i seriously doubt gildartz is in any way weaker than makarov
sure he lost two limbs but at least he wont have a heart attack in the middle of a fight
as for magic we havent seen much from makarov except from titan magic and fairy law and jose was able to injure him
the way mashima hypes gildartz jose wouldnt be able to even touch him
fairy law sure is powerful but if it was as hax as many think luxus would be stronger than gildartz (his fairy law was perfect in every way except from choosing targets) and thats clearly not the case
on another note id like to see gildarts with 4 limbs vs makarov in his prime
lol if that happends it might destroy the whole fiore country
There always will be discussions about who is stronger, and this is more about how the fans perceive the strength of the characters. So rate who do you think is the guild top 5 or top 10! And of course you can discutss why someone or think, and give arguments...
You can include former members, like Luxus or Mistgun, if you feel like it.
My top 10 would be:
1 - Makarov
2 - Gildarts
3 - Luxus
4 - Mistgun
5 - Erza
7 - Natsu (This one is hard to rate, but i considered he didn't eat etherion or Flame of Rebuke. Just his own power)
8 - Gray
9 - Fried
10 - Gajeel
Last edited by ErosVp; August 02, 2011 at 02:25 PM.
1 - Gildarts
2 - Makarov
3 - Erza
4 - Mirajane
5 - Fried
6 - Natsu
7 - Gajeel
8 - Gray
9 - Bixlow
10 - Juvia
Laxus & Mistgun are no longer members of the guild.
Well... I said if you wanted to include former member you could...
I think Gray surpassed Fried and Gajeel by beating Urtear. It wasn't a complete victory, but Gajeel had problems with a underling of the GH and Fried needed Bixlow to beat only one of the 7 kin...
4- Mystogan (his sleep magic worked on Erza but not on Laxus )
Last edited by Ifrit; August 05, 2011 at 05:07 AM.
I could swear i looked for a thread like this before crating that thread myself!! I didn't searched carefully enough, sorry for giving you unnecessary work moderator...
Edit: I still think Gray showed more power than Gajeel this arc...
Last edited by ErosVp; August 05, 2011 at 10:53 AM.
i would say if lucy was more serious about getting stronger she would be maybe under erza
(since other celestial wizards can summon up to 2-3 spirits and she can only summon 1)
:]]] i think im just biased lol
Can I just say that in my opinion, Fried - given maybe half an hour to set up - is unbeatable. His runes he writes can be outsped, he can be outpowered using just runes, but His Barrier/rune combo in unbeatable. For instance, against Mira if he'd set up a 'No magic' rune and attacked her using his sword, I have no doubt she'd lose. Or against Gildarts he set up a 'if you use magic offensively you die' rune, and fly around. Evergreen and Levi vs him would be outsped by his runes. Fried is potentially the strongest FT character, given time to set up.
Including the former member? Hmm, in that case. Three of the spot would have already been taken, for sure.
IMO gazille is still stronger than grey even if only marginally so (as is natsu). Its not like the guys that gazille fought were outright weak, not being in the seven kin or not using lost magic does not imply inherent weakness. More so, there were two of them and gazille took them on...
Gazille won after he ate Steel, Gray don't have that option and was always a rival of Natsu being a little behind..... And Gazille beat two guys, but later was out of work! Of course we have to consider sometimes characters look more strong because of their role in the arc plot, but i just think Gray is a bit stronger than Gazille even if he is a DS..
Without plot-no-jutsu or Makarov: