I agree with you both and this is the best match up you have made, Kiki. Thanks

.
Even if August can't duplicate Magic Tools, he is extremely strong and versatile with his own mastery, Eileen's rival.
Even if Erza is a hard counter for August, she needs her PoF to stand a victory as I still can't think causal 100YQ Erza has enhance enough since a year to be on par with climax PoF Erza (the one who fought Eileen).
But yes, she's Erza and is a monster tank, so, as for now, I am about 55%/45% in August's favor. If Erza was in a battle configuration like "Erza vs August vs Jellal", it should be perfect as, with Jellal's fallen, she could enter her PoF to protect his life and made a finisher.
My vote is for August, but I still wait and see. I can possibly change my vote, just like Zelefomavis

.