Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (10/13/14 - 10/19/14).
Forum News: The nomination phase of the Community Awards 2014 is live! Visit new sections for Nisekoi and Kingdom!
Monkey D. Luffy, Roanora Zoro, Sanji
Donquixote Doflamingo, Tralfalgar Law, Vergo
Little bit of info about Film Z that inspired me to make this thread
--Lemme say this though, I'm not trying to find out who wins as much as I am trying to see where you think the monster trio stands right now...
The fight takes place on an island full of empty buildings, trees everywhere, it's very stormy, very foggy, full of caves and crevices, and no other sign of life besides the six fighters
They don't have to fight in groups, you can start them outside in the rain or inside a building, or in a cave... Bend the scenario to fit your imagination...
Due to respect for his opponents, Law won't switch their bodies...
>>Poll after a bit of discussion<<
Last edited by RezzieThaRapper; January 26, 2013 at 03:29 AM. Reason: Spoiler Tags
I'm seriously doubting that the Monster Trio would be able to handle Doflamingo, Law, and Vergo. Although, there are some difficulties in gauging this battle. I'd say we haven't seen the Monster Trio get serious since the timeskip, so it's difficult to grasp there ability. Also Doflamingo's actual ability remains largely unknown. But even so, I'd say that the Monster Trio shouldn't be capable of handling these three. Law is ridiculous, Doflamingo is probably as problematic, and Vergo, although he got taken out with relative ease by Law, pretty much destroyed Smoker. I think the Monster Trio does put up quite a fight. I'd say Vergo might be taken out.
The way I see it, Doflamingo's gang stomps.
I don't know... I think Zoro is superior to Law, I think he'd be able to block his ability with CoA and out do him in terms of swordsman ship... Sure the teleporting and electric shocks are deadly but it doesn't mean Zoro can't survive it... the biggest threat for Zoro is losing his heart, and I'm assuming that even that won't knock him unconscious seeing what Zoro has done before...
Sanji was at a disadvantage due to being injured by Ceaser while Nami had his body when he fought Vergo, so I'm sure Sanji could at the very least hold off Vergo given the chance to fight at full power... his biggest threat is COA Covered Vergo, he has Diable Jambe and Spectrem and a few Rokushiki techs but I don't think Vergo will land a finishing blow on Sanji
Luffy's combination of CoA and CoO give him a good defense against Dofla's invisible strings, and I'm sure he can dish out punches strong enough to make Dofla think twice about just tanking... I believe Luffy has superior speed and strength but loses in DF ability, but it doesn't matter if Dofla cannot grab Luffy... at the very least Dofla and Luffy should fight a pretty long time, enough for Zoro to defeat Law IMO to go help Sanji overwhelm Vergo, then it's 3 on 1 and I'd give this to the Strawhat Trio with Grievious injury...
I think Vergo is clearly the weakest of the three, but I think he's being underestimated slightly. He was able to defeat Smoker. And we simply haven't seen much from Sanji against top tier fighters after the timeskip. I think Vergo, based on what has been shown, is probably favoured against Sanji.Quote:
We lack sufficient information on Doflamigo's abilities to make such arguments. Even his DF remains unknown. What we do know is that he is versatile. If he was capable of manipulating Jozu, it would be probably be simple for him to do the same to the SHs. It is difficult to assess the exact outcome between these two.Quote:
With the matchups you've provided, I see two losses for the SHs and an unknown outcome. I think that would translate to a clear loss for the SHs.
luffy vs law -->win luffy gomu gomu no mi counters laws fruit quite good if you think about it
zoro vs. dofla --> hate me for it, but zoro would take it... strings vs. swords are never a good idea
sanji vs. vergo --> vergo takes it
Everything that gets cut off of Luffy, he can get back with a a little stretch. Also his gear 2 should be very effective against law. Not to mention that for fighting law u need midrange fighting skills and at this luffy excells truly.
We dont know it for sure yes... but come on. Its obvious from all the actions we saw from him.
can't wait till Dofla actually cuts loose, so we can really get started
Now I thought about Vergos strenght and it might help in some ways in measuring strenght of those from Monster Trio and "Dolfamingos Gang".
We saw Vergo fighting Sanji, Smoker and Law but we still cant measure their strenght with precision.
For me there was some very slight differences between those guys strenght in Punk Hazard Arc. For me Vergo, Law and Sanji are all pretty close as it was seen in their fight against Vergo - Sanji was only one of those who fought Vergo on Punk Hazard that underestimated him(he tanked his heavy kick, he stood before taking it on his leg with his hand in pocket and other hand on a cig, he was too cocky - but Law and Smoker knew Vergos strength from the start, they knew him for years, maybe they knew about his DF ability that we dont know yet(if he has any).
Smoker went all out against Vergo, when he started to feel that he will loose to him he went to Vergos pockets for Laws heart, If he could beat his commander he would do it and then give Laws heart back to owner, but he wasnt capable of beating him. What Law shown us is as I believe one of his strongest if not THE STRONGEST of his attacks, just at start of fight without taking any chances with trying to fight even a little, he used Vergos arrogance against him.
So I wonder will Oda use next Vergos fight to clear things up? It would help but to me its somehow clear now. But knowing Oda he can(for example) make Vergo fight and win against some top dog from Kaidos crew and hype us up with strenght of people that fought Vergo before. I do think that he is around Marco/ Jozu/ Ace level with Doflamingo being very close to Admiral fighting capabilities.
I would vote for a draw or Doflamingos Gang takes it with like 60/40.
Well, sanji already showed that he was able to match vergo even though he was in a relatively beaten up state when they just met. Sanji arguably would have done better against him if nami had not taken a beating in sanji's body. As far as weakest links go the strawhats are not behind.
Anyways, I would argue the issue lies in just how strong doflamingo is. In this fight the coherent matchups would be luffy vs doflamingo, zoro vs law and sanji vs vergo. Zoro vs law could go either way as far as I am concerned. Vergo does seem to have some sort of edge over sanji in the end. So the deciding factor would be luffy vs doflamingo. Doflamingo is supposed to be someone of true power and I doubt he could amass such great influence over the underworld if he wasn't insanely strong. To boot his ability seems specially dangerous to some degree, he ripped oz apart rather easily. Luffy has grown strong, enough to be an even match to jinbe however where exactly does doflamingo stand? Luffy has just recently reached true strength however we still do not have enough information to assert just how strong other people are. I am guessing doflamingo would not have an easy time and even if he does win it would not be precisely easy (although it does not necessarily have to be an even fight). I guess I have to go for doflamingo and his crew for now.
It's a really interesting battle, but seen the layout of the fight, DD's team wins this easily!!!I mean, powerwise they might even be on par (at best), but in such a ground, strategy and tactics would make a huge difference. Luffy is an idiot, Zoro might get lost and end up being ganged up, Law and DD have tricky powers in a Tricky environment with high intelligence!
Now, if it was a one vs one batte in a colosseum, I would give it to the strawhats with the DD vs Luffy, Zoro vs Law and Sanji vs Vergo match-ups, just for a matter of willpower taht it would make a difference even if they r close in power...