Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter! Celebrate another year with MH and read our yearbook.
Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (8/11/14 - 8/17/14).
Forum News: Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Why Dae Isn't Worried
Hysteria's Getting Attacked
The Org Shacking In Fear
Galatea Sensing it in the Bath
You're making an unfair comparison. Even Clarice or a human would be able to chop Teresa to pieces if she didn't fight back (and claymores are practically indestructible and would chop almost anything). I'm pretty sure that Teresa would not allow Rosemary to hit her if she was using claymore. Rosemary is obviously more powerful than Irene (do we know weak #1s? No, these warriors are always exceptional). Irene was a very strong #3 and a strong #2 but all of this was thanks to a technique that allowed her to store all of her youma powers in an arm. If she awakened, she might have been weaker than she was as a Claymore since she would not be able to concentrate all of her power in one part of her body anymore.
for my own view, on these speculatory comparisons and of characters:
Teresa is Teresa, she's so powerful, she knew she was completely safe against an AO, AO Rosemary, that she could allow AO Rosemary to bash her body around. Maybe it has to do with Teresa's PYSA, in that she could tell what AO Rosemary was going to do, in other words, if Rosemary had tried doing something that could endanger Teresa, she wouldn't have allowed Rosemary to do it.
I think she's a good candidate for being a rank 1 and here's why
1. She just had bad luck being overshadowed by "monsters" Teresa and then Priscilla
2. Her level of control of Yoki, and her own calmness as well, is astounding, as Clare said, ~"The fact you can do the QS with no signs of struggle/effort upon your face, makes you a Monster, Irene!"
3. The QS is a very advanced and powerful Ability.
4. While the QS is very powerful, Irene herself is quite capable, and also we seem to almost never see the QS being used by Irene, as most of the time it appears Irene is doing (normal) sword skill combat, we actually rarely see for certain the QS in action by Irene.
There's only 6 instances of certainty of QS use by Irene that I can recall:
*Against the 2 NYs in the "Yoma Nest Town"
*Inside the Inn against Teresa
*Against Teresa on the bridge, when we see the ground around Teresa being sliced up (and I think this is where Priscilla comes up behind Teresa, trying to decapitate Teresa from behind, but Teresa avoids Priscilla's attack, slices up Irene, and backflips or whatever away from both of them, holding up her bloody sword, as Irene collapses behind Priscilla, Priscilla turns and weeps for Irene, as Teresa pwns Sophia and Noel off-screen, Priscilla then goes after Teresa and gets pwned off-screen, Irene looks up from the ground, realizing she obviously again didn't understand how supreme Teresa was/is, lol. Teresa walks over to decapitate the crying/fearful Priscilla, but decides not to do it. Priscilla then snaps and goes after Teresa outside of the town as Orcish Priscilla, and we know the rest... lol)
*Irene against Ophelia
*Irene "against" (practicing/testing) the tree
*Irene "against" (training) Clare
4A. Irene's speed, she was able to rush over and save Claymore Priscilla from being decapitated by Teresa
4B. Irene's leadership and strategic abilities
4C. Irene's strength, she was breaking the ground up!
4D. She's superior to Sophia and Noel, as they said, ~"You firmly have the rank 2 position"
4E. Great Yoki Sensing Ability (she was able to find Teresa as well as later sense Clare-Teresa as well as sensing Rafaela's true power level) and great Yoki Suppression Ability (SAO Priscilla didn't know that Irene was still alive).
she was stated to be a rank 1 Claymore, and that's all we've got about her, there's no reason we have to assume she's not a rank 1 Claymore.
Also, there is no knowledge to how powerful she (as an AO) is, despite those who try to argue that she's weaker (or stronger) than Isley, Riful, Luciela, Alicia, Beth, or whoever else is a rank 1. We simply have no evidence either way on this matter.
thus, it's only fair/reasonable to assume she's just as powerful as is Isley, Riful, Luciela, and etc, until we get evidence to whether she's more or less powerful than they are.
---------- Post added at 12:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:03 PM ----------
I actually disagree with this, and here's why:Originally Posted by Goral
1. Isley's Arm Modes while in his Humanoid form, clearly he's Focusing his Yoki into his arms, just as Irene is doing with her arm in her use of the QS.
2. Riful's able to use her Ribbon-Tentacles while remaining in hre Humanoid form, suggestive that she's Focusing her Yoki, as well
3. Luciela is able to have only her bottom (LOLOLOL) Awakened in the form of her two tails while still in her Humanoid form, clearly showing that Luciela can Focus Yoki (into her bottom - LOLOLOLOL) just as Irene is Focusing her Yoki into her Arm for her QS.
4. Dauf is able to use his Rods while still in his Humanoid form.
5. HA Clare is able to Focus her Yoki into her legs so that only her legs Awaken, just as Irene is Focusing her Yoki into her Arm for her QS.
6. HA Clare is able to Focus her Yoki into her Arms/Shoulders so that only her Arms/Shoulders Awaken, just as Irene is Focusing her Yoki into her Arm for her QS.
7. and probably many more examples
Last edited by HegemonKhan; October 09, 2011 at 02:15 PM.
Which databook is this? I haven't seen any info on her abilites and it's not in the wiki which is usually very good with this kind of stuff.Originally Posted by FrostyMouse
Last edited by HegemonKhan; October 09, 2011 at 06:54 PM.
There is a difference between concentrating all your power and partially awakening some parts. So far we've never seen anyone besides Clare and Irene doing that and certainly no AB. What AOs, Clare and shrimp twins were doing was just using small part of their awakened forms' power. That's why Isley and Luciella said they didn't want to ruin the scenery and were fighting in their human forms (at first at least), they knew that in their awakened forms the destruction to the area would be much worse. That's why Riful said that she didn't want things to escalate to such degree and didn't want her power measured. If she had had all power stored in her awakened arm (the one she stopped Jean from killing Duff with) Alicia would already know her power but that wasn't the case. However, QS is a technique where all power is used and stored in an arm. As a result someone has a super strong arm and human-like the rest of the body (at least when compared to the power of the arm). If Riful could concentrate all her power in an arm her mere touch would obliterate Jean. So, if what Irene and Rafaela said is true (and we have no reason to doubt it really) Irene would be the last person to profit from awakening. Sure, she would have a tougher body and more power but I doubt she could do her technique anymore, there is no indication of that.
Rosemary is mentioned in one place only in databooks - in Teresa's section in databook 1. And there are no stats of her. However, it's certain she must have better stats than Duff has and Duff is super powerful (but not even close to AOs). In this subforum, in databooks thread I've given links to all databooks. And what it says there is:
Entrusted with the black letter of the former number 1
Though she didn't have a special intimacy with the former number 1 Rosemaria, she accomplished this mission quickly. This denoted her self-consciousness about being the new number 1."
Last edited by Goral; October 09, 2011 at 11:03 PM.
Oh, you are right, Goral. It had been so long since I'd looked at the databooks that I'd forgotten that Rosemary wasn't in there. I was remembering Hilda's stats, and she actually does have SSS+ Yoki as an AB.
My apologies for misleading anyone.
On the topic of Hilda, however, I still wonder what rank she held when she awakened. I mean, Hilda possesses SSS+ Yoki as an AB, which is the same as what Dauf possessed, and Dauf was a #3. Ophelia's a #4 at the time that she awakens, but AB Ophelia only has SS Yoki. That could just be an indication of Ophelia's actual strength.
However, I suppose that debating any amount of Yoki as an AB is sort of pointless.
Moderator message by: HegemonKhanHilda was a rank 6 as a Claymore. Upon killing Awakened Hilda, rank 8 HA Miria was given Hilda's rank 6 position, becoming the rank 6 HA Miria that we know
Last edited by HegemonKhan; October 10, 2011 at 06:17 PM.
You know, I wondering if Dae was the mastermind that made the 3 AO. You think about it, since those 3 AO's are gone he's trying to create 3 more. Just look at his intent?
But what would his motive be?
HK, while that's true, I was more or less under the impression that Hilda would've risen in rank by the time she awakened, so we can't say for sure that she was a #6 when she was killed, unless I'm just misremembering some page that actually says that she's #6 at the time. I know that Hilda was #6 when Miria met her.
I had thought that, but I'd forgotten that Rafaela was #5 at the time and that Ophelia was #4. Somehow, I had thought that Ophelia was like #6 or #7 at the time, so I must have misremembered it. So, yeah, Hilda had to have remained #6.
Last edited by HegemonKhan; October 11, 2011 at 01:44 AM. Reason: nvm
Ignoring that all the more powerful ranks are already taken, your point that Hilda could have become more powerful than a rank 6 is valid (indeed you're right that Hilda's rank 6 was mentioned -I think- when Miria was still rank 17 and first admiring/befriending Hilda)... on the surface..., however, the manga does not give any mention of it, and thus for all we know, Hilda could just as well have become a rank 1 in power, or heck, even more powerful than Teresa, just as much as your point that she might be at most a few ranks more powerful now than her previous power of a rank 6. Thus, while it's possible for Hilda to have become more powerful than a rank 6, she could just as much have become even more powerful than Teresa just as well, and due to this I feel your point is moot, and thus actually not valid. Anything is possible when talking about an uncertainty. So, for me, Hilda remains a rank 6, unless the manga were to say or show otherwise. Sorry for the long counter argument and explanation of mine to your possibility of Hilda having become more powerful than a rank 6, this was as concise as I could be to make my case or argument, lol.
Last edited by HegemonKhan; October 11, 2011 at 01:50 AM.
I suppose it's time ZERO PHOENIX has returned.
The only thing that makes me wonder about Dae is that he has shown self preservation. He made that clear when he didn't travel with the Rod infected Raki. His motive may well be to see if he can do it, or how powerful his creations can get, but he doesn't see like the type who'd just put himself in a fatal situation.
And the war effort.Originally Posted by ZP
He's smart.Originally Posted by SA
Last edited by HegemonKhan; October 19, 2011 at 08:45 PM.
Anyway Zero, thanks for answering all that, but it was only jibberish thoughts on my behalf that we weren't going to see Clare and Priscilla until next year. LOL!
I'm thinking Yagi is trying to focus more on Miria battle for now, but this is taking quite a lot of time. He's also just bringing in more Power Card to the table so that the story would be interesting. Since the 3 AO is of no threat anymore.
What surprises me is that how the AE can defeat the AO but the Claymore or Miria new army with the TAITS can defeat the AE.
What also surprise me is that the 3 new #1 are just Claymore and wooping all the Miria/Claymore/TAITS. Now in theory if these 3 #1 Awaken and become AO, wouldn't that mean just defeat the purpose of what I said up there?
AO < AE < Miria/Claymore/TAITS< 3 #1 < AO
Well, this was interesting. Or was it that Lucilia/Isley/Riful just big bluffs. Nah! I doubt it.