my strentgh list.
1 luffy well he just is. but dont make a mistake luffy was never this all time monster. his willpower is above any1 in the manga and he just cant except to lose. the enemies he defeated were several times stronger than him and yes he still managed it but not before coming close to death . his exact lvl of ability was clear in marineford. with his haki (all 3 types) he edges the others. 1 factor he is monster lvl is his enourmous luck.
= zoro i dont think zoro and lufy has to much difference in strentgh. the only downsize in which he seems not so is because luffy always tries to punch above his weight where as zoro always fought with opponents he needs achivable adjustments. after the lessons he received from mihawk his exact ability might be more clear for every1.has also 2 types of haki confirmed. (though he might also have haushouki too. though this just a hunch)
3 sanji he is not so far behind than luffy or zoro. his policy of leg usage is not a downsize and i dont think it makes much of a difference.with the improved diable jumble and his hell enhanced legs he can adapt to any situaition. the only problem seems to be his haki and how effectively he can use it.
4 franky his versatile arsenal and the fact that he can reconstruct himself when almost dead shows he does have above average stamina and endurance. his new remodeling is also first class.
5 robin her DF is one of the best paramecia there is. maybe the exception of earthquake one WB had. but her own strength is not so great. but beacuse of her superior intelect she made it a plus rather than a weakness.
6 chopper by managing to transform 6 times and having control over monster point he can easily take care of himslef in almost all situiations.
=brook new found blade coating his superior speed and near immortality makes him component. but his swordsmanship pales in light of zoro. he makes up for it with his magical music.
7 nami her sorcery climatact is something tobe feared. but a life that made her runaway from the age of 8 left her with a very keen survival instinct she cant just forget. she wont be put down as easily as she was before but not exactly some1 she can go head to head with elites of the NW.
=usopp same as nami mostly though his cowardice is mostly a personality issue than actual events. you cant become a new person no matter how much you train. his redeeming quality is that he seems to be effectively damage foes regardles of range.
the fight starts 1 page early.squibble starts when tashigi starts speaking like kuina.and in loguetown zoro didnt run away from the squibble either dragon's storm make it stop. he starts running away from then on as i have explained and u mentioned.
yes there r points like that specially the return of usopp and more so when he offered his life for lufy. about the responsibilities of the first mate, isnt just done by him though every single 1 of them took command at some point. (nami more so since she has more brains.) but what i said is unless oda says he is the first mate it wont be canon and his job on the ship will be the lookout and fighter(swordsman). think of it like this; when an actor plays extraordinarily well and is said to be oscar worthy doesnt mean a thing unless said actor actually wins that oscar.Also;
you can say this is usopp rambling but it can inadvertently means the ship doesnt actually have a first mate.
though this isnt the thread to discuss this. so sry every1.
How about this order of strength:
Anyone who puts Nami above Usopp in strength needs to be slapped. Nami in my opinion needs way more one on one battles before anyone can say otherwise. She's the type who can really get knocked out by strong opponents in one hit. Her and Robin have barely had any battles so I'd like to see more but as it has been shown currently he is definitely higher than Nami. She's the only crew member that I need to see in a true hard fight. The sad thing is Usopp built the foundation of the current weapon she uses today.
I thought it was stated that Usopp would be the weakest, ergo, below Nami.
The way i see it (i am counting Jinbe already) is this:
Zoro - Sanji - Jinbe
Robin - Franky - Brook
Chopper - Usopp - Nami
Nice to see that someone is already counting Jinbe, but how would you account if the SH add another member before he officially joins?
I still think that Zoro, Sanji and Jinbe would be at the same level approximately while Luffy is above them. It depends on how strong the other new nakama is, personally i do not want that a new nakama is weaker than pre-TS Luffy anymore. They are soon going to attack Yonkou so that would be counterproductive.
Maybe something like this:
Zoro - Sanji - Jinbe
Robin - New Nakama (my unlikely wish would be Bonney)
Franky - Brook
Chopper - Usopp - Nami
well i am not sure jinbei will be a nakama as we think. he is a man who takes his responsibilities very seriously. i dont think he will dissolve the sun pirates. i think he will be more like an ally under the banner of SH pirates like he was doing before. most likely with WB though. just as a feeling.
I think everyone is feeding around the bush when it come to this list. Luffy is far beyond the monster category. He poses Gomu Devil Fruit, All 3 Haki's, and what you guy call luck may actual be the Will of D. It has been mentioned by characters far more powerful than Luffy and the world government fears it. One thing made it clear in the Fisher-man Island arc, when the mermaid princess awakened or gained control of her power of Poseidon, that Luffy is Joy Boy. Luffy may have another power besides Haki that he has yet to realize. So my list goes as followed
0. Jinbe ( his recruitment may be the same as his alliance with White Beards. Allies but not apart of the crew. Same goes for Law, and Kid.)
3.S.A.D. (my guess as the new member of the Straw Hat crew or at-least weapon)
4.Franky (I think we have yet to see what else he has. Also since he knows Dr. Vegapunk's tech he can be is bumped up to monstrous class)
5. Chopper ( He was already a monster he just lack control but now after the gap he clearly has more control over his yeti form. Also his use in medicine and how he uses them in fights makes him a contender.)
6. Brook (his use in the Yami Yami fruit makes him near immortal, tangible like a ghost, and ability to manipulate his enemy with music. *its almost like gen jutsu)
None they have improved over the gap that no Straw Hats are weak anymore.
S.A.D. is interesting to say the least.
well i can somehow see Law(though not exactly sure of it.) kidd isnt some1 lufy will enter in alliance since he harms civilians.
To all those who still speak of Jinbe´s responsibilities and him becoming an ally:
I do not know how Oda could have made it more obvious that Jinbe is going to join in the future^^