Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter! Celebrate another year with MH and read our yearbook.
Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (9/8/14 - 9/14/14).
Forum News: Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Singles 1 Irie Kanata Niou Masaharu Title Pierrot Trickster of the Court School High School 3rd Year Rikkai Dai Fuzoku 3rd Year Height 178 cm 175 cm Weight 66 kg 62 kg Dominant Hand Left Left Playstyle All Rounder All Rounder Techniques - Illusion
Serve Order: Irie -> Niou
This round ends on Wednesday, September 19th 8 PM GMT.
Cast your vote and discuss (logically) why you voted for who you voted for. Have fun, but keep it clean!
Irie would win this. Even if Niou can imitate others, he is not the real thing, he'll never be like the top players. Also, we haven't seen Irie going all out yet, troll Irie was able to walk over Atobe, until he achieved AK, still wasn't going all out. Against Akiba, he might have been serious, but I think we still have to see his true face. Even if Niou becomes Tezuka or Sanada, he won't copy BA, or Tenimuhou, or if he becomes Yuki, I don't think he could yip Irie, and even if he could, Irie's mental would make Yips useless. If he becomes Tezuka, neither ZSServe, Zsdrop shot, Tezuka Zone or Phantom would work, Phantom would injure niou, Irie for sure would break Tezuka Zone, maybe Hyakuren would be useful but as Irie doesn't use strong shots the power won't be doubled, so it would be useless, he could break Saiki. If Niou becomes Sanada, I don't think Irie has problem returning FuurinKaZa, Rai would work but Niou's legs won't hold on. So what he has left, nothing, also his physical abilities limit him.
If Irie goes all out, Niou has no chance of winning. Irie wins the match 7-5 or if he goes all out 6-1.
Last edited by LetalHawk; September 15, 2012 at 05:14 PM.
LetalHawk has kinda summarized it all.
As cool as Niou is, the fact that Irie walked all over Atobe and toyed around with him even after he got AK, it's just too much.
Irie probably won't lose this.
Can't see Irie losing to Niou.
Unless someone on here can change my opinion. Which I doubt coz I am seriously trying to look at this from different angles here.
Irie is probably winning this. I love Niou, but it's a shame that this is his first match.
Niou is nowhere near Irie based simply on tier, let alone the practicalities of a match.
Troll Irie wins 7-5
Serious Irie wins 6-0
Two Trickters!, both are amazing, but Kanata is just better, against Atobe used is "troll state", and he beat him! , poor Niou not a fairly match lol, Maybe 6-4 Irie Kanata Wins
As for the match itself, Niou has access to a wide variety of abilities and stat combinations, so things like Saiki Kanpatsu no Kiwami and Bible or Myougi should definitely be considered here, and we've seen that he's capable of changing during the point.
Why would ZSS and Saiki be useless against Irie. You're saying that they are, but you're not explaining why that should be the case. Furthermore, Niou used Phantom for at least 49 points against Ochi and Mouri, a clean victory in a one set match only requires 24 points though. Could make the same argument for Rai assuming roughly equal amount of endurance for both his arms and legs.
Rai, the same. Niou's legs won't work after he uses it for some games, then he won't be able to continue the match. Is just that Irie would completely overwhelm Niou, as much as I like Niou, if Irie decided to go all out. Niou won't win this.
Irie got serious only because his acting got dissed. Atobe never dissed Irie's acting.
Yeah, Akiba walked over an Irie, but we don't know and cannot confirm what sort of Irie it was that Akiba walked all over.
Since Irie understands his opponents perfectly so he probably chooses what sort of level he plays at.
Yeah Niou and Atobe are same level, and yeah I expect Atobe and Niou to ass-kick Akiba but so what lol?
Irie VS Atobe, showed Irie just taking Atobe for a fool which I thought no character would be able to do.
Troll!Irie had beast stats in Speed and Mental I think. The Irie we saw when Akiba dissed his acting left Akiba on the floor and we don't even know if he was conscious haha. Don't know if Niou and Atobe could do that.
I don't like to go entirely by stats, but stat wise Irie should win.
Also if Niou does not know the real Irie, what good is SKnK?
Irie can hit weak shots to counter HJnK since his technique that he showed against Atobe was off the charts.
If Mouri managed to pull off returning ZSS, and Mouri is someone who relies on technique just like Irie, surely Irie should pull off something of the sort.
Becoming Sanada would be useful I guess, I don't know if Irie can return Rai. But at the same time Niou I doubt is as strong as Sanada, and may not be able to handle the toll for a whole 6 games.
What's the possibility of Niou becoming someone such as Oni or Tokugawa? Basically, on the big 3 HS level.
Kaoz I think you forgot to hide the results in this one, cause I'm viewing them lol
Niou can only become somebody he has seen play. Regarding Shiraishi, its likely he saw Shiraishi play during an earlier round before we saw him in the Semifinals.
Niou can become any Schooler he has seen play to a certain extent.
This won't be an ass-kicking of Niou. Niou will put up resistance.
Saying ''why can't he become Oni or Tokugawa?'' doesn't mean a thing.
Nobody anywhere right now can prove Irie is weaker than Oni or Tokugawa.
That Top 20 2nd Stringer list couldn't have been an accurate portrayal of abilities.
The list here has Nakagauchi in 8th, Yamato in 10th, Miyako in 12th, Takei in 19th and Yukimura in 20th.
Just the fact the list has one MSer means it can't be much to go by.
Also, we have no idea if the Top 20 even played one another.
Nakagauchi > Yamato based on their displays in the Team Shuffle just seems far-fetched and I can't honestly see it.
Secondly, if Irie never had a match with either Oni or Tokugawa, how can it be proven that one is stronger than the other?
Especially if Irie has been messing around this whole time.
Irie > Niou and we can't even be sure if becoming Tokugawa can save him.