I just prefer Naruto out of taste. One Piece is great though. But I don't agree that it doesn't have super power spamming, it does have moments of PNJ/PIS as well, or extreme faggoting by some characters. But what makes it a nice manga is its story. Though I don't like the art, sometimes it looks too childish for my liking, and sometimes Oda draws some transvestite with a big ass face, which IMO is crap.
It terms of art I choose Naruto, Kishi is better IMO when he can draw stuff like this;
Last edited by ◆ T.D.A ◆; January 02, 2010 at 06:25 PM. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
the sharingans in naruto fails so badly .
I mean, how much more do the author
have to focus on the damn eyes?
There's 3 kind so far or maybe 4 idk.
Magneko sharingan(whateevr u call it)
and the one with the moon.
Too much is baaaad.
really baaaad, and naruto don't have a sharingan :O
Heh, To me it'd be One Piece > Naruto > Bleach
Naruto was always my favourite but that was until I found out about One Piece it just has everything I could ask for fights comedy and a damn epic story.. Naruto has its moments also but only a few times I get to have chills and be like OMG that did not just happen Naruto its story is also good but damn its way more confusing and plot holed than our ozone layer >.<.. Bleach well its not really that well thought out, its seems like all its story is envolved in one villian basicly where as massive overpowers out of nowhere, so weak at one moment decides to show off another one heh dunno I do like some of the chapters tho..
I don't want to comment on Naruto or Bleach since they don't really catch my interest lately (or after certain you-know-what arcs). I just skimmed through the chapter each week. Though I admit they were once on epic level.
Voted for OP since it is my all-time favourite manga. There's so many points that make this manga interesting and ranked above others, which I won't bother to list them. But instead, I'll give one thing that I don't like. Well, not that I don't like it, but it may or may not lead me to disappointment.
It is the main character, that made out of rubber. Seriously, rubber? Okay, I admit. It's interesting. It's interesting to see Luffy's development in time. The attacks got better and better against stronger foes. And now it comes to the point in the story where he'll face really strong guys, which the readers know that there's no way in hell rubber can win against eg. light or ice, or probably even scissors (lol). And here comes a huge countermeasure:
This attack (of some sort) can work on a certain level or at a certain part which can still be accepted, but cannot be used as a solution to everything as per discussed in the forum . I hope Oda will pull something off and not use it each time Luffy is facing tough foes. But if, and BIG if, he does and it proves to be the answer to everything, seriously, I'm gonna be disappointed. Not that much to strap OP off of my top all-time fav manga, but enough to make sigh and complain.
One piece is DA BEST!!.Enuff said.
Just wish Kisihi and Kubo improved his plot and character wise...instead of their art..Then again kubo art is getting too simplified that it's getting ridiculous imo.Sometimes i simply can't or difficult to figured out a picture in one of his panels..I know what he's trying to achieve with his minimalistic approach of his artwork.He's trying to potray "spiritualism" and zen like qualitiies to his manga which i think he fails...big time..lol.(and i'm an art student btw).
As for naruto i will admit his artwork is better than oda but plotwise is not much to be desired.As for Oda his art is getting better and better along with his plot lines.Oda is getting there.
Then again i appreciate and glad what all the mangakas did for their manga.You know how hard it is to produce a manga..so appreciate more, criticize less..
One piece best because never boring good plot
naruto is fair it used to be good except for the stupid sasuke thing the should just kill him .good art
bleach is ok except for the prolonged fights .
That's my opinion:
Naruto Part I>One Piece>>>>>Bleach
One Piece>>>Naruto Part II>>Bleach
fights : naruto > one piece > bleach
story : one piece <> naruto > bleach
character art : bleach > naruto > one piece
background art : naruto > one piece >>>> bleach
overall : naruto > one piece > bleach
villains : naruto > one piece > bleach
IMO the villains in naruto are much more interesting they seem more human and while their actions are evil the cause and effect relationship that kishi develops is awesome i know that most people are annoyed with the fact that no one is truly evil in naruto but this is what makes it appealing to me
madara is probably one of the very few villains that i have seen that has been shown to be insanely powerful and yet at the same time in such a pitiful condition
i feel in the villains in one piece and more stereotypical and beyond the fact that they ultimately are there to be defeated by the good guys they dont seem to have much of a purpose
edit :lack of plot holes and stuff : one piece >> naruto >>>>>>>>> bleach
one piece is better planned than either naruto and bleach but i dont know whether this is because of the mangakas or because the editors interfere and force the mangakas to edit their stories. like kishi did not want to write too much about team taka but had to because of the higherups
uniqueness : one piece > naruto > bleach
usage of the world in which the story is set : one piece > naruto > bleach
one piece uses the world in which it is set better than the other two. the strawhat crew get to explore many uniquely designed place on their adventures which is pretty awesome but sometimes it works against it. for example i absolutely hated the moria arc i found it too long and boring
since naruto focuses on konoha the other countries and neglected but that i bound too happen since only so much information can be squeezed in 17-18 pages per week
Last edited by ameya730; January 07, 2010 at 06:47 AM.
plotholes - Naruto >>>>> one piece
Last edited by msg; January 07, 2010 at 06:27 AM.
I voted OP cause it has the better story, it has always flows very well with very little inconsistency. I like how the menial things that are said or done have become much larger parts of the story, an example being Cammie as a frontpage story getting put into the main story. Also the way Oda changes a really serious topic to humour is great! I love the drawing style too!
Bleach is on the last position because it lacks pace, story and plot. The fights and the art are very good but the rest is just average or below average.
One Piece and Naruto are on the same level in my opinion. The OP story and plot is better then Narutos story and plot but I just love the artwork of Naruto. Another point to mention is that I think that the Naruto fights are better then OP fights.