Alright, please read this description everyone, because this match has certain restrictions.
- The fight takes place over 100 years ago, during the time when both Kisuke and Shinji were captains.
- They fight in the forests of Rukongai.
- To make things evened out a bit, Shinji obviously will not have any form of hollow powers, and Kisuke will not have access to any of his inventions. They start the fight sealed, and can only go as far as using their shikai.
- Kidou will also be disregarded here since we have no idea which one of them would excel more in that field.
- Neither one of them has any knowledge of the other's zanpakutou abilities.
I think this will be a pretty damn even fight. Both of them seemed to have top notch sword skills and top notch reflexes.
Last edited by El Samurai Guapo; April 30, 2010 at 02:57 PM.
I think that Urahara has the better chances here: he should be able to create a barrier that protects him from all directions, and then proceed to attack.
Also, being a Genius and not having LOT of fighting experience, he should be able to more or less adapt to Sakanade, and then use his Benihime's attacks to defeat Shinji.
60/40 for Urahara IMO.
Kisuke had been training with Yoruichi since he was a kid too.
I'd lean towards shinji based on what we know. He was an older captain and his shikai can certainly help him get a good his on urahara. Urahara's shikai is versatile in that it has both offensive and defensive capacities but overall I would think none of them would be that helpful if he simply does not place them where he should.
I would also lean towards shinji in this case. He's a more senior captain (he was a captain of reasonably long time (him and Kensei being the non-novice captains from the vizards)) and Urahara was still a third seat in second squad IIRC. Also, less inventions (not sure if he invented the bankai doll before or after he became captain...).
shinji release would work but urahara prob figure out the key to beating it he is smart and his benihime is one powerfull zan blood mist shield and his version of GT....i also belive urahara be fast practising with yoruchi look at the part where yammi tried point blank cero yoruchi he appeared and blocked it damn fast.
I also think Shinji would have a slight advantage here because of him possessing the second most hax shikai. Kisuke would still be a challenging opponent because his blood mist shield and the fact that he really is a genius (unlike a overrated that character that Shinji was matched up against in a similar thread) so he may be able to at least block some attacks from Shinji. But if Shinji keeps the pressure up, Kisuke would have to stay on the defensive, and eventually he's bound to make a wrong move and get slashed.
Alright, not disagreeing that Shinji will win since I personally think he will in this case.
But his shikai is: not that hax.
It's like a nerfed version of Tousen's bankai, and guess what, Tousen's bankai was defeated by Kenpachi with relative ease (still had eyepatch on and didn't use kendo). I can just imagine what Kenpachi could do to Shinji's shikai.
Seriously, Tousen's bankai takes away all vision and hearing (maybe smell too, bottom line, people can't find out where Tousen is while in bankai).
Shinji's shikai reverses just one sense.
At least with reversed vision one could have a chance at defending themselves, with no vision at all, no chance, and yet, Kenpachi managed to pull off a W.
So I ask you, is Shinji's shikai really that "hax"?
Ah, don't know why I thought this thread was about kyoraku vs shinji lol.... Nevermind that now anyways...
Actually, what exactly is the depth of shinji's shikai? I was under the impression that your very movements were actually also reversed -as if you tried to move your left hand you right would- but after reading about it, it is not necessarily the case. If shinji's shikai truly is limited to only an optical illusion then other characters would still have a good deal of trouble but reacting would be a step simpler than what I thought. Still, closing your eyes is not that much different from having such an optical illusion on you, I'd go as far as to argue it is worst considering you won't even know when an attack is coming -unless you are kempachi-.
Now, back to the fight. Shinji's shikai will definitely be a problem for good old urahara. It does not provide any form of boost in terms of speed, offense or defense but at least for a while it will utterly get rid off all of those aspects of urahara's fighting. A main issue about this technique is what happened here. The extent to what things are reversed are also controlled by shinji. In that sense, things won't be upside down and left will be reversed with right and front with back every time. By not reversing up and down shinji can still use his ability to have sneak attacks on urahara. Also, seeing what urahara can do with his shikai, I have my doubts about how much would it work if he tries to use it to defend from urahara. If it covered a wide enough area, urahara could use it to defend himself from shinji but it does not seem like the type to cover 360 areas fast enough.
Shinji simply has a tactical advantage, his zampakuto can utterly mess up the enemy's offense and defense along with being great for sneak attacks.
Last edited by Kaiten; May 03, 2010 at 09:21 PM.
If Shinji can control every level of inversion and switch them at will like you say then he wins period. That would make his ability ridiculously more hax than I thought. I'd have a hard time believing he's fail to defeat anyone besides Aizen or Yamamoto with that kind of ability, but who knows Sakanade really works that way.
Kisuke knows some stuff, but he had just began captain duties, Shinji on the other hand had been captain at least for 6+ years prior. Shinji is a smart guy too, not just Kisuke. He knew Aizen was up to something even though he was under an illusion. Sakanade is just one ability of a captain. I'm sure he has knowledge of Kido as well. And a Bankai. I think it'd be close, but my guess is Shinji with a slight edge over new captain Kisuke.
- I actually thought of a method to deal with Sakanade. Hit and Run. The biggest problem with dealing with Shinji's shikai is melee combat. With Urahara's genius and his skills as the former 3rd seat of the assassins division, I think he might be able to pull it off with difficulty.
IMO Shinji would still be to difficult to beat though especially with his mask.
Edit: The gigai trick kidou combo might work, if they could use kidou in this battle.
Last edited by En Yang Ji; September 27, 2010 at 07:39 PM.