Yeah, I corrected my post.
Yeah, that's solid XD
From the moment I learned that I was the Freeman in the beginning’s pm, and that I understood how this character was actually pretty much helpful to the Mafia, I decided initially to help a little the Mafia (while still confusing them a bit to enjoy myself). The worst Townie a crew could hope for I guess, given Freeman’s “ability”. My suspicious characters list at the end of day 1 was:
_ My Sifu : Expert Steve.
_ Adorien : Bird Catcher Sarah.
_ Farfalla : Psycho Maria.
_ xi0 : Blackbelt Gary.
_ Blai : Tamer Adam.
_ Organizized : Gentleman Jon.
_ Bakahaze : Youngster Jerry.
I soon took Psycho Maria out of the list, because I decided, as the game advanced, that she would be the late Boss in my character’s background story. And also, well, there was no way I’d vote for her. And...
I never really knew what to think of Gentleman Jon, except that he made sense and was actually acting really wise in the next day phases, so I kinda stopped doubting him in the process, especially after I came out as the Freeman.
If Tamer Adam did not write: “I'm starting to think that Tai is the type of mafia player we all want to be: Brilliant.”, which seemed like a cocky taunt by someone who understood my game to me, I would have stopped suspecting him too.
About Gary & Sifu : 99,99% sure that they were Mafia. I couldn’t say anything against my Sifu though. And I wanted to see how Gary’s analytical skills would move the flow of the game. If I had any doubt about you, your “Occam’s razor” explanation was the best way to confirm my suspicions. Anyway, you two made the whole game very interesting to follow, so thank you very much!
After her: “Tai is okay for now, I guess.”, I had also no more doubt about Bird Catcher Sarah either.
We had really kind Mafia players here.
My stubbornness to keep my character as I created him, an offspring of Team Rocket (raised by his Sifu and the late Boss) who was nowadays taking care of his own ‘malevolent’ business by himself, but who was still thankful to his ex-peers, cost me the ability to be read properly from the moment I decided to also try to help the Townies. At that time, the doubt that I expressed about Youngster Jerry was true, and I hoped that the change in my tone would plead my cause.
I felt quite neutral for a first play in the end, and given my character. That explains why I was so confusing to everyone. I was not trying to save my hide, as I did not care to win (and I made it pretty clear with Tai's words & behaviour I think). But I really was trying to give the Townies a boost of spirit when I stated that I was the freeman, even if it was a gamble that could very well precipitate their downfall. I also was hoping that the inconsistencies would be correctly analysed by the Townies in my post :
Concerning the game in itself, I was a bit disappointed to read so many posts relating to earlier games’ experiences/behaviours, as I thought we would play a Mafia Game and not a Mafia Games. It kinda spoiled the fun for me, as it made me feel as an outsider (while my character’s specificities were already enough for that purpose to my taste) to your game. As I already wrote earlier, these were my misconceptions of course, so there is not a shred of blame against anyone except myself, in my words. I hope the way I played makes more sense to you all now, and I apologize in front of the Townies who were really trying to win.
I want to thank Evil3ye for creating/managing all of that, and for allowing me to play, as well as all of you.
I deeply regret not going with Zel T.T I posted those images going to vote for Baka, and then I saw Gary's post and got full of questions. His answers to my questions didn't make sense and I just left it. I didn't suspect DD 'cause I missed Zel's posts about being the bomb (they were kinda confusing) and when he came back to talk about it, I just decided to check how it would go and work on the bomb later, considering that we would have the sickly so the game wouldn't end. Now I regret not following Orgz's with Adi's revelation and not doing what he did: folllowing Zel T.T Then we'd have a tie and Blai could use his vote... ARGH
Teubier was dragonair! Best Pokemon out of the bunch!
Well played mafiosos~ DD is the shit! He can completely fuck up a game for the better or for the worst
I found it very interesting when the Freeman revealed his role, as we never had this before. I was curious how the Townie as well as the Mafia side will react to that. At first I thought it was a big mistake as he'll become instantly mafia's target from now on. Then again they might fear he's the bomb and leave him all alone. I think after the first few hours though, or a day maximum nobody doubted him anymore and that created the opportunity for the doctor to target him. The freeman in his role could have become a second bulletproof as long as the doctor would be alive, which could give the Townie side an edge for a while.
Well, unfortunately this game's sane doctor was obessed of being the insane one, which made his role utterly useless, because he was surprisingly successful with targeting the mafia members. However, after night 3 latest he should have realized what his role in this game actually is.
I thought that this role could become a really powerful asset for the Townies, if only played right and by the right player, which wasn't the case for both criterions this time around.
Dammit i knew i should have gone with Gary . This is all Albert 's fault for pissing me off on the 1st day and making my suspicion on Gary shift to him
We figured out Maria had a Shellder rather early on.
Tai revealing he was a Freeman was interesting. I had wanted to rob him earlier than we did, but we have feared that he might have been the bomb in reality and decided against it.
Not robbing Jerry ended up being invaluable to us. I was under the impression that there were two detectives, but because there was only one I was still able to lie and say it was me since Tod was out. Obviously I knew who was Team Rocket and who wasn't, thus I was able to recruit Townies to my cause when they doubted me. Though I'm still unsure why Farfalla said multiple times that my answers to her questions made no sense
Anyways, good game...inactives on your side really hurt you guys though.
You were what?