If so, provided there are no hostkills, our best bet would be to pick one, vigilante kill a guy and if it doesn't work out, lynch the other.
Then again, gnut did it in the last game and it didn't happen to be necessarily working.
---------- Post added at 01:38 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:27 PM ----------
Help me update the suspect list. Faust is a suspect. Chances of Mazino being a Mafia seems to be on the rise.
And I don't really trust Gary anymore. I don't know, the last time I sort of bought into what he said, I ended up getting fooled. Besides, he has almost said nothing aside from constantly bringing up the same points about me in the first day.
Who else now?
I have to leave because something urgent came up, I will probably be back around the time the phase ends. If someone feels like updating the list when new votes come in, feel free to do so. Besides that, everyone who didn't vote or made the necessary posts should be aware that he will receive a hostkill =/ I don't like it, but rules are rules.
haku's time to troll has come
Okay, so, the Detective schema again, here.
1) gnut is faking his role. Difficult to pull out a Third Detective claim, but with tons of pressure on both me and DD at that stage, he could be fairly sure that he would be trusted, more or less.
2) gnut isn't faking his role and he's a Detective.
2a) If we disregard the Paranoid role for a while, DD was Insane, and either me or gnut is Naive, and the other one is sane.
2b) If we take the Paranoid into account and say DD was Paranoid, both of us could also be Insane, not to mention one of the guys we investigated could be the Mafia Boss.
---------- Post added at 01:53 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:52 PM ----------
I'll shoot this clown down into hell
Yeah, I'd love to shoot GB as well, but I don't wanna hit the bomb... again @.@
I investigated maz because 1st day he was in and out...but the same day faust came with that bullshit about his internet....I didn't think much of it that day but the next he says the same thing...internet is messing up...I decided to look at him...
now,this is why I was so sure either Kute or DD was lying...like you guys...I thought it would be 2dets/2docs...but I was wrong again.
if anything...if you guys cant tell by my game play that im a noob...you should know I could not come up with such an elaborate scheme
DD and Kute got innocent on Imp....Maz and Faust innocent by me...
but if you shoot me down then haku will loose his muse of inspiration. how will you deal with that i wonder?u.u
Well, still, the Bomb claim has been a little bit.. too convenient.
First of all, you said you could hardly give any clues without completely revealing it and you said we'd be screwed if you did so. The Bomb claim doesn't actually screw the Townie game. Indeed, it does take out a bit from the role since that makes Mafia to back off from the Bomb also, but it's give and take situation, not screw up, like Freeman, as we thought you might be one. In fact, a timely Bomb claim like Imp did in the last game could work quite well.
Secondly, there was an element of faith in claiming the Bomb role. That's usually the role of a.. sort of prankster, unless someone like me or Imp plays it, trying to imply a role and staying back so to make Mafia go for you at night. In this game, there was no one fitting that meta, perhaps with the exception of Faust. But the thing is Faust's highly suspected, so, if you were to clash with him for the Bomb claim, it's not that difficult to foresee who would come out on top, which would indeed be you at this point. With Gary hinting to have the Bulletproof role, he would probably not be able to risk and claim he was the Bomb instead, either, because in that case, he would immediately become under spotlight as a suspect.
Last but not least, in a scenario that we somehow shutdown Faust first and he doesn't come out as the Bomb, you would gain extra faith in yourself, since people would be inclined to think there is indeed a Bomb in the game, which is actually a fallacy. There is no sure pick for a role in a game. We lost SF because I believed we would have a regular Townie and unprecedentedly, we didn't have one. Still, this is pretty prone to be overlooked as a fact.
Therefore, for the reasons I stated here, you get my vote.
Vote Kill lawlett-kun