Cleaned 2 pages of 343 (including cover) - want some feedback

[Xrono]

ok, i tried to do as high a quality clean as i could possibly do, which takes a loooong time, so i only have two pages. however, i would like some input regarding the quality of my cleans, and what i might could do better.




corrected chapter number in title ~ttx

 

[kyubisharingan]

Re: Cleaned 2 pages of 243 (including cover) - want some feedback

pretty good^^...but, you should try the MH academy for some great tutorials on cleaning. i could also give advise cuz im a cleaner^^you diffinately need to redraw somethings, also fix the boaders/panels for a crisp look!

 

[Predator]

I must say that it's a pretty good work ..... According to the list of ratings it's a very good MQ clean. It still isn't entirely black, gray and while. There are some spots on the white parts, and the little images are a bit flushed, but otherwise it is a very good work.

.... By what you're saying, I can see that you're starting to see, how much effort a real HQ clean takes.

 

[venicia777]

.... By what you're saying, I can see that you're starting to see, how much effort a real HQ clean takes.

I wouldnt have put it better myself. Now you see why my group struggles to release One Piece HQ's- much worse than doing Naruto.

And i agree-- it is good for MQ. But pretty close to HQ-- very close indeed.