Who should've joined the Strawhats from the ones who were left behind?

[M3J]

oh, forgot about Bon Clay. He'd definitely be a great addition to SHP and bolster their fighting power for the New World. Though, his abilities might be a bit too haxxed because he can trick tons of enemies. This would actually be interestin to watch should SHP team up with Revolutionary Army and take on the Tenryuubito and/or the World Government. Bon's abilities seem pretty useful in helping to free prisoners.

Plus, SHP still needs an okama to complete their weird group.

[Dekker]

Bon Clay is actually of all the people that were left behind the one whos most worthy of becoming a strawhat. He sacrificed himself twice for them, his power is unique and not hax (an ability i would call hax is something like kizarus ability or so, just in case someones wondering), his character fits the overall scheme of the strawhats perfectly, and most importantly, he and Sanji would make a great couple xD

[EddyBob15]

Bon Clay is actually of all the people that were left behind the one whos most worthy of becoming a strawhat. He sacrificed himself twice for them, his power is unique and not hax (an ability i would call hax is something like kizarus ability or so, just in case someones wondering), his character fits the overall scheme of the strawhats perfectly, and most importantly, he and Sanji would make a great couple xD

Please tell me that last part was a joke. Aside from the fact that Sanji hates okamas, Oda said there would be no pairings.

[hyper_megaman]

Please tell me that last part was a joke. Aside from the fact that Sanji hates okamas, Oda said there would be no pairings.

why the huge homophobia

i inferred that statement as him and sanji being good rivals, much like sanji and zoro are right now, and i agree they would make a good couple

he would antagonise sanji to no end and the two of them would compete in whose kicks are stronger

[EddyBob15]

Sorry, I didn't mean to sound like a homophobe. What I meant was that pairing sounds too crazy to even think about.

[Dekker]

Yeah that was a joke, dont worry.

[EddyBob15]

Actually, when I first saw One Piece (4Kids dub), I was thinking those two bounty hunters Zoro knew were going to join.

[Sachsenhesse]

Gin! Gin! Gin! =D Zoro, Sanji, Gin... badass count has reached over 9000.

And i still want Buggy as nakama.

[matzik1212]

Buggy

No offense but this is the most unrealistic thing i've heard . Buggy is Buggy , weak and useless and he always hated Luffy . What would be the point to have him in the crew anyway ?

[Kaiten]

Buggy joining would be horrible

I wish Vivi had joined, she's still one of my all time favorite characters. I know it wouldn't make plot sense but she would have been great as a regular character.

[Doraku]

I wish Vivi had joined, she's still one of my all time favorite characters. I know it wouldn't make plot sense but she would have been great as a regular character.

I miss Vivi too. I was surprised the one who joined the Straw Hat is Robin not Vivi post Alabasta arc.

[Kaiten]

Vivi has a country to lead and family to miss her, I'm not surprised she stayed in Alabasta. I miss her, she's one of my favorite characters, but it makes sense that she stayed behind.

[M3J]

I miss Vivi too. I was surprised the one who joined the Straw Hat is Robin not Vivi post Alabasta arc.

I don't mind, to be honest. Robin is pretty awesome, love her.

Though, I do miss Vivi as well. Too bad she won't be a part of SHP, it'd be great to see her back. I really hope Bon Clay does join though, he'd be a great SHP.

[Doraku]

I don't mind, to be honest. Robin is pretty awesome, love her.

Though, I do miss Vivi as well. Too bad she won't be a part of SHP, it'd be great to see her back. I really hope Bon Clay does join though, he'd be a great SHP.

I don't mind either. I was just surprised that one of the main villain figure in that arc join SHP, without having any "clear" goals like any other crews do (At that time, before Water 7 arc began).

[M3J]

She wasn't really a main villain figure. She didn't really fight the SHP and even saved Luffy from dying. We did know her goal or her intention though, to learn history or at least, to read the poneglyphs.

Though, it did make sense eventually since Robin wasn't evil but was still hunted by majority of the World Government/Marines.