Basically if you were on a pirate crew... who would you want as your captain and why...
Example: I'd want Luffy as my captain. Because he seems the most proned to get into the most exciting of adventures with. You would never get bored with him, maybe a little pissed off or scared shitless, but the fun would be recurring far too much...
My personal choice.
Sadi-Chan: because I am also a masochist... and we'd be great together.
Whitebeard and Red-haired seems to be some nice guys, I wouldn't mind be under their command.
Luffy for the same reasons. Too much fun with Luffy - it's never a dull moment with him around. Plus, he's a good guy, albeit an idiot, so there's the moralistic reason for wanting him as cap.
I wouldn't mind having Zoro as my captain either, with the way he seeks to improve himself and his take-no-shit attitude.
I will side with Shanks, he chills most of the time, is traveling to the most beautiful islands and when it comes to action I could die happily having lived with such awesome nakama. XD
edit: There's an edit button.
Last edited by Schabrak; April 30, 2012 at 09:18 PM.
I've also changed my mind...
My captain would be Kaku... because no matter how serious things got, I could always laugh at his SQUARED-NESS
I don't have one ideal Captain, but my choices are Luffy, Garp, Shanks, Whitebeard and Dragon.
Every one of them are interestin in their own way. Some of them are funny, some are more serious, but all are strong-willed and the jouney with them will be full of epic moments.
Yeah definitely Luffy . He's just too funny and awesome at the same time . But i wouldn't mind Zoro as my captain either , he's also cool though knowing his sense of direction ... many adventure would await me
Actually i would love to be part of the SH's ...my dream is to be the 11th nakama of the SH's
I'd like to be a captain myself. but if I had to train under someone,than I'd say Roger,WB,or shanks. they are strong and can protect me
i want luffy to be my captain..because he have the heart of a real captain..^_^
Shanks, Luffy and Dragon one of those. I think in Shanks' and Luffy's crew it'd be very funny and you would have a lot of good and hard fights.
And to be a part of the revolutionaries would be also awesome. Dragon as your leader and to be a part of a big army and fight against the world government, that would be pretty fun.
All of your guys choices as captains kind of suck. My number 1 choice would be Captain Kid. He would be the ideal image of a pirate captain. In his crew, you would constantly challenge those that are stronger than you, pilvage anything you like and Kid would have enough brains to know how to lead.
If I didn't want to join a so gong-ho pirate crew, my 2nd choice would be Buggy's crew. This would be a crew where we steal just to party. Just pure fun and entertainment.
Luffy would be kind of be my last choice as a captain. Luffy isn't really smart enough to warrant control over his crew. Anyone that follows him is due to his nature and strength. The strawhats are less a pirate group but more 9 friends that sail together and have equal voice in the crew.
People like shanks and whitebeard are no longer mere pirate captains but emperors that have territory. They move away from a pirate crew and towards an organized fleet that defends its waters from external attack. Very stagnant.
Dragon is the worst of your guys choice as captain. He is more a leader of an organization that plans to overthrow the world. Unless I believe the world is corrupted and follow the hope of change that Dragon might unleash. I have no reason to join his group.
I'd choose Shanks over Luffy... All because I'd like to eat meat even once. I could stop on the alcohol, since I'm not drinking that much anyways, but if one took my meat it would be unforgivable!!!!
I also wouldn't personally join luffy's crew because of his amazing characteristic as a respected captain that knows how to lead but would want him as the ultimate best friend. Noway joining Luffy's crew would be boring, it would be probably the most fun.
While Kid might be immoral in the sense that he is highly bloodthirsty and pursues challenges and makes sure anyone that challenges him to know of his power, such goals make him the ideal captain. Just like luffy's goal to go on the ultimate adventure or Buggy's goal for more and more treasure. Haveing a goal is what makes a captain enticing. This is how the Yonkou who have already achieved the pinnacle of strength and power are stagnant because they aren't chasing after anything.