I agree that it would probably have killed him since the pledge is something deeply personal that he made to and with himself.
Now what would happen if he used it on Hisoka who he thought was a Spider? We know that Kurapica's judgement chain didn't frag Kuroro when he spoke to Hisoka once he knew he was a fake Spider (or perhaps the removal of the tatoo could be considered quitting - i don't know). I think it makes sense for Kurapica's nen to be otherwise omniscient so long as the conditions are not knowingly breached by Kurapica himself, whether he is factually correct or not.
It's actually not quite as dangerous as you make it out to be. Imagine if Kurapica's powers couldn't be used AT ALL against non-spiders. Kurapica's master remarked that such a restriction would be pretty flimsy but in effect it's no different from the restriction as it is. In fact, its worse because it would actually preclude Kurapica from using his powers entirely.
imo the restrictions don't adequately justify his power and emperor time sure as hell shouldn't have given him the capability of tanking uvo's punches.
Kurapica's master remarked that the restriction of limiting chain jail's use to spiders only is pretty weak. The restriction that Kurapica came up with is that if he used chain jail on anyone other than a Spider, he would die. But the two are pretty much the same thing, except the former restriction is arguably even stricter because it literally stops him from using chain jail on anyone full stop whereas the current incarnation of chain jail allows him to use it on non-spiders - it just kills him if he chooses to do so.
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Post Thanks / Like
Re: About Aura Combat & How Nen Works
They aren't two separate oaths, they're the same actually. When his master told him it was weak, he told him that that was merely the pre-condition. The pledge itself is to die when used on anyone else.
I know that's silly and that there not even one in a million chance that it would happen but what would happen if:
-Kurapika uses Chain Jail on an innocent and is convinced that he is a Spider?
-Kurapika uses randomly Chain Jail on a Spider without knowing he is one? (For example, would have CJ worked if he hadn't seen Uvo's tattoo?)
Even if he was convinced he was one he would probably still die bcuz they really weren't (like if he used it on Hisoka even though he was just a fake spider, he'd probably still die). Either that or it just won't stop their nen and then he will realize they aren't a spider and his judgement chain around his heart would crush it.
If he would randomly do it for some reason and it turns out they are he'd be ok.