Announcements
Translations: Gantz 279 by njt, Fairy Tail 100 by Carlos Net, Kekkaishi 201 by Kaya, Persona 3 #16 by Ju-da-su, Yuu Yuu Hakusho v19 ch5 by HisshouBuraiKen, Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo 145 & 146 by StrangerAtaru, Kekkaishi 200 by Kaya, Double Arts Akamaru by Squirrellord, The Royal Orchestra of Guignols 01 by njt, Majin Tantei Nougami Neuro 170 by Bomber D Rufi, Psyren 35 by shrimpy, Gintama 225 by Bomber D Rufi, Anjuu no Chi 02, Blame² & Yugo the Negotiator 01 by Kyrie Eleison
Raws: Gantz 279, Code: Breaker 11, Vagabond 254, Fairy Tail 100, Ann Cassandra 04. Visit the R/T/S Section.
Releases: Samurai Deeper Kyo 149 by MAXBS, Hayate no Gotoku 91 by FoOlRulez, Elfen Lied 105 by endless abyss, Minami-ke 38 by Bakayarou, Barairo My Honey 10, Full House Kiss 10, Shounen Dolls 01, Akahime Ranshin and Midnight Secretary 21 by Aerandria, Private Prince 11-15 by Aerandria & Operation Boredom, Shiawase Kissa Sanchoume 12 by Aerandria & Intercross, Evangelion GD 11 & Slayers Revolution 4 by Turtle Paradise, Shigurui 7 by Kotonoha, Nurarihyon no Mago 23 by NKSH/JcScans, Area no Kishi 7 by Chibisuke, Bleach 322 by M7, Id v10 c05, Ares 126 & 127 by kmts, Blazer Drive 5 by INP-Mangaz, Sidooh 28 by Bakalicious, HSD Kenichi 158 by Yuisaki, Battle Royale: BR2 10 & Saru Lock 14 by Illuminati, One Day 1 by Illuminati & The Rabbit Reich, Tekken Chinmi Legends 3 by Noizy, Katekin 4 & 5 by Stupid Group Name, King of Thorns 27 & 28 and My Balls 18 by Strays, Yankee-kun To Megane-chan 15 and Yu Yu Hakusho 171 & 172 by ryColaa, Shin Tekken Chinmi 19 & Shura no Mon 25 by Minna-scan, Skip Beat 128 by Fluke32, Bitter Virgin 30, 31, & 32 (END) by Solaris-SVU.
Contests: No art contests at this time.
Sig Contest: Submissions #19-20. Votings #17-18!!! Winners of the Week #15-16 contest is Akasunasasori. Congratulations.
Raws: Gantz 279, Code: Breaker 11, Vagabond 254, Fairy Tail 100, Ann Cassandra 04. Visit the R/T/S Section.
Releases: Samurai Deeper Kyo 149 by MAXBS, Hayate no Gotoku 91 by FoOlRulez, Elfen Lied 105 by endless abyss, Minami-ke 38 by Bakayarou, Barairo My Honey 10, Full House Kiss 10, Shounen Dolls 01, Akahime Ranshin and Midnight Secretary 21 by Aerandria, Private Prince 11-15 by Aerandria & Operation Boredom, Shiawase Kissa Sanchoume 12 by Aerandria & Intercross, Evangelion GD 11 & Slayers Revolution 4 by Turtle Paradise, Shigurui 7 by Kotonoha, Nurarihyon no Mago 23 by NKSH/JcScans, Area no Kishi 7 by Chibisuke, Bleach 322 by M7, Id v10 c05, Ares 126 & 127 by kmts, Blazer Drive 5 by INP-Mangaz, Sidooh 28 by Bakalicious, HSD Kenichi 158 by Yuisaki, Battle Royale: BR2 10 & Saru Lock 14 by Illuminati, One Day 1 by Illuminati & The Rabbit Reich, Tekken Chinmi Legends 3 by Noizy, Katekin 4 & 5 by Stupid Group Name, King of Thorns 27 & 28 and My Balls 18 by Strays, Yankee-kun To Megane-chan 15 and Yu Yu Hakusho 171 & 172 by ryColaa, Shin Tekken Chinmi 19 & Shura no Mon 25 by Minna-scan, Skip Beat 128 by Fluke32, Bitter Virgin 30, 31, & 32 (END) by Solaris-SVU.
Contests: No art contests at this time.
Sig Contest: Submissions #19-20. Votings #17-18!!! Winners of the Week #15-16 contest is Akasunasasori. Congratulations.
Welcome back Franky House!!
As most members know, on December 28th 2007, Franky House was banned from MH on a scanlation case. Both parties (MH and FH) went separate ways after that. But those days are over now. Out of goodwill, both parties have come to a conclusion that there's no need to prolong this. So, MangaHelpers is now hereby lifting the ban on Franky House from the site.
Both parties decided to put the past behind and move on. It is for the betterment of both parties. There's nothing good coming out from this if it is prolonged, thus we decided to mend things and work together. All is for you, the worldwide community of manga fans!
From here on, scanlations from Franky House are welcomed on MangaHelpers again. Perhaps even more than that. Working together is our aim at this point. There's a lot of possibilities indeed.
Many people might ask if the policy on MangaHelpers changed. The answer is "No", it doesn't change. From our point of view, the ban served its purpose and is no longer needed. There's no longer a need to continue the cold front. We also have their commitment to avoid anything like in the past. That's good enough for us to consider and lift the ban.
It's not about the policy, it's about whether the ban is relevant or not today. And we feel that it's no longer needed.
It is all out of goodwill from both parties that the ban is lifted. With this move, I'm sure that both parties will benefit from the friendship and working together. We don't want the bad atmosphere to go on. For people of the community, you guys can expect them to post their scanlations here too.
So from this point on, Saturday May 24th 2008, MH is happy to announce, Franky House is no longer banned on MangaHelpers.
Welcome back guys!!
Both parties decided to put the past behind and move on. It is for the betterment of both parties. There's nothing good coming out from this if it is prolonged, thus we decided to mend things and work together. All is for you, the worldwide community of manga fans!
From here on, scanlations from Franky House are welcomed on MangaHelpers again. Perhaps even more than that. Working together is our aim at this point. There's a lot of possibilities indeed.
Many people might ask if the policy on MangaHelpers changed. The answer is "No", it doesn't change. From our point of view, the ban served its purpose and is no longer needed. There's no longer a need to continue the cold front. We also have their commitment to avoid anything like in the past. That's good enough for us to consider and lift the ban.
It's not about the policy, it's about whether the ban is relevant or not today. And we feel that it's no longer needed.
It is all out of goodwill from both parties that the ban is lifted. With this move, I'm sure that both parties will benefit from the friendship and working together. We don't want the bad atmosphere to go on. For people of the community, you guys can expect them to post their scanlations here too.
So from this point on, Saturday May 24th 2008, MH is happy to announce, Franky House is no longer banned on MangaHelpers.
Welcome back guys!!
Comments
Add your comment:
You need to Login or Register to post comments.
Benefits of registration:
You need to Login or Register to post comments.
Benefits of registration:
- * Interact with hundreds of thousands of other Manga Fans and artists
- * Upload your own Artwork, Scanlations, Raws and Translations
- * Enter our unique contests in order to win prizes!
- * Gain reputation and become famous as a translator/scanlator/cleaner!
#1. by nxlouco (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 11:38:53
Aww thats so awesome, Welcome Back Franky House!!! I agree nothing good was going to come out of prolonging the ban
#2. by Linkmasta (中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 11:48:52
Happy to be back! ^^
#3. by hissatsu (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 12:56:29
yosh. Franky House back. Niiiiiiiiiice!!!!
#4. by kyuuzor (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 13:29:44
waaaa,..thats great,..
FH back,..^^
#5. by Guts (英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 15:02:21
I am glad!!
welcome back Franky House!!
#6. by baboysai (MangaHelper)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 15:32:34
awww such a sweet reunion! ^^
#7. by weixiaobao (有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 16:37:31
yay, :D.....
#8. by ginousuke (Intl Translator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 18:10:45
That's great! Welcome back, Franky House! ^_^
#9. by gigantor21 (MangaHelper)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 18:46:12
YES. That's awesome.
#10. by gcd (中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 19:52:32
Welcome back fh, lov u all.
#11. by Waeyen (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 20:01:46
Welcome Back FH ^^
#12. by Em_Leingod (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 22:29:14
Cool, What were they banned for?
#13. by janu_onliners (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 22:51:19
YAYYY Welcome Back FH!!
#14. by DeepEyes (Intl Translator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 23:00:06
Wlecome back, Franky House n_n.
#15. by Viewtiful (下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-24 23:29:59
I believe that the decision to ban Franky-House was a hard one, and even harder than that was to accept them back here, but they were necessary. This story is better in the past, in the future it is better if both work together to grow more and more.
#16. by Charly10 (Intl Translator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-25 03:23:59
Welcome FH!
Rlz! (°<!
#17. by coungpow (上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-25 03:26:44
This is great! I'm glad franky house is back
#18. by imintheradio (英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-25 05:21:46
hm,finally all of us are working toward the better ways for worlwide community of manga fans..it's really good to hear such a good news..i hope both of this parties can benefit from each other!!!yeah...
#19. by Helltroll (英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-25 05:23:03
A good decision. Welcome back.
#20. by adachi2 (中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-25 05:51:42
Welcome back Franky House *o*
#21. by makhan (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-25 07:29:47
nice, I'm glad this matter is over :]
#22. by night_wolf (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-25 10:52:44
hi, welcome guys. im really happy to know this. as stated, only good will come from this.
after all FH are really good people to work with. :)
#23. by HanaTenshiHimeko (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-25 20:57:09
I'm glad the ban is served it's purpose instead of keeping the ban on so that FH could be forgotten and pushed aside. What a great mature way to handle the problem! Welcome back Franky House and thanks MangaHelpers for its wonderful work!!
#24. by sakura_hime04 (Intl Translator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-26 01:57:11
Glad to hear that both of you had been back together :XD
#25. by emer (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-26 04:44:38
Welcome : D
#26. by name1 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-26 08:38:15
I seem to be the only one opposed to this. They broke the rules, you issued a judgment and now you are changing your mind. I suppose permanent ban means a couple months.
When are you going to unban every other group / person?
I only wait for them to steal again. Then I can rightfully mock your decision.
#27. by yoniekai (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-26 12:28:18
^hehehe you registered just to say that? who could you be....
franky house is welcome anytime... like they need it, they have lots of visitors in their site anyway. but welcome back!
#28. by name1 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-26 15:20:12
I hope you as accommodating when they steal your work.
#29. by yoniekai (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-26 15:54:46
no i wont... but two infractions should leave them very aware of consequences. give them one more chance, they've been clean since then
#30. by heavens_dragon (英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-26 19:50:34
Awesome! Welcome Back, Franky-House!
Miss you guys!
#31. by renrutal (中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-26 21:45:15
"They broke the rules, you issued a judgment and now you are changing your mind."
I see you don't believe in redemption, nor forgiveness. Punishment isn't a life sentence you know.
#32. by Not_Log (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-26 22:17:41
My burning question is why did the group not have to issue a public apology for what happened? I would think this would be the very first thing that would need to be done before someone who stole cleans would need to do before being allowed back, as well as firing the offending parties.
#33. by craziii (下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 00:06:09
"We also have their commitment to avoid anything like in the past."
this above sentence is all you guys need. welcome back!
#34. by Mooncrow (中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 00:08:51
yay, I'm glad that crap is finally over.
Apologies and explanations were issued on FH's site shortly after the incident.
While on one hand, I supported MH's ban, on the other hand I'm really glad it's over, because the vast majority of the people that work there are great.
WB guys =)
#35. by ~Lilium~ (英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 00:56:35
awesome!!!! i'm glad everything's alright now :)
#36. by fluke32 (英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 03:49:27
whahaha all this time i thought someone just plain forgot about updating the RTS forum about F-H releases. LOL~!
#37. by OZ-900 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 09:08:54
1) call it "steal" if u want, but the real situation is explained here:
http://www.franky-house.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1659
2) I was in full support on MH's ban (mind u, i'm a FH scanlator) but this is the way it should be. Instead of having a banning war, we should work together to bring ungrateful leechers, erm, readers more manga =)
#38. by name1 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 10:17:06
In your post, that I did in fact read. I see this.
First paragraph you play the sympathy card, your leader is sick. That really has nothing to do with the situation. You might as well just told me your dog died.
Second paragraph, you play the victim. People steal your scans, it happens to most people. They report them to the sites, the remove the scans. MangaHelpers is fairly decent at this.
Third paragraph they play the well everyone is a thief since it's copyright infringement.
Seventh paragraph we finally get to what this post is about. The stolen translation. They say they had been given permission in the past. So that should have hinted some group cooperation or something.
In the eighth paragraph the play the sympathy card again their leader is more sick, it was Christmas almost all the staff where busy. They have no idea what happened, but clearly no-one is responsible.
Then they start quoting bible stories and play the sympathy card for the third time saying they use their money to keep the site up etc. Congrats every site admin spends money and time keeping sites up.
Letting Franky-House back in is a mistake. They are an entire group of new users and thus prone to fucking shit up. And when a group fucks up. It should be on the group not the user.
Bax was so kind to say, well the staff that where involved in this quit Franky-House. That doesn't matter. Franky-House let it happen. That means it can happen again.
They have already stolen work twice that we know about.
#39. by bax (Magnum Opus)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 16:29:51
[quote]
Bax was so kind to say, well the staff that where involved in this quit Franky-House. That doesn't matter. Franky-House let it happen. That means it can happen again.[/quote]
I wasn't meaning physically by it though.
And true, in terms of possibilities, they let it happen, it can happen again. But instead of thinking negative about it, why not look at it with a more positive thinking. They let it happen, they learned from it and they'll avoid it.
I don't know about you, but you sound like everyone who did mistakes will always do the same mistakes. That's a little bit too harsh, no? Mistakes happened, lesson taken. That's all the point of punishments. Punishments are not made to condemn people, it is made to make us realized about something wrong we did.
Then, for someone who was punished and learned his mistakes through the punishment, there's no need to continue the punishment right?
#40. by ddadain (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 16:31:38
I for one don't welcome the return of F-H.
The criteria of scanlation quality labeling of FH is much lower than that of MHs.
I find it strange that the decision was labeled as "for the betterment of both parties". As I see it, FH gets more traffic from MH, but MH won't get any extra ones from FH. The vast majority of people going into FH are only looking for Shounen Jump scanlations (i.e. Naruto, Bleach, OP, etc.) whereas the focus of MH has readily shifted to a more broad spectrum of manga genres. Those who deem FHs scanlations as satisfactory most probably will not go look for other scanlations of the same manga, for better quality. It is well know that leechers prefer "speed to quality"... just like Americans prefer "fast-crap-food" to "nice-home-cooked-meals" -_-
I am a bit disappointed with the decision to reverse the "perma-ban". I can't say it surprised me, but it just comes to show that politics (the kind we have here) & business opportunity (aka "the hope of more money") always tramples over justice.
Well, nothing can be done now, lest I ask MH to take back what it already said (again! which would be counter indicative of my point!!)
WB FH...
#41. by Nimloth (よろず屋 / Yorozuya)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 17:00:06
[quote]I am a bit disappointed with the decision to reverse the "perma-ban". I can't say it surprised me, but it just comes to show that politics (the kind we have here) & business opportunity (aka "the hope of more money") always tramples over justice.[/quote]
Err, I'm not entirely sure what you are implying by this comment, but MangaHelpers are not making any profits off of lifting this ban.
#42. by bax (Magnum Opus)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 17:04:57
Ermm.. I don't see where money is involved in this ddadain.
True, it's FH who'll gain more benefit in this move. MH will be as usual. But the goal here isn't related to money. It was me who approached njt and FH to talk about lifting the ban, not the other way around.
I realize MH has nothing to gain from this. We're not asking for their money either. They can keep it to maintain their site. We're always a free site, we even turned down offers for donations. It's just that we're satisfied that the ban already served its purpose.
#43. by bludshock (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 18:16:31
I'm not a huge fan of Franky House in light of their underhanded attempts to sabotage Binktopia and their majority role in ending Kylara's raws... but I'll agree that inviting them back on MH will benefit the community since they appear to have a broader lineup nowadays.
I think ddadain might have assumed that from the "perhaps even more" bit, which is a little distressing in itself. Not only are they fresh off the ban but the hint is dropped that there's something else in the works. Which also raises questions of why MH would be reaching out to them first and not loyal scanlators / groups who haven't been banned twice. Though I might be reading too much into that.
#44. by koenosaki (Global Moderator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 18:51:52
I don't see any point in complaining about this. A PRIVATE matter between MH and F-H has been solved. MH takes their own policy and I don't see any point in what other people got to do with this matter. Others are doing their releases on their OWN good way for mangareaders. But the same goes up for F-H, they are doing their releases on their OWN good way.
I truely believe F-H on what they have said (read their post), giving them another chance is an extra for this community and everything outside of the community (scan leechers/readers, etc). Guys it's all about manga and reading
#45. by 3955elits (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 22:06:28
glad to see the ban lifted...uh and for some reason I got annoyed with ddadain comment...we all read LQ just because we are curious about the story...and MS also released LQ nowadays(I got shonen scans from them,mostly naruto) but when the HQ released,I DL it ASAP and shift+del the Lq one...they got what they deserved for it..hope they learn from that and not repeating the mistake..
#46. by ddadain (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 22:22:07
Of course more traffic means more advertisement, although for the most part, FH will get more of "teh moneh" :)
For real, I'm REALLY trying to justify the decision of MH by making it more "GTA IV" XD Obviously (hopefully), sex & drugs aren't involve! XD So, that leaves money :D If MH doesn't gain anything, then the decision is like you stabbing yourself for nothing ;_;
ZZzzzz
#47. by bludshock (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-27 22:58:26
[quote]MS also released LQ nowadays(I got shonen scans from them,mostly naruto) but when the HQ released,I DL it ASAP and shift+del the Lq one...they got what they deserved for it..hope they learn from that and not repeating the mistake..[/quote]
Who are you referring to when you say "MS", if it's MangaShare, we haven't released under that name since December.
Edit:
"they got what they deserved for it..hope they learn from that and not repeating the mistake.."
Yes I'm sure "they" felt the full extent of the blow from you swiftly deleting their manga after leeching off of them. Do you really think any of you are in a good position to complain about any other group's scanlation quality being bad? If you scanlate yourself kindly stfu and focus on our own releases, if you're a leecher kindly stfu and do it yourself or join the group and help them if you don't like it.
#48. by manu (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-28 02:39:09
lols at the drama, Reminds me of the Narutobuzz and Yuma fiascos.
#49. by ddadain (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-28 03:09:12
lols ;d
MS's (Mangashare's) speed scans are the best! :D
nice scripting blud ;d
#50. by OZ-900 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-28 03:24:38
[quote]Of course more traffic means more advertisement, although for the most part, FH will get more of "teh moneh" :) [/quote]
i dont know what u mean dude
just in case u havent noticed, there's not one single ad on FH's site
indulge in your own "everything-must-be-for-money" thinking as much as u please
#51. by dsr (下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-28 09:16:00
Welcome back FH!!!
#52. by Reclaimer (中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-28 16:59:12
The possibility for redemption is important; however, it should only be granted to those who prove themselves worthy of it. You cannot try to justify your actions while apologizing for them. If the link provided by OZ-900 is their only public mention of the issue, then their ban should be made permanently. The level of hubris exhibited by that message, which also committed numerous egregious logical fallacies (common practice, traditional wisdom, and appeal to emotion), would make Lucifer blush. No one knows whether they will repeat their misdeeds, but they have not provided any reason to believe they will not.
#53. by iceflake (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-28 18:41:28
um... can't we just get along for now. If they actually do break the rule again then MH can just ban them again - this time permanently. But for now, why don't we just trust Bax-sama and welcome them without prejudice. Bax did say that the members that broke the rules have left the group so I'm sure the remainder of the group must have learn their lesson by now and would strive to do better.
Please don't judge a group only because of one or two rule-breaker.
#54. by fxu (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 00:19:26
an admin has it out for me...
lOl
#55. by name1 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 00:21:49
[quote]If they actually do break the rule again then MH can just ban them again - this time permanently.[/quote]
Yeah, they did break the rules once. Their leader was banned for a short while. Then they did the second offense of stealing the translation. They were perma-baned (6 month suspension)
So after the 3rd time they steal something we really perma ban them? Or is that the 4th time. Maybe the 5th time? How many times do we cut a group slack for breaking the rules?
#56. by iceflake (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 00:42:33
Like I said, give them another chance - sometimes people need more than 1 or 2 chance to prove their worth in life. Besides the perpetrator [which is only ONE or TWO person - A MINOR] that stole stuff have already left the group.
It's just not fair that those people that had done nothing wrong have to suffer for the mistakes of others. I'm sure you would feel the same if you're one of that people.
... Then again, I'm starting to wonder if FH is being discriminate for a much personal reason than thieving. My guess is that you want people to hate FH so that people don't want their scanlations - that would mean one less fish to fight against.
Urgh... humans are just rotten.
#57. by name1 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 01:01:41
First, brush up on some grammar.
Second, it doesn't matter if it's personal or not. They broke the rules and are getting far more leniency than well, anyone.
http://mangahelpers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=8132
That is a scanlator who everyone likes, getting perma-banned for stealing translations. Franky-house does it and it's 6 months. Does that mean Mangahelpers is going to change policy and un-ban Yume in 6 months?
#58. by xxxCGxxx (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 03:40:53
lol, very fishy for an individual who's anonymous to HATE FH very much.. are you the root of everything?
#59. by michiyohayashi (Translator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 08:11:59
Sigh. What is this... Drama - Part 2?
Why can't we all be happy? If FH does wrong, then ban them.
From what I know, the whole issue was a case of bad judgement (assumption that it was OK to use the translation), and bad mangament. There's also the lax regulations (letting newbie(s) work on releases).
Now think... If that newbie joined your scanlation group and not FH's, what would happen to your group? You'd say, "I WON'T LET THAT HAPPEN!"
But who knows what'll happen?
I for one am very tired of this issue. Let it be, see what happens. If FH screws up again, then you can go "HA, I TOLD YOU SO." Watch them for now and see what happens.
#60. by ttxdragon (Back in Blue)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 09:14:15
name1,
in the "Yume" case you linked, we were never in a position to even rethink this kind of decision. I don't know how much of the case you noticed back when it happened, and I don't like to refresh what happened with her, but after the ban was issued, the banned Yume tried several times through different accounts and name-changes for 'her group' to post scanlations meeting the same criteria as those she got the ban for. Creating Dupe-accounts and trying to tell us we're the bad ones made any form of a chance for redemption in her case extremely slim.
These cases are in no way comparable, since Franky House behaved very cooperative in the timespan of the ban, as soon as we got them 'charged'. Besides a few uninformed _unrelated_ persons posting FH scanlations, there were no complications. I don't know how it is in whichever country you live in, but at least here in Germany there's something like "letting imprisoned criminals back into the public in the event they've shown that the penalty served its purpose and the chance for them doing the same thing over is close to none."
#61. by yoniekai (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 10:55:35
name1, let it go, they've been clean. much cleaner than Yume (she did create dupe accts and even bashed MH from afar). trust me, FH is CLEAN, i've been downloading their stuff for a while and as a scanlator myself i know a group's style, if its stolen or not. ban them worse if ever they cross the line.
#62. by name1 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 11:16:53
You're missing the point. They ALREADY crossed the line.
They stole cleans, then they stole a translation. Why should they get a third chance to steal?
Also, your opinion is fairly useless to me as you are / where part of Franky-House.
So, stop playing the "Let's give them another chance then another chance then another chance" They got one, they they were perma banned. Now they have reversed this and quite frankly it sucks.
#63. by fxu (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 13:03:28
This is better than soap-operas
*gets popcorn and sits back*
#64. by nxlouco (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 15:06:16
xD True That...... Hey name01 Wanna Be My Lawyer?
#65. by Uozumi (上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 15:24:04
I believe in "forgiveness and redemption," however, I do not like the idea of lifting this ban. Franky House did not break the rules only once, which might merrit a second chance, but broke them up to two times that we are aware of. I think that reinstating them is weak upon the parts of the admins here. Yes, having a fast scanlation team on manga might boost the site popularity, but disregarding why the ban was placed in the first place is odd. It will be interesting to see if Franky House can abide by the rules this time around, but to be honest, I think that there's no point in punishment if the punishment cannot be carried out in full as per the rules.
#66. by yoniekai (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 15:42:52
@name1: im not part of franky house anymore, i quit months ago, i had a fallout with venicia honestly. wait how you know that, means you've been here for a long time.... ;\
what's your problem with giving them a chance anyway? how would it affect you? where you banned before, if you were, you can bring up your issue again to the mods and ask for an agreement like FH. would it affect the community? you dont really think something like franky-house shakes the foundation of scanlations do you? if my opinion is useless then so is yours, what makes you more credible than me? and you're even hiding your identity. stop arguing with me, or everyone here, talk to a mod
#67. by name1 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 16:36:34
I looked at your posts to find out who you were a scanlator for. Your first post is about Franky-House.
Mangahelpers forever has been a place for translators first, scanlators second. That is also what has kept it alive regardless of competition, etc.
njt and mangahelpers has until recently, had taken a very serious stance on stealing translations and any work. Now it appears they are attempting to shift focus off of translations and onto scanlations as this move removes mangahelper's reputation of upholding translators/scanlators wishes.
Either they stopped caring about the wishes of the people who provide content to this site. Or this is a misjudgment on their part.
#68. by manu (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 17:23:37
lols at the nobody thinking we care about his opinion. Maybe if the translators held any ill will to FH youd have a point but no translator has complained. Only a few scanlators (understandable seeing as how scanlating is stressful) and some damn noob. This isnt your forum, and it wasnt a decision up for discussion. you lost all credibilty as soon as you brought up Yume, I suggest you stop the flaming before you get banned.
#69. by bax (Magnum Opus)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 17:54:35
[quote]
So, stop playing the "Let's give them another chance then another chance then another chance" They got one, they they were perma banned. Now they have reversed this and quite frankly it sucks.[/quote]
What is it for you to gain from continuing the ban? As I already said, they already apologized, they behaved well and no reports of them repeating it. You talk about Yume, Yume was given 3 chances. Yes, 3 chances, as far as I remember. And yes, like manu said, this isn't about Yume. It's about FH.
Now gaining is a subjective matter, depends on how you perceive it. People can get more options with more scanlations, can read more series, have access to more recommendations, etc.
If you really think that punishment is for eternity, then it's sad for the people who have changed, being condemned for life. And you talk like that the unbanning has some effects on you. Why though?
#70. by name1 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 19:28:04
MangaHelpers is free to do what it wants. And people are free to be opposed to their new found sense of justice and rehabilitation.
#71. by bax (Magnum Opus)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 19:35:28
Do you have details and proof that it has changed? It has never been changed. If you're really interested, people who were banned have opportunities to say about their case in a special forum. There they can say their part and give us any details pertaining to the issue. Depends on the circumstances, some of them had their ban lifted on the spot, some were shorten and for some, nothing changed (the ban type/period).
Yes, you can oppose it. Sure. If bad comes to worse, then we're the ones who will carry it. Unless the unbanning will affect you somehow.
#72. by Nimloth (よろず屋 / Yorozuya)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 19:41:22
People with such strong opinions should also be posting their comments on their main account and persona instead of hiding behind an "anon" flaming account.
Don't you think?
#73. by bycker89 (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 20:35:28
:O good notice ^^
#74. by Kanzar (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-29 22:39:43
No, they don't have to. Why should someone displaying a 'more' anonymous persona be any less listened to than a post by their 'real' name?
It doesn't matter who says it, as long as it is said.
If you should think less of name1's posts just because they are posting under a generic name, then under the same logic, I should think less of you for not posting under your real life name.
A permanent ban should be as the name suggests - permanent.
As Manga Helpers thinks this is worth the risk - and the potential backlash should anything happen (touch wood it doesn't) - then it is up to them to shoulder the burden.
There are going to be some of you who will be able to say 'I TOLD YOU SO' if it happens. You can bask in the glory of your self-righteousness then.
#75. by Odinn (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 06:44:13
really name1 quit bitching franky house is a huge organisation and if one person in the organisation steals why should the organisation be penalised when it actively discourages stealing and punishes the individuals culpable.
whats your beef with FH anyway, i mean there are ppl who have stated their distrust but not near as much as you, really is it that important if they repeat ban them again and i doubt there will be a huge increase in traffic in either direction, i mean in my 6+ years of online reading i've found sites that substitute just fine, if a little slower than. hell, naruto chuushin worked well till it folded for a while, while they put mangaviewer up. trust me if both MH and FH failed today it wouldnt mean much, some slower manga for a month. groups like Null and Illuminati have been holding the scanlating fort for far longer than MH and FH combined.
Well said Kanzar. Well said
btw I am a newb scanlator for FH and go by the same name (by coincidence), tho i do have different names elsewhere.
#76. by koenosaki (Global Moderator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 07:40:16
@name1: you're right if you're saying that It's MHs decision for lifting a ban up. You're also right in giving your opinion about not agreeing to unlifting a ban. A discussion is about more than one person, otherwise it would be a monologue.
But let me ask you some things and please answer to the questions:
1. Did you just register for criticising: a MH policy for unlifting the ban? Why I ask? Well imo it's very strange you have 0 posts, you just registered recently.
2. Are you a scan reader? Are you a translator? Are you a scanlator? or are you some of them in 1? Why? Because your reactions are always so emotional and personal. You always opposes F-H and MHs decision on what could be called, depend your point of view, rational arguments. But it's here where I am disturbed you take rational arguments but on a personal way. I think others will feel that way. Is it something personal?
#77. by Crayola (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 07:41:10
maybe you guys should just lock this down...
#78. by koenosaki (Global Moderator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 07:52:36
Forgot one thing, Why I mainly asks this name1:
because you critize MH policy. Okay you can oppose this decision. But you're a member from, what I would have called, the decision day. You didn't say anything on the ban days? It doesn't feel right.
eg: would you like that a student, who has never been to classes (compare it to being guest of MH) suddenly comes for his first time to a class (suddenly he's takes part in tha class) and opposes the professor because he comes back on a certain decision (let's say leaving out some pages for an exam). That doesn't feel right no?
#79. by name1 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 09:48:03
My opinions where made clear during the banning.
#80. by makhan (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 12:19:47
[quote]yay, I'm glad that crap is finally over.
Apologies and explanations were issued on FH's site shortly after the incident.
While on one hand, I supported MH's ban, on the other hand I'm really glad it's over, because the vast majority of the people that work there are great.
WB guys =)[/quote]
Wow, man, you're still alive? :D
Good too see you, how are you? :D
[quote]The vast majority of people going into FH are only looking for Shounen Jump scanlations (i.e. Naruto, Bleach, OP, etc.) whereas the focus of MH has readily shifted to a more broad spectrum of manga genres[/quote]
I'll give you a hint: the vast majority of people going into MH are looking for Shounen Jump scanlations XD. And the only Shounen Jump series FH is releasing are One Piece and Bleach :p (sometimes also ES21 and Naruto, but I think OP is the only one released regularly). Plus at least 15 other series XD (maybe a bit slow cause our editors are busy with school). And I don't think Shounen Jump series is what pains you XD
[quote]I'm not a huge fan of Franky House in light of their underhanded attempts to sabotage Binktopia and their majority role in ending Kylara's raws...[/quote]
Well, I don't know much about that, I'm not active lately anyway so I'm not up to date with all this conspiracy thing XD Is there any post explaining it, I like reading accusations and insults :p BTW, I don't think I had the chance to thank you for the tutorial, it's pretty good work :] (to make myself clear I'm a pretty careless person, I don't have any ill feelings to anyone and when I read scanlations I don't really care who scanlated it; and I'm friendly to every scanlator, especially a girl XD)
[quote]Forgot one thing, Why I mainly asks this name1:
because you critize MH policy. Okay you can oppose this decision. But you're a member from, what I would have called, the decision day. You didn't say anything on the ban days? It doesn't feel right.
eg: would you like that a student, who has never been to classes (compare it to being guest of MH) suddenly comes for his first time to a class (suddenly he's takes part in tha class) and opposes the professor because he comes back on a certain decision (let's say leaving out some pages for an exam). That doesn't feel right no?[/quote]
I think he just wants to stay anonymous, he may have a clone somewhere here O_O (attack of the clones 2.0 XD)
@name1:
It's really edifying what you say :D It's really nice getting so much response from fans ^_^ BTW, I have a proposition for you. If you want FH to get permanent ban, just join FH as a scanlator and post someone else's page as yours. You can be sure we won't cross-check it with all releases. Too trustful, ain't we? How stupid of us XD
#81. by Kanzar (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 17:57:42
I do believe part of name1's ire comes from the fact that other users/groups banned 'permanently' are not given the same treatment.
Of course, it has been mentioned that some of those have engaged in annoyance tactics such as ban evasion. But somehow I don't think *all* of them are.
But yes. A punishment being removed like this... is setting a dangerous precedent that you can get away with anything here at MH, since they 'don't really mean it when they perma ban you'.
At least, that's the message being sent. Even if FH has stayed clean, continues to stay clean, provides (substandard) raws... the community will only look at the surface and go 'OH HAI SCANLATION STEALERS AREN'T PUNISHED!!1!!!!1!!!oneoneone!!'.
And yes, the raws are substandard. Yes, I've been leaving tips to the scanner on the FH forums, so at least they've started putting something behind the pages when scanning.
#82. by Odinn (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 20:55:14
actually FH has adopted the same standards as MH (prob copy an paste^^) but the fact FH has so many newbies its hard to keep the speed and the standards, well mainly the standards but yeah. FH is more a training group but we do try to get the scans out at about the same time as bink
#83. by Kanzar (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 21:16:45
I said raws, not scanlation.
#84. by kirimi (Translator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 21:18:12
Just a short note. A permanent ban of any active account is a big deal. We do not issue permanent bans without a thorough investigation and discussion among the entire global mod staff. Therefore, each perm ban of an *active* account (i.e. not including duplicate accounts (HINT HINT) and spam bots) is taken on a case-by-case basis. Please don't compare one perm ban to another. You do not know and cannot know the entire history causing a perm ban.
#85. by Odinn (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-30 21:33:53
my bad i was half asleep when replying though my comment still stands as FH scan quality has been brought up earlier
#86. by OZ-900 (初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-31 02:12:19
[quote]This is better than soap-operas
*gets popcorn and sits back*[/quote]
XD very true
this thread is my new addiction
dont lock it please XD
#87. by LadyHatake (Pandora's Daughter)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-31 09:50:22
Look, everyone, the decision has been made, whether you agree with it or not. I've been a mod for almost 2 years here (well, it'll be 2 years in August) most of which time I've been a global/black-op. In that whole time, I can honestly say that each and every case of translation/scan/art stealing has been discussed in depth, almost ad nauseam, in order to make fair and accurate decisions for each case. This also goes for any other problems, such as flamers, spammers, etc etc. Don't assume you know everything about our decisions. The discussions among the globals, black-ops and admins is detailed, thorough, and quite expansive. We may post a news announcement regarding the situation and an explanation for our decision, but that's it. We don't post every PM, every piece of evidence that has helped us come to that decision. There's a lot that goes on behind the scenes that no one sees. So, again, don't make assumptions as to why we make our decisions or how we make them.
I understand that part of this upset comes from what seems like a double-standard, but if every person who'd been perm-banned from MH were to show growth, change, and acknowledge their wrong-doing, we'd probably un-ban them as well. That being said, as far as I know, none have. That's why this case seems unprecedented.
What FH did was wrong; I won't begrudge anyone that point. But time has passed, lessons have been learned, and it's time to bring the manga community back together again. If something else happens, then we will take responsibility for it AT THAT TIME. Until then, I suggest a bit of faith.
Criticize our decision all you want, but if you have that severe of a problem with it, then I suggest you go elsewhere.
#88. by gin0va (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-31 09:58:13
one question, does this mean every scangroup that gets banned for theft gets a red carpet rolled out after theyre unbanned?
#89. by makhan (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-31 12:03:39
hi gin0va, didn't see you in a while, how ya been? :D
#90. by bax (Magnum Opus)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-31 12:11:07
[quote]one question, does this mean every scangroup that gets banned for theft gets a red carpet rolled out after theyre unbanned?[/quote]
What exactly you mean by red carpet? They get the same treatment after the unbanning like everyone.
#91. by LadyHatake (Pandora's Daughter)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-31 12:41:49
By red carpet do you mean us announcing their return in a news post? I believe the purpose of our announcement was to head off questions from everyone when FH releases re-appeared in R/T/S threads, among other things. Instead of everyone sending a flood of PMs, posts, etc, to the admins asking why FH was being allowed, it was easier to say it all at once so that everyone knew, rather than having to answer each inquiry separately.
It was a big decision, and a news post is the best way to let everyone know.
#92. by gin0va (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-31 14:01:44
Ah, I was just wondering because it all seemed to friendly with eachoter :P
I didnt mean anything bad with it though. :P
@Makhan, Hey Makhan, indeed long time no see Im doing fine, thanks, how about you?
#93. by makhan (Scanlator)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-31 16:59:24
I'm ok :D
#94. by Ardus (中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-05-31 21:06:13
[quote]Urgh... humans are just rotten.[/quote]
#95. by Guts (英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-06-01 02:25:58
just lock it down *facepalm*
#96. by freaky2 (下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-06-01 06:01:20
Great! I'm glad Franky House is back^^
#97. by fluke32 (英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member)
[Permalink]
Posted on 2008-06-02 14:28:42
HAHAHA, too much drama to bear from Name1.:XD
@Name1
Look, I'd tone down things a little if I were you. Coz, what your doing is what most would call an abuse of the anonymity of the net.
We don't know you, you have no posts from this forum for us to see your credibility and character, and even less ways of knowing if you are to be taken seriously.
Don't go mouthing off franky-house. Try building your own group from scratch and keep it intact for 2-3 years. It's a lot of work, and sometimes, there's too much work for some members that they would resort to some drastic measures at times. But that just means those members are just incompetent, and can't handle the job. So if those individuals no longer associated with the group, what's the point of pi
