Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter! Celebrate another year with MH and read our yearbook.
Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (8/11/14 - 8/17/14).
Forum News: Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Now we all know that it was Obito who helped Itachi massacre the Uchihas. But what could be his reason?
1. So he could recruit Itachi?
I don't think this would make sense because the Uchihas are starting to rebel against Konoha. And with a little persuasion and a little acting the he's Madara, he could recruit all of them. And the whole Uchiha clan is definitely stronger than a single Itachi.
2. To steal their sharingan?
Doesn't make sense also. As I have said in number 1, it's probably easy to recruit those Uchihas at that time and sharingan eyes in an Uchiha body with an Uchiha mind that is rebellious against Konoha is much much better than eyes alone.
3. To prove that he is Madara and he wanted revenge on the Uchihas?
Nah. It wasn't revealed that Madara is "alive" until the Itachi and Sasuke fight.
4. To convince Itachi that he is Madara?
Why would he need to do that?
5. To force Sasuke's strength growth?
Doesn't make sense.
So what do you think was his reason for this action?
Last edited by llydnarz; October 26, 2012 at 12:36 AM.
I don't think is that simple as you say:
-Uchihas weren't insane maniacs, they were discriminated ninjas of Konoha, they planned their coup because Konoha actively discriminated them, and even then it was to regain political power.
-Madara hates Uchiha, and Obito inherited that "hate", and considering how he didn't care about a thing, I doubt he'd care about his clan either way.
-Itachi alone was worth way more than the entire Uchiha clan which, according to Itachi himself, lost all of his splendor anyway. Its quality over quantity.
-We don't know what they need the wall of Sharingan for, probably its one of Madara's projects.
We didn't get the full story behind it.
-Sasuke was almost a sure investiment, since he was brother to a very powerful and gifted Uchiha, meaning there were good chances that he would grow up to be pretty powerful as well.
Just like Obito manipulated Itachi, he could manipulate Sasuke as well.
It seems to me Itachi is the one who massacred Uchiha. Reasons were explained.
About the same time he caught Obito around the village. He realized he was someone malicious, maybe suspected it was Madara, so he joined Akatsuki to work as double agent for Konoha. Itachi was Anbu, and he first joined Akatsuki, and then later he massacred Uchiha.
So you have Itachi who is Akatsuki, and he has order to kill Uchiha, so he asks Obito to help out, and Obito is like sure why not.
For Obito to use entire clan as his pawns is too much. He doesn't need women and children around his hideout playing with Gedo Mazo.
Obito is like he doesnt care about this world anymore . i dont see what massacring the entire uchiha clan got anything to do with the moon eye plan . how would he have predicted sasukes potential just because his brother was strong . why didnt he just kidnap the uchiha kids and train them then feed em hashirama cells and potentially harvest ms and insert it into his left socket
Itachi FOUND him and then made that "forced" deal with Obito. He probably agreed Itachi does not expose him.
One of the key failures of the Tobito revelation is not establishing Obito's relationship with the Uchiha and the village etc etc. instead he just cares about RIN RIN RIN RIN.....screw you Kishi..
Just realized Madara doesn't know about the Uchiha massacre or Itachi. Wonder how he would feel about it.
Imagine, Naruto tells Madara in fight: "You killed all Uchiha!"
And Madara is like: "Killed who? what now? Obito what is he talking about?"
Obito: "Yeah well, we did that sort of, on the fly, doesn't matter anyway because Moon Eye Plan will revive them all right?"
Madara: "You idiot! Moon Eye Plan was just bullshit to drag you in, I planned to bring my clan to rule the world from the start!"
Obito: "Ok, my bad."
Having other Uchihas around may have ruined Obito's plan, that is why he killed them off with Itachi.
But as long as we will not have another FB about this, all we can do is theoryzing.
So he can have his own private, eye-ball stash.
Seriously? Strategy. You had the opportunity to take a strong piece out of the game. The only people who can control Bijuu are Uchiha and the Jinchuuriki. A young Konoha ninja called Itachi approaches you for your abilities and assistance in wiping out the Uchiha. Obito now indoctrinated with Madara's plan of world labotomization wouldn't hesitate at such an opportunity. The Uchiha were disgraced after Madara's defeat and the Kyuubi attack of 16 years ago built enough pressure to force the Uchiha to rebel against the Leaf. With the demise of the Uchiha, Itachi remaining to take the blame, and no one is the wiser about your plan, it's a win-win. The Uchiha are gone, you get some eyeballs, Itachi takes the blame, and no one can thwart your ace-in-the-hole, the bijuu. It's a brillant move and one anyone would take since this plane of existance is now dead to you.
I never could understand his reason behind murdering the clan, it could be because he was passing himself off as Madara who was betrayed by his own clan? To help Itachi kill his own people would make his guise that much more convincing. That's all I have been able to grasp. Still, this plot-hole still beats what Kishimoto is doing with the whole 'Senju DNA' logic. It's a complete gag-fest.
Last edited by shahdan; October 26, 2012 at 04:20 PM.
I share the opinion that Obito did it to limit the amount of people that could interfere with the plan. Those most likely to escape Tsukuyomi are full-blooded Uchiha who have access to the Sharingan. Meaning if anyone could oppose them it would be the Uchiha.
Granted... a Tsukuyomi powered by the 10 tails should be too powerful for ANYONE to break out, Uchiha or not... but better safe than sorry, amirite?
I don't think he was trying to recruit Itachi. More like he wanted to destroy Konoha, but Itachi forced him to target only Uchiha.Quote:
Those same Uchiha that could turn against Tobi. Group of 'em would probably beat Tobi. The eyes are probably backup for Izanagi, if need be.Quote:
He wanted to destroy Konoha as whole, not just Uchiha. If it weren't for Itachi, Konoha would have been in serious trouble because of the rebellion and Tobi attacking the village.Quote:
If there's an Uchiha that could oppose him, give him the biggest trouble, turn against him and stop his plans, that would be Itachi. And that's not because of his strength and power. It's because he's too clever and has the clearest mind. He knows how to weigh things and analyze situations to make the best decision. That's why he chose to kill his own people than start another war. So why choose Itachi over the whole clan?