Themes don't matter
They do, at least a little. They are not the biggest factor ever, but it makes the game a bit more enjoyable. I really enjoyed the LoL and Bleach games for example.
Whether a game will be good/entertaining has nothing to do with the theme. The only thing the theme does is maybe get people to play who wouldn't otherwise. Just like you said, OP is a good theme, but you found the game to be sucky.
OP theme was chosen out of random because no one was really taking that game seriously.
Themes make a huge part on the enjoyment of the game, at least for me.
Are you guys serious? The theme is for a few lulz at most. It has nothing to do with the dynamics of the game...
Why wouldnt I be serious? Themes make everything more interesting, specially if the host can handle it well.
Well, I'll just say that the theme has little bearing on whether I sign up for a game or not. And I don't believe it ever will, but oh well.
Good for you gary ^^
Gary, that's great for you, and while most of the time, I would never care about a theme, other than for interesting avis, the OP theme is one that I wouldn't play in.