On phone at work and haven’t really wrapped my head around this yet but first thoughts:
Okay, so one of the alleged Spys is dead (that’s the only role he could be strongly hinting at, right? Saying he could confirm active/passive roles). Doesn’t give us any more clarity on the Vandred/Farfalla claims but I’m leaning strongly toward Farf not being legit.
For one she didn’t mention anything about Panda’s hints being contradictory to there already being two Spy claims, despite being active in the discussion concerning his hint. Instead she revealed herself “outing” both herself and Van as claiming Spy, (possibly to send her fellow Mafia the message that he should go for another role?). Feels like a non-Town thing to do, to “out” two investigative roles (even if the other one could be fake).
Van also called her out on her initial claim which, if he were Mafia, he wouldn’t have had to do if he was gonna claim Spy. He could’ve just waited and killed her on N1. Since no one but him was getting her claim, he could’ve let it slide but didn’t. Which is why I trust his claim more than Farf’s.
Also, there’s no other way for this night to have played out than a successful Insane Doc kill + successful block or save, right? Or am I missing something?
Kay, back to work.