Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (2/16/15 - 2/22/15).
! Visit the new forums for Tokyo Ghoul and The Gamer!
Forum News: Vote in the final phase of the Anime Awards 2014
One of the reasons we have this forum's so we can get a second opinion on troublesome lines and such. Well, I've got one here for y'all: Yamato's shikondeoita line (the first line, actually) in chapter 298.
Ahem... I reproduce:
Here's the thing: I'm pretty sure most translations up until now have not gotten that particular line just right, but I don't feel I'm getting it right either. So I wanted to see if anyone could come up with anything better.
This is the translation I've been mulling until now:
Yamato: And Id taken care to hide it in there at the Hot Springs, just in case...
Yeah - not too hot, is it. I consulted on the line with my Japanese teacher, but it's not like she knew follows the manga or like I could show her the entire chapter.
"Aitsu" is either Sai or something of Sai's. (Aitsu ni wa)
The one who did the action is Yamato - definitely not Sai.
Whatever Yamato did, he did so at the hot springs (onsen chi de)
And whatever he did, he did in an offhand manner as a precaution (ichioo, -deoita).
The problem is that the verb shikomu has no object, and in English we're in dire need of an object. Thus, the question is, WHAT!
Sensei's conjecture: hes talking about a tracking device or something he put on Sai. More specifically, her guess is (and I find it reasonable) that Yamato put a tracking device in Sais things. However, since Sai dropped his things, Yamatos no longer able to use it to track him. Thus, the following sentence.
Yamato: Well, whatever! I'll just follow them as-is*.
Thus, as-is would mean without a tracking device, assuming Sensei and I are correct.
Finally, there's this line, which I saw a lot of mistakes on:
It's also pretty difficult, but basically he's saying he's good at trailing/pursuing.
"Truth be told, I'm more capable at trailing than not."
The reason I'm using "trailing" instead of pursuit is simply that it seems to me they're beyond his visual range, so he has to figure out more or less where they're going as he moves along. Ultimately, it might just be a matter of preference.
Anyway, remarks on this last line where merely informative; the question is how to translate the first line in the chapter.
I believe Yamato meant Sai hid his thing for Oro when he was at the hot springs, so Yamato did not find it:
Yamato: And he'd taken care to hide it there at the Hot Springs ( when we where at the Hot Springs ), just in case...Originally Posted by Iwanin
( don't know japanese, but that sounds logical... )
Nope, it's definitely Yamato who did the hiding/implanting whatever. This much is certain.Originally Posted by Khaludh
Yeah, I noticed the translations problems for that line also...
アイツ in terms of its anaphoric relationship is just Sai himself (although, technically speaking, contextually it's obviously Sai's belongings).
A tracking device of some kind seems most likely as far as an object for 仕込む-ing.
Don't get too hung up on the technical, literal meaning when translating and just change the phrasing to something that contextually fits, still more or less means the same thing, and allows for the same degree of vagueness. In other words, do something like turning it into Yamato saying something along the lines of having "taken precautions" with Sai's luggage.
そうですねえ。。。still, the problem of how to make it suitably vague remains... suggestions are welcome.Originally Posted by Nihongaeri
I'll throw a few off the top of my head to get things rolling (and lets be rolling people).
"And I'd taken those precautions at the hot springs for just such eventuality... " problem: doesn't directly link Yamato's actions to Sai.
"And I'd rigged his things at the hot springs just in case this happened..." problem: rigged...hmmm....
"Looks like what I added to his luggage at the hot springs is not gonna do me much good..." loses the "ichiou/oita" nuance, but ties in very nicely with the sentence that follows.
Awaiting feedback from you guys. Mods, feel free to chime in with your own thoughts.
Wow, I totally missed this in my translation. It makes sense now why Sai would toss his stuff, lol.
I should have just said what I was thinking yesterday, but I have serious self-esteem issues...
Anyhow, 299 confirmed my interpretation... The 仕込み is still on Sai somewhere (i.e. it isn't in the stuff that Sai dropped). If it were that Yamato (木分身版） had noticed that the 仕込み got dropped, then it should have been アイツには一応温泉地で仕込んでおいたのにな instead...
In other words, Yamato's words there are something along the lines of "I have already taken the precaution of doing wadda-dee-wadda to Sai and/or his belongings, but whatever... If it's a chase they want, then I'll give them one"... The このままで is semi-superfluous and doesn't particularly refer the 仕込み being neutralized.
Yeah, I'd also figured there should have been a "noni" in there, but the rest of Sensei's assumption sounded reasonable enough, so... I guess the "maa ii ka!" is more like a "Yeah he's a traitor, but whatever".Originally Posted by Nihongaeri
But yeah, upon reading 299, I PMd a corrected version to Terra, which I now reproduce. I know you don't normally rig a person, but using the verb allows me to remain ambiguous just in case it's not a mere tracking device.
Yamato: Yeah, Id taken care to rig him at hot springs, just in case...
Yamato: Well, whatever! I'll just follow.
Yamato: Truth be told, I'm more capable at trailing than not.
Anyhow, further suggestions are welcome but no longer imperative. Thanks again for all your help, everyone - especially you, Nick!