Who is the strongest non top tier MSer? I guess first we have to define what is 'not top tier'. I will define it as not including anyone who can be recognized at the national level. For example it is said that everyone on Rikkidai is considered 'national (Tezuka) class player' so every one of those guys is automatically out of discussion, even though it really doesn't feel like it. This list can include national-level double team players while playing single, i.e. Golden Pair would surely be considered not top tier if they played singles. Gin Ishida is considered the #1 power player in MS, so he'd be out too. Same with WoK, and roughly anyone on par with them. Kite seems to be recognized nationally (i.e. Rikkidai guys know about him) so he's out too. Actually if you're the best player in your school, you're probably out unless your school really sucks.
For the sake of discussion let's not include Kabaji because he'd almost certainly be #1 on this list.
For POT, I'll vote for Kaidoh, Hirakoba, Otori, Inui, and Krauser.
Kaidoh has great stamina, and two kinds of different snake type shots with the same motion. He even has a devil form that he can use, and is on par with devil form Kirihara.
Hirakoba gave Fuji trouble and that's about as good as you can expect any non top tier character ever do against Fuji. Granted it was a double but it's still impressive.
Krauser's southern cross almost knocked out Kirihara and seems to be the best power player that's not at a national level. I don't see Kawamura doing that in one move at least, even though in theory he become the best power player after defeating Gin. I tend to think Kawamura's victory is more like divine intervention as opposed to his power.
Otori would basically be Ochi jr. His serve is very hard to return, and sure he has almost nothing else, but if you don't lose your serve you can't possibly lose. At the non top tier I don't see most people have a shot at returning that serve.
Inui's serve is slightly weaker than Otori, but he got data tennis for backup, and again at his level his serve would eat up most equivalent level characters alive so he wouldn't even need anything else.
For NPOT, I'll go with Momoshiro, because he has BJK, which is a top tier move that your usual non-chosen ones have no chance of ever learning.
Last edited by Phantron; October 25, 2012 at 05:36 PM.
There you have our tiers. For now, Yagyuu is the best "not top tier" player... but you can still discuss there.
That being said, I'm not sure how many practical applications there are of this.
Marui's defense is pretty floored. You just have to lob the shrimp.
I don't think Marui/Jackal are National Level Singles players.
---------- Post added at 02:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:47 AM ----------
Also, why is Inui in this list?
Inui destroys everybody you listed.
He is top tier where Yanagi is.
Especially after he beat the guy who destroyed Yanagi.
---------- Post added at 02:50 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:48 AM ----------
Inui and Yanagi would be on Kite's level.
They have ability and technique to take on most players.
Inui is definetely going to beat Gin. Inui doesn't belong on this list.
If you want to discuss who belongs on which tier come to the tier thread.