I just missed that hint from Hardy, and in the end, he wasn't third party, but maybe he got his role in blue before the game started (not that it matters now).
So it's possible that we have only 3 mafias, right? That's a good thing.
On one hand, it's weird that the mafia didn't try to kill someone who claimed to be a detective (Haku). Maybe they didn't do it 'cause, in case Haku is indeed a detective, his first investigation alone would lead him nowhere. Plus, he didn't try to survive the voting, he said he'd vote like a man and bla bla bla. I think that mafia are more commited to their team than townies, so I think a mafia member wouldn't surrender or compromise his team like that. Anyway, I'd rather not risk killing a detective on day 2... If they both are telling the truth (Haku and DD), that could benefit us a lot. Leave if to mafia to get rid of them, we should be more cautious, imo.
Mido again, in first night. He's becoming another cursed player.
I was thinking he might be the Sickly, but apparently, that was a misjudgment for my side. At any rate, Serial Killer's death is sort of a good development. With two killing parties, the game would be developing pretty fast and Mido would always be very difficult to spot as a Third Party.
I wonder what happened to Hardy, though.
I was expecting to be recruited this night, since I came out with my role earlier than planned. Looking back at it, Hardy apparently didn't want me dead in late first day. Or he could have possibly gone for Mido instead, thinking he would be targeted at first night.
I think it's time to try and get a list prepared.
---------- Post added at 06:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:47 AM ----------
The list is ready. Someone post something so that it doesn't get auto-merged with this post, please.
I would like to have it as a separate post.
3 of 13 votes
3x Hakuteiken (Kuro/xi0, Arlong/Faust, Blackbeard, digitaldude)
Dayphase ends in 21h!
Hope that helps Haku ....barely any discussion since the day started
01 digitaldude- Detective - Found Haku guilty at first night. Seems to be playing with his usual style. Fairly trustworthy.
02 gnut - Suspected me early on, but decided not to vote for me. Later on, he suspected Mazino. *Gary,Falla,lawls and DD, he says, as his suspect list. *Thought either DD or Haku was lying. *Detective(?) Investigated Faust and the result was not guilty.
03 lawlett-kun - He has been staying back, he could have one of the roles that require him to do so not to die, a la Sickly Townie. I always suspect him for who he is (), but the suspicion is pretty low at this point. *Hard to give clues without revealing much, he says. *Bomb(?)
04 Hardy- Mason Recruiter - Mafia/Serial Killer target or recruited the wrong person. Could be killed by an Insane Doctor.
05 MidoBan- Serial Killer - Mafia target/Possibly killed by an Insane Doctor.
06 Josef K. - Highly inactive *Could possibly get killed by the host. *Prostitute(?) There is almost no reason to claim this role as a Mafia, so, he is nearly completely cleared. Targeted Naomidee first night. *Targeted Haku second night.
07 TheBoss - One of the guys that went under radar for me. I don't really have a good/bad feeling about him. That kind of makes him a suspect, but of low degree. *Seems to believe in what Naomi put out so far. *Sickly Townie(?) Infected Haku and xi0, respectively.
08 Farfalla - Looked pro-Townie to me, since her posts were rather calm and not rushing to anything. Fairly trustworthy to a degree. *Cautious about making a wrong move, she doesn't seem willing to join quick bandwagons. * Vigilante(?) *Thinks of Boss or dark lord as the Doctor alive in the game. *Vigilante killed Mazino.
09 Mazino - My first day suspect, since he was laying low. gnut shared the same idea, but we have nothing concrete. Suspect of low to mid degree. *He doesn't want to reveal his role at this point.
10 dark lord - As in the case of Farfalla, he seemed to be in no rush to support bandwagons. Fairly trustworthy to a degree. *Considers three Mafia members to be present at the moment.
11 X3D2YFaust - Appeared in the dying minutes of the phase and became one of the reasons Milly died. Either he didn't want me dead or he wanted him dead badly. Looks a bit personal reasoning to vote. Still, that unusual action makes him a suspect of mid to high degree. *Didn't come out with any proper response to my initial suspicion and he has continued his inactivity. Remains as a suspect.
12 Imperium - Another person who was highly inactive. Then again, this could mean little, at least to this point, since he wasn't even on time to vote. *Got into a debate with Gary over the strength of his arguments. What he usually does, as analytical player, so, difficult to tell at the moment. *Townie(?)
13 M3J- Townie - That trollish attitude was a blunder, but we did no good when players jumped at him.
14 xi0 - Demands not to be recruited. I can't really say which role, but he should have a strong role that he wants to play with. At least, that's the implication. *Votes for me again for the previous day's reasons. As pointless as those reasons are from my perspective, they are still better than what we had against any other player, I'd say. Makes him fairly trustworthy, also taking his style into consideration. *Got blocked by the Sickly Townie. Would vote for Haku.
15 Naomidee- First, the use of words made me think she had a daytime kill ability, a la Vigilante. But I don't think that was the case, if it wasn't a blunder. Claims to have a pro-Townie role. *Early burst of activity, then a bit of step back makes her a suspect of low to mid degree. * Doctor Her target did not die last night.
16 Hakuteiken - Detective(?) - First day suspect, for an early random vote and asking about doing the list. *Changed vote to Mazino later on, who wasn't really going to die at that point, instead of Milly, since he thought of him as a troll Townie rather than a Mafia. Claimed the role not before Mido asked him to do so. *Investigated Imperium first, as in the Death Note game. Result is not guilty. *Investigated Faust, no result. Got blocked by Josef.
Confirmed Roles: Mason Recruiter Sickly Townie Regular Townie Doctor Detective Vigilante Serial Killer
Claimed Roles: Detective Detective Prostitute Townie Bomb
Suspect List for Haku
*Low Tier: gnut,
*Low to Mid Tier: Naomidee (Dead), Mazino, xi0, lawlett-kun, dark lord.
*Mid to High Tier: X3D2YFaust.
Trusted People List for Haku
dark lord, Josef, TheBoss xi0.
Well, that's it, I guess. At least, I don't think I missed out on any points that need a place in this list. Remind me of them if some are missing.
Last edited by Hakuteiken; March 29, 2013 at 07:50 PM.
You seem to be defending him a bit though, Alvida. Are you in cahoots with him?
I don't have a daytime ability other than voting for someone to be lynched. I was just trying to get into character by saying I'm not a back-stabber that kills in the night. I didn't realize it would be over-analysed like that. It was bad wording on my part, like you said. I'm a little rusty. I had an early burst of activity because that's how I always play. I like to get REAL discussions going, since I hate hate hate all of the spam that typically happens in the first day. Or worse, throughout the entire game.
And I backed off later because I wasn't able to post for the remainder of the day, I clearly said that before taking leave. I did read everything and catch up yesterday and this morning though.
Naomidee is suspicious to me ...
---------- Post added at 08:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:18 AM ----------
I'd like to hear more, seeing as you haven't posted very much. If you're mafia, that gives you a big advantage.
So go on.
There is the Mafia side or roles like Bomb, Bulletproof that would benefit Townie side even if he was targeted. He could be of either camp in that sense.
It wasn't really an over-analyze. For a moment, I just thought you were implicitly hinting at it, rather subconsciously, but I don't think that way any more.
Hm, so, you are a DD type, getting active early on to speed up the process. I wouldn't know about it since this is my first time seeing you play. That's why I put you in the second tier. Unless something new comes up, there is currently next to nothing reason to vote for either of low to mid tier suspects.
Sorry for not voting yesterday, I got high, thought I did, etc. I've been given another chance though, like a recovering heroin addict niichan kindly said to me he still believes in me. It was beautiful. Anyway going back to read some stuff I missed.
And that's true. I dunno. I'll consider it I guess, but I'm not convinced.
Naw, I don't think that I've ever played with you. But yes, I do discuss a lot and don't really hold anything back. When I'm townie, it's easy to do those things like right now. I'm always aware that I'm taking a risk by posting a lot and throwing things out on the table, but I'm willing to do that in order to try and help people that are really suspicious come to light.
"She stands out" is a bad reason. I think "she is trying to stay off the radar" is far more suspicious than actually throwing yourself into the game without fear of 'standing out'.
And I'm sacrificing my early morning work out time for this, god damn it! I expect a few more people other than Haku and I to start standing out!
---------- Post added at 08:37 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:34 AM ----------