Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (10/13/14 - 10/19/14).
Forum News: The nomination phase of the Community Awards 2014 is live! Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
HxH is the Best Manga Ever
Tie with One Piece/Naruto
Tie with Toriko /FMA/FT
I like HxH more than One Piece
I like HxH more than Naruto
I like HxH more than Fairy Tail/Toriko/FMA
2nd to One Piece
2nd to Naruto
2nd to FairyTail/Toriko/FMA
HxH is in my Top 3 Most Favorite
HxH is in my Top 5 Most Favorite
HxH is in my Top 10 Most Favorite
03- Anything by Hayao Miyazaki
04- Madoka Magica
05- Spice and Wolf
06- When the Cicadas Cry
08- Elfen Lied
09- A tie between Hunter x Hunter and Fullmetal Alchemist
11- UFO Robo Grendaizer
12- Treasure Island
13- Death Note
14- Digimon Tamers
15- Black Cat ((The manga))
16- A tie between One Piece and Dragon Ball
18- Mazinger Z
19- Lupin III
20- Azumanga Daioh
Runner ups (Not in particular order):
-Dragon Quest: Dai's Great Adventure
-Chobits ((The manga))
-Ninku ((The anime))
-Kurogane (Kei Toume)
In my "Top 3".
But I don't rank stuff, it's actually hard for me to do so. I always talk about bubbles of status that some things reach but they're not ranked in between the bubble. I'm afraid I can't explain it better xD
Even so, saying it's the best manga ever would be an insult from me since I don't read every manga there is to have an actual objective perspective.
Opinions on WHY MANGAS are being rank.
from Bakuman Chapter 90
Last edited by FaustXIII; September 21, 2012 at 11:51 AM. Reason: image is not accessible
Best "shonen" manga: Hunter x Hunter
Best: "seinen" manga: Berserk
well... those two are essentially tied for number #1
My top are an amorphous blob composed of HxH, Berserk, Jojo, and Gantz. Though I get most excited over HxH.
I voted best manga ever because I was too lazy to read the bottom options :P but it's not really the best EVER imo. But definitely the best battle manga and leagues above mangas like One Piece, Naruto, Bleach and such
I'd say it's a tie with FMA
---------- Post added at 04:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:26 PM ----------
Crap I missed the top 3 option T.T
Edit: Although even for a shonen overall it is not my #1
Last edited by Chrollo; September 21, 2012 at 04:32 PM.
I honestly have no idea where Hunter x Hunter fits in my list. Scratch that, I don't even have a list, just a whole lot of series which I love. I confess that Naruto is my favourite manga though (despite knowing that my other favourites such as HxH and One Piece are better series). I'll always be a Narutard. Please don't hurt me!
Well, I'd say Hunter x Hunter is in my top 3 or 5 depending on how I work the list, I have a list for anime only and a list for anime/manga/light novels all pretty much mixed in for top 10. Plus no matter how the work is crafted I rank shows soley on my enjoyment, so if I ever made a list I'd more than likely be frowned upon or slapped with fish. Seriously you don't want to know what series battle for my number one. XD
Even still Hunter x Hunter is a great series very high on my list, I'd probably put it above one piece, though it still hasn't beat my number 1, which is soley because of my taste bias and because this, OP and another manga are my own big 3 from WSJ (F**K THE STANDARDS!)
thinking about it, its pretty damn obvious what series I was refering to, but I'll leave it at that XD
It's my favorite shonen.
^I want to read Vindland Saga but first I have to catch up with JoJo's Bizarre Adventure
*reading part 2
Last edited by Netero; September 23, 2012 at 12:42 AM.
JoJo would be my 2nd favorite shonen. The reason why it is second is because I prefer a story like HxH where pretty much everything matters compared
to JoJo which has a very episodic and "monster of the week" feel to it. Not that it is a bad thing. It's just it would be cool if the parts were more connected.