Note: Though it's only a theory and not like it'll definitely happen, please turn back a page if you don't want to regret reading spoiler!
The Coordinate (as of Chapter 47) by Bandreus (The discussion continues after Bandreus makes his point.)
Original Post (Speculations prior to Chapter 46):
Not sure if anyone's made a similar post here before, but in any case, random theory as follows, bash all you like lol. I've decided to update this post along the way to keep ideas nice and tidy. Last update time should be shown in the "Last edited" time tag below.
Based on the manga author's confession (link at the end of the post)
I totally stole the basics of the theory from some random Japanese thread, but my heart feels so heavy as I was typing this up lol, because it makes so much sense to the scene at the very beginning.
Another 'theory,' which counters the Time Loop theory, is the Dream 'Theory.' All that weirdness presented in the beginning of the first chapter is dispelled simply as a dream. (Not really a theory, but it sounds more epic that way.)
Very similar idea to the Time Loop but different (and more developed) speculations than the one above ^^
Time Skip (Atlantis-like civ from past):
Eren = 2000 years old (as of Chapter 49) by mirrorstorm
Titan from 2000 years ago (from Graydient's post):
To be developed.
Grisha: "...As for the way to use [the power], their memories should teach you..."
Assassin's Creed development (as of Chapter 49) by TheOwl
"The Big Rock that has been here (on this land) (since) before the town was built." @SnK Language Thread (+ posts after this)
Even wondered how the boulder got there in the first place? Or how the boulder was exactly the same size as the hole? Did you know the sub-heading for this section is actually engraved onto the sign next to that boulder? Why not make your brain implode with the help of the following post?
And finally, extra information (spoiler) from the author himself:
Big Fat Spoiler that's engraved onto the inside covers of the Manga by the author: (Thanks Georgie for the link!)
Big Fat Spoiler that the author confesses in a mini-interview (This is the main basis for my support of Time-related theories):
Last edited by Utsune; September 14, 2013 at 05:44 AM. Reason: Updated theory.
Very interesting. Yeah, there is something very fishy going on in that first scene.
I love all these theories. We should have just one theory thread to keep all the theories organized or something.
Anyways, as I said, very interesting. I have read theories similar to this, involving time skip.
In my opinion the setting is not earth as we know it, but an alternative universe similar to earth. If you notice they never mention countries. They are not in Germany, Mikasa is not Japanese but "oriental". They don't even call the planet that they live on "earth" but they say "humanity" idk...just something to think about.
Also, the title "To the You 2000 years from now" is so full of implications. As to what it could suggest, the basis for those arguments are too frail because there are so many possibilities.
I tend not to bring up the anime version since this is purely manga-based, but since they stick pretty much to the original, other than Mikasa's first two lines being replaced by some horrific flashback (which Eren calls a "dream,") I might as well mention it here.
Sometime I think that maybe they are humans who have settle on some planet in the future. They took over the pure titan's planet or something. The Titans retaliated and forced all the remaining humans to settle in those walls. But then....the walls are made of titan material. so idk..Again, I have no idea. lol. So many possibilities.
Also...a few things that bug me...
Sasha eats a potato:
Potatoes did not exist in europe until potatoes were discovered in the americans back in the 1500s and then brought to europe. So maby they are in the future...or an AU where potatoes exist.
Those gas tanks and weapons:
For such a civilization that looks like medieval Europe, they sure got pretty advance technology. So yeah, again future or au.
Last edited by Georgie; May 24, 2013 at 08:23 PM.
I like the time skip idea (they're in the future,) but I don't know too much about it so maybe you can shed some more light on it if you know more? :P
At the moment, I like it mainly because of one thing that bugs me a lot. When did they even build the walls, if they were made of Titan material? Surely they wouldn't have been able to build something like that after the Titans appeared 100 years ago seeing how desperate the situation should be. And for so many buildings to locate within the walls, this civilisation must have been here for a long time. Finally, surely the people are bound to know the truth when you're building the walls? If so, it must have been during a time when Titans are common knowledge.
I might have missed something, if so, feel free to correct me.
Last edited by Utsune; May 24, 2013 at 09:41 PM.
I like the time skip idea too.
I don't know anything. It's all speculation and I was just trowing ideas. Anything is possible at this point.
The wall thing bugs me too. Ok...someone had to build the wall, and it takes time to build a wall like that. So I wonder who built it? how long did it take? what were the other humans doing and where were they living while the walls were being built? Did someone with high political power decide to build these walls in the middle of wherever and just told everyone to move there? Who are Maria, Rose and Sina? blablabla.
Fascinating theories. I like them all.
Imo the "how they built the WALLS" topic must be the focused one. Probably the answer to this question will clear up a lot of things in the future about who the titans are, who built the walls and why, when all the story began and so on.
Rereading the first chapter imho that "See you later" was said by Mikasa before leaving Eren to his nap. BUT I know this would be too much "granted" even "stupid" for a shonen like this.
Maybe Eren had some sort of premonition about the incoming future, nothing happy but a lot sad, and that's why those tears.
About that "To you in 2000 years" reminds me about another manga, BLAME!, that began with the emblematic phrase "Maybe on Earth Maybe in the Future". Like the author would say "This is a vision of what could/will be the Earth in a far Future 2000 years since now".
That is not a theory lol. That's what the story naturally leads you to believe. You don't have to do much thinking to say "Eren must have been dreaming/ having a vision." It is common knowledge.Originally Posted by Utsune
I don't know where to put this, so I'll post it here since we were talking about the walls anyway.
So, have you guys seen this? Pretty interesting eh? This makes things a little clearer. The walls were already there when humans settled there. On ships. To a new world. That's why the religious people worship it so much and call it a gift from god.
Editing to say that I reread the earlier chapters and Armin has a book which talks about the world outside the walls and well....it's basically earth. oops at me. my bad.
Last edited by Georgie; May 28, 2013 at 07:25 PM.
This is SPOILEROUS as HELL!!! Well if the author put those info there probably he wanted the readers to find them nope?
And this explain a lot of things about the walls but the majority of questions about titans origins remain.
Now about this "New World" and his "Great (Holy) Walls": someone built them for the high caste of humanity, "the rich and powerful", than this implies that someone "knows" about the Titan threat and "made" this world before the things were worst.
Than Titans could be made by the humans themselves as a weapon or as a failed experiment that in a zombie-like way plague the earth driving the humanity to extinction.
And actually people live out of the walls and some of them (Reiner/Berthold/Annie faction) wanna take revenge on the offspring of the rich people who closed within the walls leaving the others die at the titans teeth.
Well thinking about the titan into the walls the same people that take refuge there must knewn a lot about titans... What if someone (a government leader/scientist/general etc) commits a BIG MISTAKE (and crime against humanity) creating the titans and than try to save himself and others rich (paying) people moving to a place defended by the same titans bodies built as a wall?
Maybe Maria, Rose and Sina were his daughters name or something similar.
A lot of stuff here, maybe too much! ^^
I also clicked on the link to the original post, and guess what? the language on the canned herring in chapter 38 is also upside-down Japanese! (it says "nishin," which means "herring.") Makes me wonder if there really were a race of Japanese out there before a huge gap in time with a lot of knowledge/technology gone loss. I would at least expect that 'Japanese' race is part of the Oriental group from which Mikasa also descended, and the language is designed based on the real Japanese Katakana.
I think that the reverse katakana is only a way for the author to conceal incipit into the series nothing related to Mikasa or some sort of japanese people who live before the titan century...
Never read Hunter x Hunter?
In that manga there's an alphabet made by the author using HIRAGANA (same syllabic alphabet of KATAKANA but with different writing and use), a simple cryptography that imo SnK author used as well.
Since Mikasa, who is of "Oriental decent" (as the manga puts it,) has a Japanese name that resembles that of our real world, I make a bold assumption by saying this Japanese-looking language is the native language of Mikasa's race. If not of Mikasa's race, then it has gotta be a language of something, since Ymir can read it too. As I say, I don't really relate SnK Universe to our real world, but I am lenient when it comes to designs and concepts inspired by our real world.
Just for the reference, I've flipped the panel in question, pull up the contrast, and highlighted the part of interest in the following picture:
which is basically ニシン (herring) in reverse (remember that I've flipped the picture upside-down!)
As an aside, I haven't read Hunter x Hunter, so I'm not too sure of the details. What is that alphabet about? Where does it come in it the plot? or is that just a language of their universe?