It is simple! Who is the strongest Geezer? Uses '>' for stronger and '-' for equal, like this:
Whitebeard - Sengoku > Rayleigh - Garp
I was going to use a poll, but I thought the number of options wouldn't be enough.....
Edit: Damn! I posted in wrong place... I'll ask Uriel to move this to the Davy Back Fight.
Last edited by ErosVp; December 18, 2011 at 12:47 PM.
I would say WB is the strongest among them and by some margin, but three others should be more or less equal.
Whitebeard and Roger would lose 'cause they're dead :I Oh snap!
WB is probably the strongest out of all four due to his (former) DF but the other 3 probably are just a smidgen behind WB..and about equal with each other IMO...I gotta see Garp or Rayleigh go all out before the manga ends...or else I'm gonna to be one upset fanboy.
I thought that since Garp used to challenge Roger, people would put Garp equal to Whitebeard or superior to Roger's firstmate.
I think Garp would tie with Rayleigh and both would lose to Sengoku. I have the impression the fleet admiral must be stronger than any other marine (admirals, VA) and Sengoku even had a DF, unlike the other two...
Ehm... as you may recall, Edward, old and sick as he was, was actually canonically stated to be the strongest man in the world by the narrator when he was introduced (similarly to Mihawk, who was stated to be the strongest swordsman).
Anyway, I'd rate them like this (both in their heyday and in old age):
Garp D. Monkey
I think the former Fleet Admiral Sengoku is too underrated... Am I the only one that thinks Sengoku beats Garp and Rayleigh?
I don't think that Sengoku is underrated. He was an Admiral during Roger's time, but Garp should have also been one, but he declined promotion several times. Sengoku and Garp should be at least at the same level or Garp might be even stronger, because we know that he foght on par with Roger several times. So If WB and Roger were practically equal so was Garp. Even though I would say that Roger was stronger, than WB and the third was Garp, than Rayleigh and then Sengoku.
All in all, from what we've been given so far, I see nothing that would indicate that Sengoku are right on par with Garp and/or Rayeligh, let alone superior to them.
I think you missed the point of hoeru's post...
We have seen Sengoku take out Gear 3rd Fuusen luffy and 3's Candle Wall and the Scaffold...
But we also saw him slamming BB's crew with Shockwaves from his Buddist Palm...
Well Fuusen of Luffy that time wasn't infused with haki,naturally hel'll taken that out, Garp could also do that, he is only the one who attack Marco face to face and seen Marco owned, Kizaru didn't owned him like that.. Im not impressed by these shock-waves of Sengoku.. after a seconds, we saw BB's crew standing like nothing happened..