Yeah, I'm totally disappointed.
I was really sad when I read that story for the first time, and I was super happy when we discovered that she was actually still alive.
Although, had I known that she would be that useless to the plot, I think I'd have preferred that she stayed dead...
At least, when she was dead, she was important to the plot in a way... since she was part of the character build of Natsu...
Whats wrong with Jet and Droy? Without a few good for nothing recurring side characters it wouldn't feel right. The world isn't made up of only strong people.
The question Mashima has to answer is: Lisanna was out of the story. As the youngest of the Strauss siblings - what is special about her? Anything that goes beyond being a short-haired and younger Mirajane. Mashima has implied that she was an exeptional mage in X778 - is that all gone due to her being drawn to Edolas? And why was Mirajane not really amuzed by Lisanna being friendly towards Natsu?
I really hope he's going to show more on those questions I have about her character...
i am not saying she should be as major as lucy or erza to the story line, however i dont like the idea of all of the drama involved with bringing her back if shes just going to be a wall flower or cheerleader
i would at least like to see her become somewhat relevant, maybe get her up to somewhere near juvia's fighting ability
Lisanna feels like a character you get for your party if you install an optional DLC. Not much in the story changes with or without that character. Zaeed from Mass Effect 2, Javik from ME3, Shale from Dragon Age, to name a few.
And at the time of her death it seems shes stronger then Elfman as a mage. He was the only one who could not do a full takeover but she could.
As far as her plot. Mashima said in interviews before that its not his idea to bring her back it was his editors. And he regretted it. Indeed her role as dead was bigger then what she has now. Her death could strengthen both Mira and Elfman to live up to her memory. Now that shes back shes put on the shelf.
Also her spot is kinda 2 sided. She used to be a strong sidekick for Mirajane as shown before, now shes more all over the place scouting with the tribe and then back as a waitress (already got 2 of those). Team Strauss is rather non existant with Elfman going solo and Mira at the bar. As far as her interest role with Natsu, its all could have been, but Lucy took her place. Something that could be played out but usually that ends up with the character dieing. And having a character die twice? Thats a bit too much.
Bright side? Well depending on plot development, as in the ascension you see in stories, that is the main character goes to *heaven* or whatever place then she could have a on-viewer role. But it depends on if its Natsu or Lucy.
If Lucy were to ascend and leave everyone behind perhaps the old promise could be kept (first child named Lucy) kinda thing. But thats a longshot. And even if this happens it would most likely leave many readers unsatisfied. People rather see the male character depart.
If Natsu the problem gets bigger (for Lisanna). The main focus would be on Lucy, Erza and Gray how they feel about him leaving. She would be sideshow, even tho the promise to marry still stands. It would definitely be awkward.
I believe Mashima wants to backseat Lisanna as much as possible and basically all contact between Lisanna and Natsu is non existant. Which is awkward because truth be told Natsu felt for her, if its love? I think it actually was. I mean he wanted to go with her on mission before she died. And they did spend lots of time as kids. She still seems to feel for him but maybe less.
The reason to backseat her is to avoid it and possibly try and forget it all together. Let it be childhood stuff. But then again 3 years ago is not that long. She embraced him when she got back. Its just that Lucy is the main together with Natsu so for her there is no place other then doing some sidework for the guild.
everyone should know that it was worth 100% alone for the fact we no longer have to see mirajane and elfman crying next to cemetarys and trying to not bring up lisanna around them.
As for Lisanna shes not a shorthaired version of Mira. Actually Mira changed her image/attitude when she died. Thats most of it really. Lisanna was more levelheaded then Mira was back then and she was stronger then Elfman (she could do full take over he could not)
Im still unsure about her. She should have some kickass takeover but only has those useless pets that she had when she was a kid. It doesnt look right.