Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (10/13/14 - 10/19/14).
Forum News: The nomination phase of the Community Awards 2014 is live! Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Translations: Bleach 600 (2)
I'm sure you've all heard me mention how much a love it when my polls are divided. So you can imagine the smile on my face in seeing that the poll "Will Koon's group eventually pull together or fall apart?" was dead even.
Now onto the review!
Chapter 121 & 122 Review
Ah, measuring Baam's power by seeing how hard he kicks your ass. A bold plan!
After we saw Baam's team finishing up the quick defeat of thier opposition, we got to see the real reason the plot started at the 28 Floor. That reason is the story of Horyang and the "Devil of the Right Arm", his former friend, Beniamino Cassano. Who is apparently the one who beat Hatsu and a person Horyang has been searching for. But we'll get into all that later.
Koon, for his part, didn't seem quite convinced by Emile telling him that Baam is alive but he wasn't able to dismiss it either. Ultimately, he set it aside so that he could concentrate on his next little project, "catching" the man who defeated Hatsu Beniamino Cassano; setting himself on a collision course with Horyang and possibly the rest of Baam's group.
Much of the second chapter was devoted to Horyang and Cassano's backstory as test subjects and how he got to where he is now. It was surprisingly in depth and seemed to put just about everything about his origin as a living ignition weapon on the table.
After Horyang was done with his tale, and everyone had bedded down for the night, he calls Baam out to a secluded area and explains his original purpose of joining the group was to confirming whether or not Baam was like him, a living ignition weapon. He ignites his arm and steps forward to find out.
The art in both these chapter looked, at times, unpolished. The first chapter was the better of the two, but only managed to look about average. Mainly, because any character who was speaking was usually reasonably well drawn. The problem was that most everybody else usually wasn't.
The second chapter, which was Horyang's tale, just didn't look very good. It had issues with lighting, shading, detail, and background issues coming and going throughout. This could have been a side effect of the chapter's impressive length but, whatever the cause, I wasn't impressed by the result. The greatest problem was how it failed to really capture and express the emotions of everyone listening to Horyang's story. From the way it was drawn it's hard to even notice Arkraptor in the room, that shouldn't happen.
The preluede to the 30th floor took an interesting turn with "The Hunt for the Devil of the Right Arm". It's a shame the art just hasn't been able to hold up it's end so far.
I give them a 3 out of 5
Points of Interest
The Hunt for the Devil
Randomly being caught on camera by tourists. The bane of Waldo and Carmen Sandiego alike.
It seems Baam's group and Koon's group may run into each other even before the 30th Floor, with Cassano drawing attention from both groups. For his own part it remains unclear exactly what sort of person "the Devil of the Right Arm" actually is; right now he's just something everyone's chasing.
However, I'd be kind of surprised if this ends well. At least for Horyang and Cassano. I can't put my finger on what it is but something about this situation carries the aura of tragedy. So I am not expecting their reunion to be a happy one.
The Human Ignition Weapon
Such a lonely guy...
Horyang's backstory explained a lot about him. He ability to go from a gentle person to scary person is representative of the two aspects of himself. One being the human, the other being the weapon living within.
His interest in Baam also apparently stems from him seeing something in him that made him wonder if he was a human ignition weapon like himself. This is a concept that, while interesting, seems unlikely as none of his attacks look like they "ignite". The red skeletal defense seems like the only skill with even a ghost of chance of being an "ignition" skill.
It also should be noted that Headon seems to have personally freed Horyang. This is no small thing. Why or for what purpose I cannot say but it's certainly something to keep in mind going forward.
You, sir, are no Willy Wonka.
The closer we get to the factory the more apparent it becomes that it is not a nice place run by umpa lumpas. Emile, and now Horyang, drive home the point that the 30th Floor is a place where bad people do bad things. This will almost certainly play a big role in the big showdown on the 30th Floor.
The characters in Tower of God are not exactly champions of justice with an iron clad sense of right and wrong but it seems like the factory is the kind of place where the heating system is fueled by pure kitten blood. That kind of thing has a way of making even characters that dwell in moral grey areas, like Androssi, smite some evil.
Last edited by Jammin; December 11, 2012 at 02:56 PM.
Most of my interest regarding these chapters is focused on the fact that A) Koon's group and Viole's group are looking like they're meeting before the factory round. and B) A lot of things are focusing on the Workshop.
I'm not sure if everyone is as interested in the Workshop as me but I think it is going to play a big role throughout the rest of the series, maybe not the Workshop directly but its leaders(McSeth, Flux,etc.) and especially the weapons it has created.
A good review, not your best, but at times, SIU was responsible for a lackluster story, so there wasn't a huge amount you could do with it. :P
Horyang's arm was always a source of more interest to me than Wangnan's murky past (I've expressed the opinion before that I could care less about Wangnan, especially as SIU has done exactly nothing to make Wangnan interesting to us, aside from the ring thing, but Karaka has one as well, so who knows), so to some degree, I am interested in how this story plays out.
If the question is, "Do I really care about Horyang in the grand scheme of things?," I would have to reply, "No." I care about seeing Androssi and the minor characters that we see along the way until we reach that magical moment aren't that interesting to me.
I did like how there was a grand explanation for this whole living ignition weapon thing and we didn't just get cheated with some lame ass explanation, especially how Headon was brought in to the whole thing. In last chapter's afterword, SIU did say that the Arm of the Devil was connected to the lobster, so whether or not you want to believe that that makes the lobster a living ignition weapon, I can't say. It could just be that it's a similar idea, but for the side that says it's not a living ignition weapon, they do have a good point as it's not how Baam fights. Horyang's whole combat ability surrounds the Arm of the Devil, from increases in strength, the actual Devil ignition attack, to a speed boost, to that shield thing, although the actual Devil ignition attack could be an amalgamation of all of the weaker forms that the Devil can take on. Like the answer to whether or not Baam's lobster is a living ignition weapon, we'll see how the Arm of the Devil works next week.
I agree that the art was fairly poor these last two chapters and that did detract from the story. The introduction of Cassano with that picture was horribly drawn, and, as you pointed out, the whole scene where you could gauge the reactions of Baam's team looked awful.
While the Workshop/Factory doesn't appear to be a very warm place, it does fit in with the theme of the world of the Tower not being a very nice place. Look at how Androssi had to kill/injure the other girls in her family in order to get any recognition. Look at how Koon's father casts out his sons at times. Rachel has been convinced that she'll succeed in the Tower if she "kills" Baam. Headon's test for irregulars literally separates the men from the boys immediately, as if you're afraid of the eel or can't survive in that concentration of shinsoo, you're a failure, which, of course, raises the question of how many irregulars have failed the test. We know that Rachel failed the test (although she apparently hitched a ride on Baam's entrance door, even though she left first somehow, and wasn't truly supposed to be selected as an irregular, but that's all water under the bridge at this point), but it could point to the fact that all of the irregulars that the Tower has known recently have been godly fighting figures, as the weaker irregulars are always immediately weeded out. Androssi even tells Baam that he can't save everyone and if he's not willing to hurt people, he needs to stay out of the way, as the truth is that in a cold, cold world, you need to be willing to be just as cold and heartless as everyone else.
---------- Post added at 12:51 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:49 AM ----------
B) SIU said that the story will focus on Workshop a bit more. And we are getting close to the factory round
Yeah I noticed the artwork too.
But at least for me, someone used to reading HunterxHunter xD, thats not a problem at all.
What matters is the plot, and about that I have never had any complaints.
Anyway, Its seems Headon have lots of hidden plans... He is messing with Fug, the 10 families and the Factories simultanisly lol
Now that is someone that likes to stir things up xD
When an immortal being like Headon says that it's been a long time since an irregular opened the door, then it must have been a very long time indeed, so I doubt anyone has entered after Urek aside from Baam (and Rachel)
Ok so here is my attempt. Please enjoy!
I'm such a sucker for that kind of thing.
And that was just one experiment
As for irregulars it's certainly plausible that some have been killed along the way but I doubt there have been all that many. As abc1233 said, Headon came out and said it's been a while since he's let anybody in and if they were more common you'd thing FUG would be collecting an army of them.
And I agree about Headon. Time to add another mastermind onto the pile.
---------- Post added at 10:19 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:13 PM ----------
LOVE your choice of music! The scroll speed was a little to fast for me when things got wordy but still awesome work.
Last edited by Jammin; December 11, 2012 at 10:43 PM.
It's also unclear what a long time is. In the life of the Tower, a few hundred years (especially as a year in the Tower isn't nearly as long as a year in the real world) might not be that long. I suppose that 1000 years might be considered a long time, as that's how long each Lord rules in turn for.
---------- Post added at 10:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:25 PM ----------
Of course, and hopefully, it won't be more than another 6-7 weeks before we see her.
Yeah, I know that his afterwords often contain possibly large spoilers, but if you don't read them, you sometimes miss out on things or don't get a clarifying explanation concerning something from a previous chapter.
The deaths of 99,999 children really is quite reprehensible, and considering that this was just for one experiment (albeit possibly one of the largest experiments that they'd ever undertaken), they could've killed millions and millions of children. The blood of children coat the Factory's deeds, apparently.
We don't really know if other irregulars had to take the ball test or any test at Headon's place whatsoever (Phantaminum sure didn't have to). Headon could've just made this test in order to trick Rachel and Baam.
you guys have a weird way of critiquing the art when it sound like your bashing on the art work left to right
critiquing" is, more or less.
It's not meant in a mean-spirited way but the only way I know to judge artwork is to look at it with a critical eye and ask yourself, within the context of the story, "What didn't work and what did? " If you can spot an imperfection, that's something you need to cover. If you spot something amazing, you need to talk about that too.
Sometimes it does seem like "bashing" because focusing on the negative is part of what you need to do to rate anything fairly. At least, that's what I think.
But what I was always taught is that art is about relaying intent. For example, if you draw a picture of a "table", you want people to look at that picture and think "this is a table". As long as they can do that it's a success. If you want them to think of a "specific type of table" then the artwork has to step it up in order to more effectively relay that. Comics step that all the way up to relaying a "complex story." How well the intent of chapters are relayed through the artwork is the only thing that's really important. Detail, lighting, and such is only really important as tools for helping to do that
I don't consider perfection photorealisim or anything like that. It's when the artwork helps tell the author's story seamlessly. To me that's the threshold for perfection.
Last edited by Jammin; December 13, 2012 at 10:39 AM.