What manga do you think has the least satisfying ending and why? Lists and multiple entries are welcome as long as a reason or description of why you find the ending so lame.
First series that comes to mind is Becchin to Mandara a one volume series by the mangaka of Freesia. Everything was set for an interesting ending but there was no resolution to the story at all. The characters were not given any motivation for acting the way they did, no reason for living where they lived, and no reason to continue doing so after the manga ended. A big, black mark against an otherwise intelligent, interesting manga.
Moderator message by: AsariiWarning: Remember to be careful of spoilers throughout this thread!
Last edited by Asarii; February 22, 2011 at 12:16 AM. Reason: spoiler warning ;)
Hm... thinking... thinking...
I haven't found a single really disappointing ending so far. Even though for at least two manga people complained all over the web for their endings:
-> Planetes. Very open ending, many say it ends without concluding a single thing. I think that it isn't a problem though. Planetes dealt with a variety of topics very well and never depended on the storyline as itself. The ending was totally fine imo, there was nothing wrong with ending at that specific point. It did conclude a lot of things for the moment, while leaving many possible future scenarios.
-> Shigurui. Many people complain that it was too short, unsatisfying, not plausible. I think that it indeed is rather short, but not too short. It shows what has to be shown and is consistent/plausible, even though it takes some thinking and might not offer "the" one and only explanation. Let's just say that it ends very suitable for a drama story like Shigurui!
I do see a potentially bad ending for Nononono though. It's ended in Japan a while ago already, many people complained. At the current state of scanlations (~95) I already think the story is kinda deteriorating and too far away from what made it good, way overstressing the staging and arts style put into the manga and in general delivering a weird atmosphere.
Last edited by Roflkopt3r; February 21, 2011 at 01:26 PM.
Is it a bad ending if I want it to last longer?
But seriously I believe it was a Jump manga called Ane Doki, the art really captured my eye. It was a really rare series with a plot that had ecchi stuff in it a lot, but somehow I really overlooked that. It just felt that when the end came that was not it. The series did not have a bad ending, but before it came to a conclusion it should have explained more. And that is a worst ending for me, when a manga can go for even more chapters and yet it ended.
Of course this might have been because of the Jump axing policy towards low - ranked series. But I forgot if Ane Doki was doing good in the ToC when it was serialized.
YuYu Hakusho was another for the same things as Ane Doki, pre mature ending I don't know it felt rushed. And for me rushed=ruined, it is often the case though today with the Jump series. But this was a series that was done a long time ago. The story could have gone a long way. The plot could have gone many ways, sure I do not mind the ending but at least it should have gone for a few more arcs.
666 Satan and Eyeshield 21. The former's ending felt so rushed, as if Kishimoto was dying to work on his new series Blazer Drive, whilst the latter should have ended right after the Christmas Bowl, instead of dragging out for a couple more chapters. The world tournament actually had potential, plus I wanted to see Panther again, but it was so rushed. So yeah, Eyeshield 21 managed to have a rushed and prolonged ending at the same time.
Certainly Full Metal Alchemist. It has a lot of plot-holes in the main concept of equality. More over, it was like made only to the children readers.
Other ending mangas are really worse, but i have to given some credit for other reasons that Arakawa doesn't has.
Perhaps, the worst mangaka giving an end to his mangas is Naoki Urasawa. His popular works were good but just PLUTO was the only with a decent ending.
New character introduced, and then suddenly it ended? Totally abrupt and just... Bad. The manga itself was pretty good and it really sucks that it had to end that way because it wasn't doing well on the TOCs. A really unsatisfying ending.
Shaman King, has the worst ending of any manga I have read.
Shaman King's ending was so bad it was legendary. At least Takei got a do over when the kanzenban came out.
In my opinion, even with the many unsatisfactory endings I've read, Hikaru no Go's displeased me the most. It builds up to a point where your expect the story to go on and show Hikaru's rise in the go world then just stops abruptly. Other series like Eyeshield 21 and YuYu Hakusho at least showed signs of ending (Eyeshield had already finished the main plot while YuYu had been deteriorating for quite some time). Hikaru no Go, on the other hand, seemed to continually hint at lasting much longer, and it was really popular so I'm still not sure why it ended
I'd stick Shaman King with it, but at least it got a proper ending eventually.
Is it a bad sign for Bakuman that Hikaru no Go and Death Note had less than satisfactory endings. Sorry Sally
Although it wasn't the worst ending I've read, I'd rather have Hikaru no Go end before the Hokuto Cup. That "Part 2" seemed out of place so it would have been better as a side-story.