i think projectiles r a little different thant the air. 1 is at least touching the user the other may or may not touch the user as the attack commences. about rayleigh scene i think it was more like the return force from the animal more than rayleigh beaming haki. we also have vergo from the current arc who apperently is a monster in BH, fighting close combat not ranged. even law "cut" him when he was near him and not from afar. these give me belief that BH cant be imbued to air.
If you come up with the TV show esp. Episode 516 as reason now, I'll answer with: "The anime has misinterpreted attacks regularly and still does. The last time I recall was when Toei's animators made Sanji heat up two legs for Diable Jambe instead of one in episode 555." :P
there is one thing that we are overlooking is technique itself, first how does the air suppose to cut things anyway, if we look in to mechanics of technique one could argue that basic of the air slash technique is usage of haki
* The serious ones
* The joke ones
Those above clearly belong to the joke type. I know that we have seen super floating wood later which I rather see as an homage from Oda to his SBS fans. On the contrary, the fact that Luffy can be hit by his friends contradicts so many things with regards to devil fruit than you can't really take it seriously.
As for the bar scene, I would agree with MiyamotoMusashi. I had always problem with the fact that Logia can have a flesh form or not. I remember there was a huge debate on that aspect one day. Oda has never been clear on this aspect. If there is this bar scene which points to the flesh theory, there is also Ace having difficulty to make a hat which suggest the contrary.
Anyway, let's say that Logia have a flesh state since it is the most accepted one, can they be in a flesh state other than in their human form ? To me that is clearly impossible. Since Monet is in a snow monster form she is therefore in her element state. Then there is no question whether Zoro used haki or not.
Also during the war, the admirals have defended the platform against Whitebeard quake waves. There is clearly no other explanation than haki for that. So it is possible to make a bubble of Armament haki in the air around you. Then why would it be impossible to imbue it into a air slash ?
---------- Post added at 10:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:34 AM ----------
also why r we omitting tashigi haki? she is using haki in that scene. otherwise monet will just leaves her as she has done before. so i must have to say i am not so sure zoro did anything other than a slash but tashigi's haki made it possible for him to cut. i will also say the cut would have been much deeper if it were zoro. i hypotize his haki is much stronger than tashigi's.
about the bubble scene the admirals created there is some sort of discrepancy. the 1st scene seems they have a giant sphere in which they protected the execution platform. on the other scene it seems like they r touching it. i will say the 1st airview scene may be a mistake and consider they touch the water as in close-up and circulating their haki through it. but i seriosly would like an explanation about haki before long these suppositions makes ppls head spin....
Last edited by cearon; December 04, 2012 at 09:55 AM.
Well, I don't know about the possibility of ibuduing CoA Haki in air. I think we should wait for the clearer confirmation from the manga. But if we talk about what move Zoro used on Monet to wound her face... Well, when I was first reading a manga, I just thought that he used some small piece of stone or ice, imbuded it with CoA and threw it in Monet.
I thought it looked fairly obvious that Zoro could imbue his slashes with haki, due to the damage on Monet's cheek that didn't recover. We saw evidence of airborn haki doing damage to physical objects back when Shanks boarded Whitebeard's ship. It may be a special skill that is linked with haoshoku, and I'm of the opinion that Zoro has it.