Manga News: Check out this week's new manga (2/16/15 - 2/22/15).
! Visit the new forums for Tokyo Ghoul and The Gamer!
Forum News: Vote in the final phase of the Anime Awards 2014
Staff, city of the far east (prior to 100 years ago, prior to the Org's arrival) becomes the Org HQs (after 100 years ago, after the Org's arrival)
Manga: Sutare = eastern land
Anime: Sutafu = eastern land
you actually (based on the prior translations anyways, lol) didn't make a mistake:
Staff is the Org HQs, which is indeed in its (the Org's) "Life and Death struggle" (as well as the attackers-the Rebelling Claymores against the Org, lol).
the eastern land which Staff/Org HQs is in, is called Sutare in the manga and Sutafu in the anime.
so you got it right, though using Staff is a bit ugly... it doesn't really belong... as Staff is now the Org HQs anyways, and few people know that the Org HQs was once the city Staff, city of the far east.
so, I'd personally change Staff to like Org HQs or Organization's fate or Island's fate, lol, as it would make more sense, not be as "ugly"/out of place.
Last edited by HegemonKhan; September 02, 2011 at 06:24 PM.
Well this was rather an intresting chapter. I didn't expect Raftela at all. My first reaction was why didn't the Organization finished off Raftela like many of you guys thought, surely the Organization knows the sure way to kill a Claymore was to lop off her head. After some thinking, I concluded two likely reason the Organization didn't cut her head off.
The first one was that they just wanted punish Raftela for her failure instead of killing her. She failed in her duty for sure but she didn't openly raise her arm against the Organization. That shows that she still had some loyalty to the Organization up till that point. I also think physical punishment of a Claymore that failed in her duty but could still prove to be useful later on was something that the Organization has done before. I think I remember Rubel talking to Rafaela saying "You look like they mopped the floor with you", refering to the Organization as "they" as she lays in the infirmary covered in bandages for failing to control Luciela.
My second theory is, they wanted her to suffer more before she dies. Cutting her head off so quickly would only spare her of her suffering.
I think Roxanne isn't the blood thursty type like the other two revived #1s. I think she's very smart and very calculating and only kills if she has something to gain from it. I mean she didn't shoot streight up to top ranks by having raw abilities say.... like Priscilla or Miata. She done it through a lot of plotting, deceiving, and grinding through the system from a pretty low rank. That took a lot of brain power IMO. She may also have some sort of superiority complex, and doesn't kill people that she views as a none threat, she would just disable them instead. Most of the time she would be all smiles and cherry untill she actually feel like she needs to kill somone. Also she's the only one out of the three that have her memories, so she must be aware of the current situation and is leaving her options open and want to sit on the fence a bit longer. Perhaps the Organization screwed her over that resulted in her own death the first itme, so why fight for them this time around? Third, she knows something everyone don't know (us included) and may be saving her energy for what's to come. So there is no point in killing somone that she think she may need later on.
Last edited by Khorr; September 02, 2011 at 09:16 PM.
if I were to try to defend the Organization or Yagi, I'd say... the BCs (Rimuto) thought the BC spearmen had delivered fatal damage to Raftela, she's dying and would be dead soon, and that does seem to possibly be the case, as the manga does kinda hint that she's just barely hanging on... similar to dying Jean as she uses the last breath and power of her dying life (due to Rigardo's fatal claw through her stomach and probably her "vital Yoma organs") to Yoki Sync and de-Awaken Partially Awakened Clare (if I may remind everyone, hehe), so why couldn't they (the BCs) just leave Raftela to die from her fatal wounds as was seen... they'd not know that she might possibly be saved by maybe these Trainees... if the Trainees do have "Supportive Healing/Regeneration" and not are just holding-helping her stay up and comforting her as she is dying and trying to keep Audrey alive... (what about Nina... though??) that is...
the question is:
is Raftela fatally damaged (like Jean was) or not, did the BC spearmen stab Raftela's "Yoma vital organs", which possibly can't be Regenerated or maybe it can be, or not?
if Raftela is not fatally damaged, then we should question the Organization's or Yagi's "sloppiness".
Last edited by HegemonKhan; September 02, 2011 at 07:55 PM.
I'm actually a little confused why there's such a ruckus about Raftela being alive. The organization didn't mistake her for dead like they did with Miria. They knew she was alive, and imprisoned her, and Raki and the trainees freed her. This is clear because Raki says "How did these guys manage to catch / capture a warrior?", referring to the fact that Raftela had been captured / locked up (or maybe in transit to a cell, guarded by MiB?) In either case, it's clear that Raki freed her.
Surely the org wouldn't have particularly cared if she had died, but since she hadn't and she wasn't a threat, they decided to lock her up instead. Why is that such a surprise?
Bottom line is: Whatever her reasons, she didn't kill the twins, which may mean that she may also have spared other warriors on purpose during the initial attack.
I've already replied to gernot on Animesuki and he replied to the reply seen below but I'm reposting it here in case someone would like to join the discussion:
I think you're forgetting that when they've injured Raftela they knew that trainees have joined the rebellion and were destroying the prison. So putting them there would be stupid (unless she was not put into prison and in a place where there no guards which would be stupid for another reason. And if there were guards I wouldn't see a way for Raftela to escape when she could barely stand). Also these guys explicitly said that they wished they've finished her off properly which makes it clear even better (although, one could look at it that now they're regretting they have imprisoned her instead of killing her). Although it would be very convincing explanation if not for these two things. I was arguing with MalakTawus for couple of pages (it started earlier bu in this post I went into more detail) that it would be more wise to imprison her than kill her since she might come in handy in case zombie #1s turn against them. Read last paragraph if you're interested.
Also Raki couldn't have known they've imprisoned her and in order to do that injured her. He could have as well assume that they've tried to kill her but failed. Unless it's Yagi's sloppy writing showing again. I doubt it is the case though. In addition, why would they imprison someone they supposedly didn't need any more and that has become expandable according to Rimuto? That would be a waste of resources and a risk since it looked to me they wanted to kill her. And since Raftela came to them and obeyed their orders to the letter it would be better to not piss her off by making a Swiss cheese out of her.
Been thinking about that, and here's another possiblity. The guards just suck at killing Claymores. Remember Raki already stated they suck at fighting. They are mostly used to bullying the trainees. The don't deal with fullblown Claymores. The org sends other Claymores to do that. So it may not have occured to them that the stabbing was something she might get up from. In short, yeah, they are incomptetent, at least at that.
Actually it's more like their inexperinced at actual fighting. But I was just throwing another theory out their. Gernot's explination does work better, especially the part about needing her to deal with the dead trio.
Only Audrey has a chance to survive if Deneve and co. would arrived. Rachel and Nina wont probably regenerate their limbs because they are offensive types right? Too bad Nina really pissed off Cassandra.
They would eventually lost because they dont have a surprise attack like Clare back then.
Hysteria is far way too strong for Miria even at her awakened speed step, Hysteria was still able to damage Miria.
Anyway, even Deneve group is going to fail because as it stand. Roxanne hasn't even shown her true power. She brushed off Cassandra technique and said it wasn't her style and she didn't need it. That tells you Roxanne is a lot stronger then both of them. Roxanne doesn't need tricks to win. She reminds me of Teresa toying with Priscilla, Irene, Noel, and Sophia.