Singles Tier List
Only characters that had at least one match (or currently have one) are to be ranked. For Doubles, only players that played together before may be ranked.
Concerning the Tier Lists for Prefecturals, Tokyo, Kanto and Nationals, the above criteria apply to the given time frame.
Last edited by Kaoz; June 18, 2014 at 02:20 AM.
Atobe and Ryoma did shit on Viking Horn. Took it as pretty trivial moves.
In terms of technique it depends how you rank Regionals!Fuji against Ryoma and Atobe and the ease in which they hit back Viking Horn.
Since they did it instantly whilst Kikumaru struggled.
Also, with Marui in the way, Ohabu becomes a G10 level Doubles move.
Do you honestly see Viking Horn being just as effective in the same situation?
You're telling me he closed his eyes for the fun of it too then?
---------- Post added at 09:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:55 PM ----------
Yeah cause we know his exact stats... it's aight then, I dunno.
So basically, Kaoz and I were tier discussing and reached a conclusion a tier of the top half of the U-17 Camp at the best we could based on what we've seen and factoring in the lack of individual tennis.
Important things to note, tiers are entirely in groups, and within each group is done in alphabetical order. The names don't mean that because one name is directly above the one below it that the given person is stronger than the other.
This tier is done to group players at each given level.
This is our conclusion on the what level all of the given players are i.e S tier, A tier and so on
Added in + and - tiers to show that there's a bit of a gap, but that it's not as big as a normal tier gap would be. As for who has a shot at beating who if they're not in the same tier, I'd say anyone in a - tier could beat someone from the non - tier, and the guys in a non - tier could beat someone from the - tier above (e.g. if you're in B- you can beat the guys in B, if you're in D you can beat the guys in C-).
I find it funny that Ryoma is somehow drop a tier "assuming that he doesn't have TnK" when he shows it in the manga and Sanada is somehow up a tier assuming that he have 10 ball when he doesn't show it at all in the manga.
I would just drop #11-14 all down to B tier. That, or just move Ban Rikya up to A tier. Moving 11-14 down make more sense in my head, due to the manga stating that G10 is a whole new level.
I'll probably bump Momoshiro up to C tier. Like, come on, he's confirm to beat Taira and Hara, which are both C tier, pretty much solo, with the possible team bonus that they have. That gotta means something.
Chitose doesn't scream C tier to me either, looking at other character in that tier. I thought Yamato would have shut him 6-1 considering the he tied with Tezuka. I'll probably bump Yamato up to C tier and move Chitose down to C- tier.
Last edited by -Ken-; June 09, 2013 at 08:59 PM.
Why are the Mutsus so high? All we know is that they had better stats than Washio and Suzuki (Tachibana and Chitose had better stats too), I don't think we should tier the bros. Uhm, I thought that some time ago we said that Nakagauchi was around Kirihara and Kaidoh's lvl... and shouldn't Tachibana and Chitose be equal in their tier?
Also,is it possible to have a tier discussion of each group later? Why aren't Gin and Taka tiered?
On Mutsu, we know that they at least have better stat than Yamato, who is NOT 1st stringer. I can see them above WoK based on what we know so far. I'll put WoK at 1st court level at best for now.
I don't want WoK to go up, I just want the Mutsus to go down lol. They might be 1st string lvl as doubles players, but we're talking about singles. Yamato is a scrub when it comes to stats, everyone said it, so that isn't a big feat .
I just don't see any proof why they might be weak. #2 and #6 pair AND the whole G10 line up should serve more than enough as proof that there is no real # related to line-up (Singles 1 Doubles 1 Singles 2 so forth). It's certainly shows more than pure speculation that people just have just because they want to believe it so.
I'm not really interested in discussing that list myself, simply because for everything you brought up, there's no real way to support either side more than the other. I don't want it in the OP either for that reason. Of course you're free to talk about it though.
To answer your question though, Ken, Ochi and Mouri aren't on the same level as the G10 in my opinion and only got bumped up to those spots because Tokugawa and Irie decided to stay behind/not accept the badge. So they're the actual 12/13 and hence in the lower group. As for Echizen and Sanada, just bump them up and down respectively if you see the situation differently, that's why they're labeled like that.
Yamato can't though... He did far better against Nationals!Tezuka than Kite and Chitose did.
In fact, the Tezuka that beat Yamato 6-4, was an even better Tezuka than the one who took 6 straight games and DESTROYED Chitose and Kite.
So Yamato is being really underrated here I think.
In Singles in this Top realm of the tier, all characters here can hit shots at the corners like how Nakagauchi did to Krauser.
Its not like Gin and Kawamura have ever shown good Speed or agility if you get what I mean haha.
Tachibana can't do a thing against SKnK. Sure he wasn't aiming for Chitose's blind spots, but the fact that Chitose was able to predict at that given moment that Tachibana was aiming for that area on purpose just shows how amazing his prediction was and the advantage he had over Tachibana once SKnK was brought out.
Konomi also had Ryoma miss Kintaro's match, meaning he didn't get to see TnK to make him remember he had TnK, that's what I get from it personally.
Also, @Ken, Ban was like a helpless fish against 108th Hadoukyuu. We were told Super Megaton Deluxe-- -- is better than 108th Hadoukyuu at Nationals.
Therefore Nationals!Tooyama > Ban.
Whereas Hakamada literally wiped the floor with Nationals!Tooyama. So Ban isn't on the same level as the No.14 despite him having a higher number, because Ban is in a Doubles position whilst Hakamada was in one of the highest Singles positions in U-17 Japan.
Last edited by Airgrimes; June 10, 2013 at 09:29 AM.