Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (2/23/15 - 3/1/15).
! Visit the new forums for Tokyo Ghoul and The Gamer!
Forum News: Vote in the final phase of the Anime Awards 2014
Firstly, are you asking for Fact or Opinion. Well if you put "greatest" you can't really ask a person because people would surely vote differently.
Except if you Ask ,Most Sale or most watched. we Could surely find the answer.
but most Importantly...
ONE PIECE WINS!!!
You should narrow down the category. All of them are shounen. I love many shounen and feel sick of lots of shoujo series, however, Kaze Hikaru forever shines in my heart (*-*).
Plus, the list is not finished with full of best manga titles, even in terms of shounen so I'm not gonna vote!
i for one would enjoy hot gimmick being up there, it's easily one of the best about
Because of complains about the limited poll, we removed it. I have to agree that it was heavy biased in terms of shounen manga ^^
So, feel free to just state what's the best manga for you without the need to choose from a selected few.
what is the greatest of all time
sorry i wanted to include a poll.
Eh? Sorry, but we said 'no'. Please respect that and refrain from duplicating the topic.
*threads merged* ~eni
Last edited by eni; May 28, 2009 at 06:55 PM.
Where is the "other" option?
"Other" option added to the poll.
For me it's Nausicaa, one of the first mangas I ever read. But I'd rather vote for Angel no Densetsu or Claymore if they were listed.
Ok there's 3 on this list I haven't read, and 1 I havent finished. I haven't read, Monster (though I started it I think I stopped early and moved on to 20CB), Yokohama, or Nausicaa. Though I've heard of all of them and know the general plotline, besides Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou.
I haven't finished 20CB. I stopped years back, though it was well past the time skip the guys scanlating it ran into a hitch for a while and I lost track.
But I love all the manga on this list that I have read, and the main one I'd want to add is Gantz. If this were favorite anime I'd be real tempted to put Kenshin. Even though they didn't do the Jinchuu arc justice. But in manga I gotta go Dragonball. Due to hype surrounding it alot of people downplay it, but I started with it before it really got big in the US so that doenst bother me so much. I can't fade it, while its still very generic in terms of shonen, I really like shonen and its the template for 90% of shonen out now, but there's still something very special about it.
Its funny how the Rave/FT Mangaka is a student of the OP mangaka is a student of the Kenshin Mangaka, and yet when asked what if any manga they'd recommend to someone who could only read one, both Oda and Mashima say Dragonball.
You know I see a lot of threads like this and since I've been wanting to do this for a while I just want to ask people about this little idea I've had for a while. Namely a thread to decide what manga is the most popular/ the favorite of Mangahelpers.
And yes this is totally thread jacking.
My idea's pretty simple I think. Basicly people would post their top 10(or 5) favorite Mangas. Then these top 10 mangas would be scored appropiately.
First favorite would 10 points. Second favorite would be 9. Third would be 8. And then it would continue to their 10th favorite which would be scored only as one point.
As a random example:
1. One Piece: 10 pts
2. Shin Angyo Onshi: 9 pts
3. JJBA: 8 pts
4. Kochikame : 7 pts
5. To-Love Ru: 6 pts
Then after everyone posted their top 10 mangas which would be say a week or two and then it would get locked by a mod. That would give me time to calculate the scores. I'd add up the scores and the higher the score the higher the placement. We could probablly name the top 30 best mangas for MH this way.
People could of course PM me if they wanted to change their posts that way I wouldn't mess up on the numbers.
Well? What do people think?
Last edited by Onomatopoeia; May 10, 2009 at 10:12 PM.
^Sounds cool to me.
One Piece- 8
Slam Dunk- 6
Hajime no Ippo- 4
Yu Yu Hakusho- 3
Fullmetal Alchemist- 2
Hikaru no Go- 1
wow this is tough..HxH didn't make my list!? I didnt have room for 20CB, devilman, devil & devil, I''s, etc. either ahh well
Last edited by BigCamaro; May 13, 2009 at 07:46 PM.
Space Adventure Cobra hands down.