Avatar: 5, there is something about the quality of the image that doesn't look quite right.
Signature: 8, I love the picture, the sea.
Avatar : 9, I like what I see, even if I'm not sure that I see what was drawn. Among other things, a duck.
Last edited by Teubier; January 06, 2012 at 03:01 PM.
best set one can have teube
Sig - 7/10 - Its pretty damn awesome, but the lack of anything else going on and the awkwardness of the arm bring it down to a 7
avvy = 9/10 - Dark and Awesome!!
You made th effort to colorize it, but didn't care to edit out the text, laaaaaaaazy. Also it would have been nicer if it had the same angle as the original.
Ava wasn't sharped up after the change of size. Don't like same pic sets, the first picture with them quarreling was nice too.
edit: I was being nice[+1 despite easy editable disturbing factor]. haha One should never stop trying to strive for continuous improvement of ones skills. I'm sure you could have done it yourself[the editing], don't take comment to harshly, that's what this thread is about.
It's just one of the funny scenes from the manga, especially more for those aware of the characters personalitiy. Though a plot for that scene is not that hard to come by with in my opinion. Not every pic needs a border and it stands out even with bland colors? Good, goal achieved!
Last edited by Schabrak; January 30, 2012 at 05:22 PM.
ok since we are being so harsh~~~
Sig - 6/10 - no idea whats going on or even the theme or idea behind it...
avat - 4/10 bland colors and borderlessness stands out too much~
Haha,no need to be a bitch about it.He was just being honest and as an artist you should gladly accept his comment.
Anyhow,moving on to the actual rating.
Sig: 5/10 - Frankly speaking,the coloring is meh.I do understand the intention of making it look like a photography,but the execution isn't all that good.As Schabrack already mentioned,you didn't even bother erasing the text,which disturbs the mood.Furthermore,the thumb almost looks like part of the picture.You could give it a nice touch by simply making the thumb cover the black border.
Ava: 3/10 - Same thing in small and I presonally dislike using the same pic twice in a set.
Sig 8\10 - It made me chuckle
Avatar 6/10 - I like the symbol/drawing but the colours are a little too flashy. Also the picture quality could be better, it's a little blurry.
Signature 8/10 - Pikachu!! I don't get your sig but I like the symbols/drawings, especially the Baphomet one!
'Fine' by MAL standards and nonexistent by common human standards
Avatar: 5/10 - Too small, blurry
Signature: 3/10 - Unoriginal and a bit messy
Too harsh...this thread must hurt people's feelings
Ava: 7/10 - just the right size for the helmet
Sig: X/10 - how unorginal, have seen it so often here already :P, clean and practical
7/10 SIG (Mortal Combat? )