry moment against the admirals reminded me so much of that Naruto vs. Pain episode that everyone hated. Funny that the One Piece fans completely adored it and all.
I completely hated how he faced the admirals. This was one of the many times when the animation sucks compared to the imagination. All the extra stuff they added just made him look like a wimp, their attempt to add emotion totally failed.
Yeah, the reason it was awesome in manga is the fact that it all happened so fast. It's dynamic and shit. Of course, they have to stretch the scene as far as they can so they don't come too near current manga chapters. Fuck that.