Tower of God
The results so far are as expected: a duel between fairy tail & FMA. FMA is an exceptional piece of work in which there is a great cast while Fairy Tail main (and only ??) quality is the full cast.
I'll support Beelzebub for it's nomination.
The cast well balanced in terms of comedy and i like the most of them.
I see no nomination for Negima so I nominate it. Akamatsu does a great job in making this really huge number of cast with all of them having a great characterization. Seriously, this is one of Negima's edge, imo.
I will remind you that tomorrow is the last day of voting! I already updated the OP, tomorrow night will make the last check! Don't forget to call for users to make your nominees to the final voting!
Its a hard choice between Bleach and Fairy Tail but I invested more in Bleach so it gets my vote.
Bleach - Cool designs, cool swords. But by name I remember maybe 10 characters. Which tells enough. Mostly meh. I think some characters are there just to look cool.
Fairy Tail - Wide cast if interesting personalities, but somehow I just don't feel them.
Gintama - I'm a bad judge here, I have only seen clips from the anime. But I hear the the cast is the reason why the series is so good, so I bet the characters are good.
Tower of God - Tried to read this. I'll try again sometime maybe.
FMA - Wide cast of interesting characters with their own personalities, and what is more remarkable, everyone had their roles to play in the big picture. My vote goes here.
FMA easily. I've never read another manga where almost every single character is so likeable and so well-developed. And with such a large cast, that's quite a feat. Even the bad guys were somehow likeable! Gintama also has an amazing cast but, to me, just doesn't quite measure up to FMA.
This one is really hard. For once I agree with all nominees. Well I guess FMA should get it but I think it deserves the best completed manga award better. So I'm going to advertise Tower of God too. It's a web comic with great potential. One see that the author has made lots of effort in the plot preparation sometime almost worthy of (let's not be afraid of using the big names :-) Eichiiro Oda.
Anyway, I'm already happy these awards allowed some members to discover it.
I had an hard time to chose among 4 nominations (all but bleach).
Even though I like the captains, Ichigo, the vizards,... there are 3 things preventing me to vote for it: Chad - Ishida - Orihime.
The 3 friends from High school are just "meh" characters.
I already described Orihime in an other thread:
To me, she is just a "meh" character with a very useful ability. She is doubting herself all the time, her main dialog is saying "Ichigo ..." with a worrying face. It's not even that I hate her, It's just that I don't care at all. She is just a clueless loveydovey doll.
Chad is a stereotype: a big heavy fighter with raw strength who doesn't say a lot of things. He is a character designed to be strong. Problem: HE IS FUCKING WEAK
Ishida: He was introducted as an arrogant rival for ichigo. He nearly defeated a captain. At the time, I though he was cool ... Now there is a problem: he is still arrogant BUT HE IS NOW FUCKING WEAK AS WELL.
Those 3 characters were introducted earlier in the story & Kubo doesn't know what to do with them. I really do think that Chad should be dead, Orihime left at home to do the nurse when fighters are coming back & Ishida need a real power up ... I still have hope for Ishida because of his father.
Amon the others, As I had no real preferences, I voted for ToG in order to promote an awesome new work.
So Naruto didn't make to this point. Quite a disappointment, specially when manga like Bleach and Fairy Tail did. But oh well ... since i haven't read Tower of God, i think i am going to nominate FMA, though i have only saw the anime.
The explanations why i am not going to vote for FT and Bleach is the fact that i don't really thing there characters are really that well developed. I just read Bleach till 270's chapters, and one the reasons was because i felt the characters were kinda plain. I mean, i couldn't understand why they acted like they did or what bound did connect some of them. Those moments should had been more "worked" by the author IMO.
Fairy Tail's characters are not bad ... but there's still something missing IMO.
To me, one of the weak point of Naruto is that like in Bleach, some of the characters are put aside. It's Naruto and Naruto and... Naruto again. As a consequence it doesn't really have its place here. Fairy Tail may have some weak points but the balance between the characters is well done and I think it deserve its place among the nominee for this particular award.
Can you guys imagining something like that on Fairy Tail or Bleach? I can't. I mean i keep thinking that a lot of people are more unfair for Naruto, than what they really should be. Imo it's easily way better than Bleach or FT on this category.
The author managed to make some decent, others good, but it's still a small list, at least compared to Naruto.
Kishi created tons of characters but simply couldn't manage them. Fairy Tail is simply much better handled in that area. The author isn't adding too many characters & old ones are not forgotten. Plus, all woman in Naruto are just badly handled. The only thing he did for all those girls is to cast them as nurses.
Finally, in your own example, most characters are just villains who received an explanation before dying. Kishi is now doing fan service for years. Exceptionnal form but behind it ... It's just so easy to introduce new characters, give them awesome superpowers & then just forget about old characters for some time.
Last edited by zelllogan; January 17, 2012 at 10:52 AM.
The only cool characters in Naruto lately were Raikage and Killer Bee (Maybe also Darui) and they were all from Kumogakure. The rest were ALL lame. Seriously.