Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (10/13/14 - 10/19/14).
Forum News: The nomination phase of the Community Awards 2014 is live! Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Translations: Gintama 515 (2)
Singles 2 Amane Hikaru Akutagawa Jirou School Rokkaku 2nd Year Hyoutei Gakuen 3rd Year Height 180 cm 160 cm Weight WeightA 69 kg Dominant Hand Right Right Playstyle Aggressive Baseliner Serve and Volley Techniques - Magic Volley
Serve order: Akutagawa -> Amane
This round ends on Thursday, October 18th 8 PM GMT.
Cast your vote and discuss (logically) why you voted for who you voted for. Have fun, but keep it clean!
Last edited by Kaoz; October 15, 2012 at 03:23 PM.
Jirou was the inferior player in his previous two matches, although the Jirou fanboys here voted for him and pushed him through both matches, but in this match, Jirou should be the superior player.
Jirou wins 6-4.
Jirou wasn't inferior against Kai.
I think he isn't better than Kenya however.
Isn't Amane the one who seem to stomp Hyoutei pre-regular+Hiyoshi pretty badly? I'll say Hiyoshi back then is most likely better than Jirou. I don't see Jirou 4-6 Ryoma, at all. Since we didn't get any improvement from any of them, I'll go with Amane.
I'll summarize my point
Improvement is unknown factor, and there's absolutely no way to know. Stomping Regional Hiyoshi is enough for me, for now. Compare to the feat Jirou have, which is absolutely pathetic. All Jirou got for him is "hyped". He doesn't really deliver on them.
Nah, Amane stomped what would have likely been Districts!Hiyoshi.
It was Regionals!Hiyoshi who lost 6-4 to Ryoma.
Regionals!Akutagawa got crushed by Fuji. Regionals1R!Fuji > Regionals1R!Ryoma. (1R = 1st Round).
That Ryoma was Muga-less. Fuji at that time would have eaten him. Ryoma just had Drive B and A and the Twist Serve lol.
I don't see Hiyoshi > Jirou. Especially at that time.
I didn't know Amane stomped Regional Hiyoshi. Bring a page. I didn't know they gave a specific time when Amane bt him.
and there's a page that says the same "100 Hyotei members" and has Wakashi's face on it but i can't find it (give me time lol). I read it yesterday
I just want to say 1 thing: if Davide reaches the net before Jirou, Magic volleys won't work because he has his long racquet. AND he's damn strong (he returned JK and Hadoukyuu single handed) so it's not one sided.
Last edited by Hardy; October 15, 2012 at 05:27 PM.
Jirou wins. 6-3.
Omfg he defeated 100 Hyotei members! Members which were lower ranked than Jirou -_-
Couldn't he defeat 180?
Is Hiyoshi really lower rank than Jirou? I don't see it. This will be a close match, with either side have equal chance of coming out on top. If Amane were given mountain training, I'll give to him. But beh.
And yes, stomp is assumption. If you beat 100+1 regular, that looks like a stomp to me.
I'm not sure about this, but I believe Amane defeating Hiyoshi back then is said in one of the data books. At least it's listed like that on FET.
It's a really hard choice, both of them are pretty equal, Amane has power to deal with Jirou, he returned JK and Hadoukyuu, Jirou won't return those shots. On the other hand, if Jirou didn't have MV, Amane would win this easily, but it's a match that you don't know who will win in the end.
Jirou wins 7-5, after knowing how to prevent Amane and his long racket from reaching shots.
Either way, Hiyoshi we can't prove is better than Jirou at all, so there is little point in bringing his name up.
he lost to Prefecturals!Ryoma since Ryoma didn't use Muga at all.
Then Hiyoshi got shat on by Tornado Snake which Konjiki shat on.
Then Hiyoshi got toyed with by Atobe which is in fact an achievement.
This isn't a given for Akutagawa however. But Amane has just been even more neglected.
And the way he lost 6 straight games to Regionals!Kawamura and Regionals!Momoshiro doesn't look too good.
And he and Kurobane lost to Tanishi and a random Higa fodder in Doubles according to the databook.
Forget what I said regarding this.Quote:
---------- Post added October 18, 2012 at 10:01 PM ---------- Previous post was October 16, 2012 at 06:54 PM ----------
Amane Hikaru: 2 votes
Akutagawa Jirou: 7 votes
Winner: Akutagawa Jirou