Official Grimoire Heart Thread

[ghostexiled]

This thread is for all to discuss everything related to the newest Dark Guild... Grimoire Heart.

Please try and use this thread to discuss this and anything related to the matter, rather than the chapter discussion thread... that is until an actual chapter addresses these things.

[Aloysius]

Zancrow vs Erza & Luvia (Luvia win after Erza is beaten, water being fire natural enemy)
Ultear vs Grey & Loki (don't know if Grey win, but Ultear may start to doubt about her bad ways...)
Caprico vs Lucy & Cana
Mirajane and Lisana vs Hikaru (or Meldy)
Makarov vs Hades
Natsu vs Meldy (or Hikaru)
Elfman & Evergreen vs Rustyrose

Then, you have Mest (ab)using Wendy vs Zeref who try to not kill anybody, plus Charles and Panther Lily going to kick some GH ass.

[Razh]

Zancrow vs Erza & Luvia

That guy was basically made to fight with Natsu. It would be a travesty to let him fight anyone else.

Fire vs. fire, that's awesome. Although I think that guy uses magma. His fire seemed more dense and he mentioned wanting to turn people to ashes.
Another possibility is that he has fire dragon lacryma, if that's even possible, but I'm leaning more to lava.

[kkck]

Pseudo natsu's fire didn't look thick or liquid enough to be magma. I lean towards him having fire dragon lachrima. If I recall, natsu's own power is seriously influenced by his emotions and can be altered. Eating other kinds of fire can also result in natsu's power changing in appearance(as seen with ethereon). Maybe because this new guy is a raving insane lunatic who seems by all intents and purposes outright evil his fire takes on a more much violent and mean looking appearance. Along with that the guy could be feeding of some evil fire provided by GH.

[Dark God Zeus]

Maybe something like "hellfire", equivalent to amaterasu or hiei's dragon of the darkness flame (albeit less powerful?).

We don't know enough about their abilities yet. Although Ultear is probably meant to fight Grey, clearly Caprico is the capricorn zodiac key (thus Lucy), and zankrow will fight natsu.

[Aloysius]

That guy was basically made to fight with Natsu. It would be a travesty to let him fight anyone else.

I would find that boring myself. Two characters using similar techniques against each other is less interesting than two characters using widely different combat styles. That, and the fact that we have never seen "natural enemy" fight situations, as were shown in One Piece or Naruto.

[MechR]

I would find that boring myself. Two characters using similar techniques against each other is less interesting than two characters using widely different combat styles.

I think there's some nuance to this. Natsu and Totomaru were both fire mages, but their fight was still fun due to their different styles, and Natsu trying a bunch of stuff to break the stalemate.

That, and the fact that we have never seen "natural enemy" fight situations, as were shown in One Piece or Naruto.

I think people expected Juvia's water form to be Erza's natural enemy, but Erza was still able to smack her around with shockwaves (or something).

[Razh]

I would find that boring myself. Two characters using similar techniques against each other is less interesting than two characters using widely different combat styles. That, and the fact that we have never seen "natural enemy" fight situations, as were shown in One Piece or Naruto.

Maybe I should have been more clear with what I meant. It's not about powers, it's about personalities. I'd just love to see Natsu fighting another impulsive, hot headed, crazy mage. Something like Natsu vs. Gazille or Kenpachi vs. Nnoitra in Bleach.

[swordsaintscoot]

Has anybody noticed that a few of the Grimoire Heart mages either have relations to characters from Fairy Tail, or have a similar appearance?

[ca12nag3]

Similar appearance? hmm i didnt see anything like that. Tho the Caprico dude could be a spirit on the bad side.

[Evil3ye]

Zancrow vs Erza & Luvia (Luvia win after Erza is beaten, water being fire natural enemy)
Caprico vs Lucy & Cana

I second that.

I'm pretty sure either Lucy or Loki will fight against Caprico, who obviously is an other zodiac spirit.

Luvia vs the fire dude could be awesome as well.

[kkck]

Under the assumption that that guy is a variation or fake fire dragon slayer, I kinda have my doubts about jubia being so effective against him. I know it is remarkably easy to say fire>water but I don't think it would be that simple. If it really is a fake dragon slayer of sorts then the fire which he would be using is not by any means normal. I wouldn't find it strange if this guy could actually burn water (it has been mentioned dragon elements are by no means normal) or at least have a high enough temperature to evaporate the water (which adds up to the same).

[swordsaintscoot]

I'm fairly sure they've frozen fire before.

No reason why fire couldn't boil water.

[hongoasdf]

I think Urtear will face Erza before even meeting Gray. There's too much Gerard left unresolved, and those two were the closest to him.

And besides, Urtear being Ur's daughter is known by no-one except Gerard, as far as we know. Let alone Gray. There's no point in him facing her as of now. Perhaps after her encounter with Erza her identity will finally be revealed to the cast.

About Zancrow I couldn't care less. He's basically Natsu 2.0 - And we've seen Natsu fight countless times already.

[Igtenes]

I'm just sad that it looks like Gajeel won't be fighting any of the main squad members, since he seems pretty beat-up.
Natsu and Happy(pff yeah right) vs Zancrow
Lucy and Cana vs Caprico
Gray and Loke vs Urtear
Elfman and Evergreen vs Hikaru
Mirajane and Lisanna vs Meldy
Makarov vs Hades
I think that Erza and Juvia will face Mest first, it's not known if he's from GH.