Games Mafia Game 94 - Magi: The Crests of Magic - END GAME

[Asako]

Here the results of everything

 

[digitaldude]

Now since grysun was sickened we can deduce this.....grysun isnt the sickly townie and he didnt enter dungeon. It's possible he was copypanda murder!!

 

[Farfalla]

Then give me explanations on why voting for me. You three. What's odd? No, you four because Hardy jumped on me at the final moment. I guess that in his case he just felt Gry's words on "on people voting holt when EH started to get votes that's strange". Can't you guys focus on who's outside and actually did something?

And there's always need for a scapegoat because mafia can abuse the shit out of it by making town confused on who to trust.

Cause D1? And we felt like you could be scum?
Say we had succeeded at lynching you and we were scum, what was our goal in your scenario? We'd have nothing to gain, cause Holt - the alternative - was town. Unless you wanna build a case on how people wanted to secure either you or Holt would die, to save someone else like Hermit. Feel free to do so.
I gave my D1 reasons and said they were no biggie, if others felt the same or differently, idk. This argument got a bit tiring, feels like tunneling on something as if you're still in danger or being chased when you're not. Just to be clear, with those I'm not saying I trust the other 3, they could be wtv and have wtv agenda, I've alrdy stated the ones I'd give the benefit of the doubt and why, the rest I wouldn't vouche for. I'm just failing to see how the voting per se implicates me or them. I think you're being a bit too stubborn here.

 

[digitaldude]

ALSO WHO ARE THE UPGRADED GOI

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 24, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 24, 2021 ---

oh margi AND

 

[Baka Taichou]

I'm starting to think that there were only one mafia in the dungeon with copan, who was already target of many votes if I got it right. People were openly saying they would vote copan. This way that one mafia could confirm copan was dwelling in the dungeon, outright combine a kill on him so town wouldn't get a MV and it would go for someone else inside, anyone but Sakura since she declared to be a Magician. If there was more than one mafia there they could simply double vote one of them and make sure mafia would grab the MV. I still don't trust nobody. People pretend to be afk sometimes to not talk in the thread, it's obvious.

i agree with that theory, thought about it, specially since margi was avoiding saying she got it. but idk

Here is a recap of the hints so far, if anything is missed or if theres any mistake feel free to tell me, i will fix it next update !

Hints and claims

Hints and claims

1. GrySun as Hakuryuu
2. Scary Noona as Serendine - she said she has an active night role #42 and had the role before #56
3. Lady pompom as Falan -> said shes a magician #539
4. Evil3ye as Scheherazade - he said he has a relatively mediocre role with an action #75
5. Crescent Jinx as Gyokuen
6. Copy Panda as Aladdin -> Goi - killed on N1
7. Erinyes as Muu
8. MarmaladeSky as Morgiana
9. Equaling Heaven as Judar - claims to be goi #469
10. MArGi as Kouen - formerly Goi who received a MV #629
11. Digitaldude as Sharrkan -> claimed to be goi who got MV #472
12. Desin24 as David - Active role but boring #139
13. James Rye as Ugo - hinted magician who didnt want to block himself #499
14. Demonspeed as Kougyoku -> claims to be goi #471
15. Farfalla as Yamraiha - magician , her role was used in the prvious game (Bnha MG93) #501
16. Seraph as Jafar
17. Hardy as Kouha
18. Hermit as Yunan
19. Brandish μ as Sinbad -> said hes a goi #188
20. Shobu_Yoruichi as Cassim
21. Belserion as Koumei - claimed to be Goi #477
22. Holt as Masrur -> Goi - lynched on D1
23. Haya-san as Hakuei - said she has a night role she used on N1 #566
24. Shinobi as Alibaba -> never got the role before, she said she s a magician #549

Actions

Night actions :
N1
Haya-san use -> ??? #566


N2

N3

N4



Day actions :
D1

D2

D3

D4

Mechanisms

Mechanisms

Donjons


Day 1

1st donjon - element life - start
Players wo said where they will enter :
panda #22
grysun #24

Players who entered :
Scary Noona (non goi) -> voted panda #561
Panda
Margi -> received the MV
Gry (assuming hes non goi)-> voted panda #464



2nd donjon - element wind- clairvoyance
players who said where they will enter :
hermit #30
evil #75
DD #115

Players who entered :
Erinyes ( non goi) - Voted Marm #474 #480
Hermit (non goi) - Voted Erin #467
Digitaldude -Self voted - got MV #472
Marmalade (non goi) -Voted erin #502



3rd donjon - element sound - word
Players who say will enter :
demonspeed #25
Eq Heaven #47
Shobu #131

Players who entered :
Equaling Heaven -self voted #469
Demonspeed - Self voted #471
Shobu_Yoruichi
Belserion - Self voted #477
Hardy


Players who didnt enter any donjon
Lady Pompom
Evil
Brandish
Desin
Shinobi
Haya
Crescent Jinx
Farfalla
James
Seraph


Day 2

The 4th Dungeon- Element: Lightning - Negate
players who said they enter :


The 5th Dungeon- Element: Lightning - Negate
players who said they enter:


The 6th Dungeon -Element: Water - Gain
Players who said they enter :
Seraph #555
Eh #554

[/QUOTE]

I'm not sure if there's a point in me using my role tonight since it's kinda obv, so I'm gonna go in a dungeon too, gonna go to water element

 

[Crescent Jinx]

I would need to check back what the vote count was like at the time, but Heaven felt like the best shot.

I do wonder why you seem to believe in Heaven so much?

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 24, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 24, 2021 ---

Already said this day, Farf too.

Sigh...... here I go searching for it

 

[Erinyes]

Tbh, unless I'm brain farting, for a killer to target someone that could hold a role instead of ones that already have it would make sense if they wanna frame the others or snatch the role themselves.

same, only 4 people hinted active roles yesterday (Sakura, Evil, Shinobi, Desin) 2 claimed to be goi (Brandish /Panda) a logical mafia move would have been to target one of the active roles, but they went for the goi. Not to mention mafia might have known who was in the donjon and could discuss it at night.

 

[MArGi]

I do wonder why you seem to believe in Heaven so much?

Me? I didn't say I believe in Heaven, I was just wondering about the reasoning behind your vote switch.

I also do wonder why you seem to believe in Hermit since D1.

 

[digitaldude]

desin has a boring role but didnt enter dungeons hmmm.

 

[Seraph]

desin has a boring role but didnt enter dungeons hmmm.

Well if he has a role then why would he?

 

[Farfalla]

Now since grysun was sickened we can deduce this.....grysun isnt the sickly townie and he didnt enter dungeon. It's possible he was copypanda murder!!

Why are you assuming the sickly is a townie?

 

[MArGi]

Sigh...... here I go searching for it

Can you link to the post when you find it please?

 

[Marmalade]

Considering he didnt vote, maybe desin also forgot/didn’t have time to pick a dungeon? Mhm.
Or simply didnt want to be in one, despite the boring role

 

[Equaling Heaven]

Actually thats not quite correct....notice grysun was sickened meaning that someone used sickly at night. You cant both kill and sicken at night so that leaves a pool of 8 suspects. We are starting to narrow it down.

I meant to say that the suspect could be me or anyone in the list of the 9.

 

[Farfalla]

Not wanting to defend Gry, but from the principle mafia would spare someone with a role to kill a person that could gain one to snatch it (leaving the framing scenario aside for now), Gry wouldn't fit it since he voted Pandu. He'd have wasted a vote on his team kill target for the vessel to land on someone else. Unless we'd consider he lied, self voted and tried his luck to get the vessel for himself.
Now in the framing scenario, it's rather minor but James wanting to squeeze Margi (she had implied alrdy she had the vessel when she asked for the pros and cons of revealing it), assuming Gry couldn't be it and it had to be her, rubbed me a bit wrong.
Sure, the killer is outside, but with someone favoring killing a goi about to get a role, I wonder if it wasn't someone from the inside as well or a team outside of the dungeon waiting to build the case to jump on the other vessel candidates.

 

[Equaling Heaven]

Cause D1? And we felt like you could be scum?
Say we had succeeded at lynching you and we were scum, what was our goal in your scenario? We'd have nothing to gain, cause Holt - the alternative - was town. Unless you wanna build a case on how people wanted to secure either you or Holt would die, to save someone else like Hermit. Feel free to do so.
I gave my D1 reasons and said they were no biggie, if others felt the same or differently, idk. This argument got a bit tiring, feels like tunneling on something as if you're still in danger or being chased when you're not. Just to be clear, with those I'm not saying I trust the other 3, they could be wtv and have wtv agenda, I've alrdy stated the ones I'd give the benefit of the doubt and why, the rest I wouldn't vouche for. I'm just failing to see how the voting per se implicates me or them. I think you're being a bit too stubborn here.

If by stubborn you mean I want clarifications on why you would come at me as odd when I had the same mindset as copan about the dungeon filling thing, who is a confirmed dead town, then yes I am. Or whatever. But leave it be then, I don't feel like draggin you guys busy agenda anymore.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

Yeah @Hermit I thought you were Magician and were like „shit I shouldn‘t have entered a dungeon because of my active role“ but then you enter a dungeon anyway? What‘s up with that, why even ask about it if you didn‘t intend to change.

this?

 

[Equaling Heaven]

ALSO WHO ARE THE UPGRADED GOI

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 24, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 24, 2021 ---

oh margi AND

I think only the one in my dungeon is left. I self voted and got nothing, same with demon.

 

[Farfalla]

Considering he didnt vote, maybe desin also forgot/didn’t have time to pick a dungeon? Mhm.
Or simply didnt want to be in one, despite the boring role

About that, we have this:

Damn, not being familiar with Magi certainly does not help. So entering Dungeons means you can't use any action right? My role is active but rather boring so I will probably be joining a dungeon.

And even tho he apoligized for not being around, we got this:

I'll be all yours until the end of the phase now time to backrest.

Aside from getting himself some penalty, he's one of the people I have in mind for today.

 

[Haya-san]

@Haya-san When and how are we going to profit from you using your role?

When: At night. How: it's one of those abilities that I'm not sure it really works or not. I used it last night, but I don't know if it had any effect on the outcome of the first night.

 

[GrySun]

this?

Yes. He asking nervously about if he can still decide not to enter a dungeon sounded like a strong role, say Doc/Det, noticing they made a big misplay. So that seemed genuine. But then he stayed in the dungeon, and I doubt he ever answered my question regarding that.