I just heard Chrollo's character song. Since they did a special ending they should have used this as the opening
---------- Post added at 07:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:36 PM ----------
i watched episode 51 this morning and since then I couldn't stop thinking about it: especially the requiem sequences, the indoor fishes and its victims, Kuroro's voice....which is odd because this part in the manga was just ok to me. It never stood out to me (not a fan of Kuroro). I guess this is the ultimate impact the anime can do: elevate a scene with the beautifully directed sequences that haunts you.
Agree that the repeated prophecy is INFECTIOUS and setup a mythical, ominous, fateful mood. I LOVE it! The way Madhouse did with the elevator scene and others somehow, finally ....convinced me of Kuroro's charisma...maybe it was his voice and and that absolute confidence coming from a director (conductor) type who got the execution the way exactly he wanted it (again this is coming from a fan who never cared for this character).
The omission completely went over my head and in hindsight they aren't that important to me (omission isn't the same as changing & ruining characters and themes with addition of cheesy sappy filler like 1999 did). This episode has a tight storytelling and very smooth pacing, and is thematically focused. In addition the prophecy and requiem is drawn out to draw you in (instead of shortening them in favor of MORE trash talking/punching between mafia guys I don't give an f for just for the sake of 'include everything'). The way Madhouse interpret this part is elegant, simpler (than the manga) but equally if not more powerful.
I can't wait to rewatch it again soon.
Last edited by chei; October 14, 2012 at 08:07 PM.
Not related to this episode really, but I adore Chrollo and Machi's character songs.
But I wouldn't be opposed if they used an instrumental version of his character song during upcoming events, like they did with Killua's.
episode 51 for 2011 was slightly better than 1999, but not by much. Don't know why you so trill, other than it being newer.
Last edited by vansonbee; October 14, 2012 at 10:11 PM.
Besides not many manga, get a second anime retelling the story from the beginning, not even the popular ones.
I think Chei enjoyed this episode, because he thought it was great (its as simple as that), I did too. I don't see how thats foolish.
Last edited by leiatte; October 14, 2012 at 11:51 PM.
Where do you guys think the next ep will end? I've been thinking it could end with the big fight between you know who. perhaps closing on the Ten Godfathers video at the auction about capturing the Troupe members, sorta leaving the viewer going "what happened in the fight? are the Zoldycks and Spiders all dead?"
Last edited by TheAmericandream; October 15, 2012 at 12:31 AM.
I don't see much of a problem with them taking out the part where he's beaten up. Interesting to think Kurapika may have let his boss get punched on purpose because he hates him. But with how clearly it's been stated that Kurapika's just using him and with that whole eye business, I don't think it needs much inferring.
I wanted Light to get punched just for the sake of Light getting punched. I really don't care WHY he gets punched.
I do miss seeing the stuff they omitted. I always do. No matter how "trivial" the scenes are in the manga they just add to the fun. Take for instance the hobo Chrollo hired. Neither Madhouse nor Nippon had him. Now what they did instead was fine, it got us from point A to point B. But still, there's just something great about Chrollo getting a hobo to get him into the auction. The best part about it is that Togashi does NOT explain anything about it except that the guy is a hobo.
Where did he find the hobo? What did he pay him? Who is this hobo? What is the hobo REALLY planning? So many questions. Lol.
But then there's other stuff that Kurapika's missing analysis. Sure he was basically saying that Zoldycks > everyone else. Yet more importantly it shows Kurapika is able to discern that they are stronger by just their mere presence.
Yet is it just me or does it sometimes seem like when Nippon DOES follow the manga that Madhouse decides to change it up?
Take Phinx pose in the manga and Nippon. They are the same.
It's different in Madhouse's version.
Sometimes I wonder if Madhouse is trying to avoid looking like Nippon's version even if it means avoiding looking like the manga.
The one major advantage I would say Madhouse has...is that aside from the OVAs and the next episode this is was the big final act for the Nippon tv series.
Whereas with Madhouse we're not even half way there. Even with the OVAs I don't think it really ever beyond the quality of the requiem.
Well maybe the immediate OVA. But Greed Island was a definite drop in quality. Hopefully this time Greed Island will look BETTER than Yorknew.
But anywho I would say overall both requiem versions are basically equal to another and slightly below the manga.
But Chrollo vs Zoldycks is where it's at. This was one of the best animated fights from Nippon. Some might consider it THE best fight despite how short it is.
Though while I think it's rather impressive for the first half it's the second half that gets a bit shaky. I'm rather hoping Madhouse can stay strong throughout
the whole fight. Though I'm sure they can.
In a way, is true.It does make some sense.But not all mafia are friendly with each other...
Kurapika definitely was one of the factor.
After thinking through about it (in a more logical way), considering that Senritsu was tired (due to accompanying neon shopping) and that she was worry for Kurapika,this may have put her in a bad condition. With her ability,she was able to detect that the worm was beneath them, knew that Squala was lying and also possess superhuman hearing! She could have easily detected that Neon was lying. But as nen ability can be affected by both mental and physical stress, she may be in no shape to efficiently use her ability. As a result, she was completely caught off-guard,wasn't alert enough and talking to Basho may have distracted her from noticing any changes in Neon's heartbeat. I do believe that Neon isn't a perfect liar (unless she taking drugs or something) and her heartbeat would have reveal her lies.Just that senritsu wasn't able to detect it due to the given circumstances.
Last edited by Akia999; October 15, 2012 at 06:41 AM.
2011's episode 51 blew 1999's version away with its beauty and elegance. For me there's sadness and a poetic quality from the 2011's whilst the 99's requiem felt more of just a massacre. Comparison is not allowed here so that's that.
Last edited by chei; October 15, 2012 at 09:08 AM.
But, I've only noticed that often happening in terms of the camera angles, poses, and backdrops they use. I doubt things like removing Light getting beaten up was because Nippon included it.
I know what you mean about them removing the fun tidbits. I'm hoping they'll tone it down by the later arcs. Especially the ant arc; MH would have nothing to compare to aside from the manga.
On a fun note, I had a dream last night where "those two" actually did something. It creeped me out.
Last edited by Riruru; October 15, 2012 at 09:50 AM.
LOL There's so much irony in this episode. The legit fortuneteller was inspired by a fake one. The girl speaks of how good fortunes will inspire people to work hard, yet she only predicts bad ones. She also sounds like she cares more about the living but in reality all she does is collect dead things. Oh wow just wow, yoshihiro Togashi is such a troll lol.